Fredrick's Supper Club

I was absolutely impressed with the food and
Service. The wait staff was impeccable and very efficient they kept waters full and cleaned away plates. The food came out fast for a Saturday night. I thought the food was exquisite we had the Ribeye cooked to perfection and seafood Alfredo. My friend had the Diablo pasta and was so in awe with the flavor. We'll be back.

Went with a group of four and can say we successfully tried a wide selection of the menu. Everything was amazing from beginning to end. The breaded mushrooms and meat sweats prime rib were the clear winners as was the grasshopper to top it off. Clearly there is a passion for making great food out of that kitchen. Never have I had not only a 2 lb prime rib but one that was well seasoned all the way thru. Cannot recommend this place highly enough.

A fantastic gem that embodies all things ✨supper club✨ in Wisconsin! Worth a road trip here, our HOG group 2.5 hour dinner ride was worth it. A little pricey, but words cannot describe the 4lb slab of prime rib ($95).... All the sides are fantastic and my martini was pretty damn good, also. Have to say the lemon cheesecake was the best, fluffiest light and lemony-est I've ever had... 🌟✨🌟

The pork chop is an excellent choice, which is not your mom's. It has a sweet flavor to it (warning to those who have sugar issues), and it's nice and thick, and moist. The mac and cheese was dry and a bit crusty around the edge. My opinion is that it could be made creamy and a bit more snappy with the taste buds.

This was our first visit but would go back in a 💓 heartbeat. Bourbon old fashioned drinks are good ( Four Roses Bourbon 8$). Had the specials. I had prime rib and lobster tail. Wife had ribeye and scallops. They were both perfect. About $54 each but worth it. Ordered onion rings to go with the meal and got a wall of rings. Delicious. Bread and chili pepper butter on the table. Don't miss this underrated, u assuming supper club.

If you’re looking for a good ambiance, extraordinary service, and amazing food, you’ve found your place! Homemade old fashion mix was on point, scallops & steak cooked to perfection! We also got the stuffed mushrooms, with warm bread (and infused butters!).. Five stars, highly recommended! Mike & staff were awesome! We’ll definitely be back!!

This dinner was fantastic. We had the chicken Alfredo and the Diablo pasta with scallops and shrimp. The mashed potatoes were amazing as well. I would try the potato pancakes again because they weren't up to par this evening but I will be back. Our server was so kind and prompt. Worth every penny to eat here.

It has that old tyme feel. The voices, the chatter, the laughing and eating. I love a joyous room and this is that place.  If you want a nice dinner  with your partner, call for a reservation
Bacon wrapped prime rib appetizer was sooo delicious. It has a spicy mayo for dipping.
I didn't even need to order a steak, with my small appetite. Did I mention they were bacon-wrapped?   Yes, the good bacon.
Amazing cod fish fry with a beautifully paired baked potato.
Bread and butter were delicious. Yes, I'm commenting on the bread.... It's that good.
Daniel was the perfect server. Prompt responsive and always smiling.  In fact, everyone there is so happy. It's contagious. Daniel was so sweet. Well done. Truly a 5-star experience. .

Today is 4 years in a row coming in on our anniversary. The food is always fantastic. The owner is the absolute best. There is no better place to eat in Rock County. We send everyone there, if you want a place to impress your friends or family I fully recommend Fredrick's!

Update, it's our 6th anniversary and still have spent everyone here.

We visited Fredrick's for the first time this weekend after hearing good things about their prime rib. It did not disappoint! The prime rib was tender and flavorful. The garlic herb cheese curds had a nice light breading and bacon-wrapped scallops were absolutely delicious. I had to try the Old Fashioned flight and I was delightfully surprised by the large portions. Great way to try 3 different Brandys in my favorite drink.

Staff was friendly and incredibly attentive, always making sure that water glasses were full and empty plates removed quickly. The facility is very clean and it's clear that it's painstaking cared for. We will certainly be back.

It was my first time dining at Fredrick's Supper Club after just learning about this fine establishment. I was truly impressed. I had an extraordinary cut of Prime Rib with baked potato, which was baked to perfection, I might add. My colleague had the Diablo Pasta that was described as being absolutely delicious. I look forward to my next visit to Milton and another exceptional dining experience.

We got the garlic parm cheese curd appetizer! They were fantastic! The staff was very attentive! I accidentally spilled the ranch on the floor and they were there to clean it up immediately. I highly recommend getting an old fashioned flight. The crown peach was especially good. My husband had the walleye and I had the rib eye. Both were cooked to perfection! I had the loaded red mashed potatoes, excellent! And my husband had the mac and cheese which was oh so good! We will definitely be back! And we are telling all our friends about it.

Best place to eat! We go every anniversary and its always amazing. Even with the covid rules the food and service are the best.

6 years of anniversary dinners here and I cannot complain. There's no where better in the area for amazing food. We have celebrated 6 years of anniversaries at this place.

I came here for prime rib on Saturday and all I can say ... BEYOND IMPRESSED! From the wait staff, bussers, bartenders & especially the chefs this is by far the best experience I've had at a Supper Club. I've been to a few but this place can top them all! Delicious prime rib & the prices were on point with the cut you order! Just watching how everyone worked together as a unit to provide you an excellent time there shows that management & the owners truly care about the customers! I highly recommend coming here, you won't be disappointed at all & will want to come back for more.

Thank you guys for an enjoyable night at your restaurant!

An amazing supper club! Great food, great service. I ordered the prime rib and scallops. WOW! We've eaten at many supper clubs in Wisconsin. This one is one of the best I've been to.

Chef has really improved the food. Walleye was delicious. The French Onion Soup was terrific. Only negative is that the room is a bit noisy. But the food is great. Good job Chef Brian Cherry!

Stopped back last night for dinner (Sat night) on our way home from Canoecopia in Madison

32 or 64 ounce bone in prime rib special was outstanding

Service ~ Molly was brilliant & took great care of us
Bar staff ~ incredible
Locals are awesome too!!!

This is a must stop for dinner

Other visit’s
If you ever get close to Milton WI stop in at Fredricks Super Club. The owner staff and food are all excellent. Stuffed filet - Prime rib - Onion soup - Scallops - Old school drinks.
Not far from 94 and well worth the short drive. We took Uber’s from Coachmen’s golf course. This will be our yearly Thursday night dinner for the boys golf trip.

Excellent, 1st time visiting , recommended by friends. Husband had prime rib, very good. I had a rare New York, beautiful crust on the outside, perfectly rare on the inside, very difficult to get a rare steak like that. Delish!!!!. Great service, not over priced cocktails, abundant mushrooms as a side. Will definitely return. Very impressed.

Stopped here on our way home to Chi from Cascade Mountain. Extremely attentive service and great food!

Excellent dining experience . The pork chops were a favorite at our table as was the prime rib. Do yourself a favor and order a whiskey old fashioned; it's ohh so good and their citrus butter for the fresh rolls was great . Excellent service to top it off.