Lake Geneva Pie Co

Excellent pie and service everytime. Never had any issues. A must try.

Delicious. We had raspberry pie, raspberry orange muffin, chipotle cheese quiche and oatmeal cookie. The quiche and baked items were nice and moist.

You can tell it’s a “mom and pop shop” local favorite. All you need is a slice of pie, a cold glass of milk, and a bit of country music to give you a lil bit of that ol’ American country morning. Thank you to Lake Geneva Pie Co for giving us a great wake up to celebrate a special day!

Wonderful friendly staff, amazing assortment of pies to choose from, soups and quiches also available, delicious as they look! A must stop if you are in the area! Best chocolate cream pie I ever had!

An amazing hidden jewel in beautiful Lake Geneva. Super friendly, family run, everything made from scratch, and their award winning pies absolutely live up to the hype. They must make hundreds of pies everyday. The line is usually out the door. So if you want to get your favorite pie come early, or order ahead.

Bought the strawberry and rhubarb pie. The crust was just right, the filling was amazing just the right amount of sweetness.

Chicken pot pie is what we come for. The crust is so flaky and fresh. The fruit pies have always been a favorite for the holidays as well.

Delicious pies. Our servers were a couple of elderys and couldn't be better, there were so sweet and kind. Definitely we'll comeback.

We tried the cherry crumb and blackberry raspberry, and both were AMAZING! We ended up buying the apple crumb as the other two were just a bit too tart for our taste. The apple crumb is probably the best pie I’ve had.

Stopped in for a local lunch choice, ended up picking up dinner for later! Fresh and delicious. Interesting that you can’t request a sandwich but choose from what is premade. Not to worry, found a yummy one. The best was the cherry crumb pie. I quess I was too hungry, all that was left for photos!

We had to get lunch AND dessert from here, and it was so hard to choose. Delicious pot pies, quiches, and a huge variety of pies. Something for every meal of the day!

I called at 11:00 asking for a banana cream pie and was informed they had none. However, they indicated they would bake one and have it ready by 3:00. I ordered two and arrived an hour early and found the pies ready to go ( I picked up a key lime pie in addition). Without a doubt, it was the best banana cream pie I have tasted. Combined with the terrific service, this is a marvelous shop. My first visit, but I will be back soon.

Had carmel cappacino and a cup of beef barley soup. Delicious! We also took home a strawberry/rhubarb pie for desert after dinner that night! Awesome pies!!

Super cute shop! We got some lobster bisque which was perfect for dinner and cherry pie for dessert. The crust is phenomenal! I cannot wait to try the quiche in the morning.

Key Lime Pie was delicious. We also purchased a frozen Chicken Pot Pie to bring home for dinner. It baked up beautifully and tasty amazing. Prices are not posted on items which made it a little hard to plan on how much to buy.

My wife and mother in law love this store. Every year we visit Lake Geneva. Last day always stop at pie co. Love the pies and quiche.

Every year we get out clients/friends pies from here for their Thanksgiving table. They are a big hit as everyone loves them. Working with Jennifer and her family on such a big order is super easy. Lake Geneva Pie Company is the best!!!

Everything that I have bought is delicious and fresh. Quality ingredients used.

We loved the pie at Lake Geneva Pie Company. They have so many options. I went with peach/blueberry crumble and wife had quiche and both were great. Excellent service and reputation. They also offer other savory pies and lots of fruit ones. Drinks available and muffins and cookies and sandwiches.

Some of the best quiche I have ever had! I got a slice of pie to go, but decided to take a taste before leaving. It was so good I ate it all right then! I was so sad they were closed on Easter. I was going back for seconds. Definitely will be returning on my next trip to LG.