Mario's Natural Roman Pizza & Pasta Restaurant

We were surprised how good the pizza is! It was our first time there, and we ordered a "stuffed" pizza (which means it has another crust on top, more sauce, and more cheese, so it's double the thickness of a regular pizza for only $4 more!) The large we ordered was about 15 pounds- I kid you not! True Chicago-style (from a native Chicagoan)! Authentic crispy-chewy Italian-bread crust. Delicious sauce, tons of cheese. Atmosphere is nothing special, and service was fine. But you'll love the pizza. Go with the "stuffed" option - you won't be sorry

Great food. Reasonable prices. Service was amazing eventhough they were rather busy. Definitely need too check this out

Nice sit down restaurant... Family Owned come in and tell Grandma Helloooo.... Great Food...

Mario. You da man. The chicken parm was gigantic and tasted delicious. I took one look, and didn’t know if I had what it took to finish the whole plate. But I summoned my inner strengths, went to work, and bite by bite, I conquered the chicken parm.
My friend got the Pesto Penne. Direct quote: “sh*t slaps”.

These meals are solely responsible for me winning the triathlon national championship in Milwaukee this weekend.

Mario - forever in our hearts. Much love from Boulder, Colorado.

This place has the best pizza & the garlic bread is out of this world! Go here or order out when you are in the mood real Sicilian pizza or on Friday they have a knockout fish fry. Can’t beat the price either!

I am never disappointed with the food here. If you are hungry, this is the place to go. I always have leftovers. The servers were prompt and friendly. I have been coming here for 20+ years, and it is as good as it has ever been. Great prices too. I would give it 6 stars if I could.

What a great experience. The food was awesome & the service was great. Christie, our waitress, has an unbelievable personality. You will fall in with her. And Char, the owner, is the best. You need to go there! Try the fish fry & the sugar puffs or whatever they’re called are delicious.

We give Mario’s five stars because of their huge portions of fantastic food at great prices. We have ordered many different meals which are all served with fresh baked bread and have never been disappointed. Their pizza and garlic bread are the best we have ever had. Service is always friendly and the restaurant has a great atmosphere.

I will give 5 stars, because the food is usually very good. Nice portions. Always enough for leftovers. Yesterday however I was a bit disappointed in the food and the service. I waited 4 minutes before someone even realized I was there to get my food. I could see an employee just sitting on their phone. I even called the store to get someone's attention and that didn't even get them to notice. Finally someone got bored from talking and saw us there.
As far as the food, we ordered the chicken bacon ranch sandwiches, one had no bacon and neither of them had ranch or a pickle. It has been awhile so maybe it doesn't come with a pickle anymore. Food was great besides those small details.

This has been a great takeout place this year with the drive thru window and good food. I've been getting the Mario's Feast which is plenty of food for several meals. My wife has enjoyed the fish fry. Their tomato sauces are sweet (which I like). The garlic bread that comes with the meals reminds me a lot of the garlic bread I loved at Mama Mia's before our local one closed.
As long time residents of Mukwonago, we had stopped going to the restaurant after very slow service when dining in, but our experiences the last few years have established Mario's as one of our favorite local restaurants.

fast friendly service. Our first time here.. if we lived closer it would be a regular place! Pizza was fantastic, fresh toppings. The super cheese sticks were different spin on mozzarella sticks in the best way possible.

What a nice hidden little gem in the end of a strip mall. Nice size screen to watch the Packer game. Service was very prompt. The garlic bread is huge and yummy and the pizza is amazing. We will definitely be returning.

Their garlic bread and cheese alfredo ravioli are outstanding. Both remind me of Mama Mia's in Brookfield. So good. Onoy downsides are trying to get through on the phone to place an order and I wish their menu had nutritional info on it.

We love Mario's! Tonight we had Pizza, Chicken Parmesan, and Garlic Bread. Called in the order for pick up, it was ready on time and as always everything was amazing!

I'm 74 and have patronized many Italian restaurants. Char, the owner has kept her original Italian receipts the same over the years... and thankfully so! Her dinners and pizzas are simply amazing...I cannot begin to think of a better place to PATRONIZE {or take out in these times}! BTW...I JUST FINISHED OFF THE BETTER PART OF HER WONDERFUL MENU ITEM CALLED THE ITALIAN FEAST. Heavenly!

I've been cooking for 22 years ... And this place is wayyy under rated and totally flew under my radar! The deep dish pizza was killer and the staff super friendly and fun. Thank you! We will be back soon!

Best fish fry around. Tarter sauce is delicious. Garlic bread is incredible. Lasagna is supreme. Quite frankly I'm surprised they're not packed all the time

We had Marios cater a recent event for 40 people and everything was superb! My guests gave rave reviews of the scrumptious food, the variety of the menu and the quantity! Char was so easy to work with and delighted with everything! We definitely will be ordering from Marios again. Thanks so much and great job!

The best pizza around! Quick and delicious! The pizza is always ready when they say. There are other pizza restaurants in the area where you can wait a long time for a ok pie. Mario’s is the best in the area hands down!

mario’s always has great food for price. you basically always take a meal or two home in leftovers. their pizza and garlic bread are great.