Dominic's NY Pizzeria

Overall Rating: 5.6/10
Ordered takeout for dinner, and it was fine but didn't stand out. The wings were definitely the better part of the meal compared to the pizza.

Food:

Thin Crust Pizza: 5.1/10
The pizza was okay. The middle seemed too thick. The sauce was the highlight, adding some needed flavor.

Buffalo Wings: 6.1/10
The wings were the highlight – crispy and flavorful. I chose the mild option, and it was just the right level of spice, making them enjoyable.

As a native New Yorker, born and bred, this is by far the best pizza place I've been to outside of NYC. Not only is the pizza great, but the pasta dishes are spot on, especially the Alfredo. Great service rounds it out as one of my favorite places to get pizza either as a pie or by the slice.

My pepperoni pizza was awesome! I'm not from New York but I feel their NY pizza is authentic! The crust was crispy! It was perfectly thin with a nice bite but not too thin. It wasn't too much cheese to make the slice "bend". I definitely recommend and will be going back.

Hands down best pizza place here in the triangle. And the owner is super awesome guy. Would highly recommend. The buffalo chicken and spinach feta/ricotta pizza is the best!

Born and raised in ny. Moved down here to nc 24 years ago. Very few places can you get close to ny pizza. This is one of them. Most of the Italian/ pizza joints are absolute garbage. Give em a try. Owner is a fellow New Yorker. He knows what ny pizza is.

Ordered pizza here for my son’s birthday party and it was delicious. Had multiple guests come up to me and ask where the pizza was from because it was so good. Will definitely be back.

My husband and i drive 15 minutes away to come here despite there being plenty of pizza places close to home. Amazing pizza and cannollis, and always friendly.

My very first visit here. The pizza was so delicious! 😊 Very nice staff. 👍🏾 I will be back soon!

I’m from NY. Nothing comes closer to actual NY pizza outside of NY than this place. The toppings are quality and if you ask for an extra crispy crust they are happy to oblige.

Good atmosphere. Will stop through more often. Wilson, NC approved!

North NJ native here and this is the best pizza I have found in the 5 years living in the area! My favorite!
Employees are cool, great service, great pie.
Gave atmosphere 4 stars because it just looks a little dark and dated a bit? It's one of those hole-in-the-wall places that surprises you in the best way

Everytime this pizza is ordered its perfection. Don’t really care for the steak and cheese it was kind of hard to chew the meat with some bites but overall great experience👍🏾

2 slices and a drink for 8.50 and they are loaded slices. 10/10 would recommend

The 2 people working when I went in were so kind that I left in a better mood and it was only a matter of minutes. To top it off the 2 things I ordered (stromboli and zeppoli) are not only delicious, but they gave me so much it's like 3 days worth of food! I was amazed it wasn't busier. Totally recommend.

Hidden gem and closest thing to new york pizza with great prices

I didn’t think I’d find better pizza than the TRUE pizza capital of the US (New Haven, CT), but oh my gosh. This pizza is so freaking good. I’m not even finished with my second slice and said, “I gotta leave them a review. This is delicious.” So here I am. Even the cheese is good PLAIN. Do you know how good cheese pizza has to be to stand on its own?!
We found our pizza spot. Grazie. Gracias. Thank you!

I relocated from New York a week ago, and let me tell you this pizza is hands down giving New York ! If you from New York and looking for a authentic New York style pizza this is hands down the place my husband and I enjoyed for sure ..and even the outside patio over looking the little pond is so cute

The pizza is really very delicious. You can feel it in every bite that they have been making for years and managing to achieve the perfect flavor.

Tasty pizza and sooo fresh! Amazing people!

As a new Yorker, I'm always skeptical about NY style pizza, BUT this place definitely does not disappoint. The pizza was amazing and the garlic knots were really great! Highly recommend especially for those transplants who are missing NY!