Laurel Supper Club

This restaurant was excellent. Unfortunately they lost our reservation but they did work us in pretty quickly. While we waited, we had drinks at the bar. The drinks were good and the bartender was not shy with the liquor. You will get a ton of food with your meal! We had the prime rib and it was delicious! It comes with a popover, choice of rice pilaf/potatoes, soup, and salad. The salad, rice pilaf, and potatoes were good. The French onion soup was outstanding! We also try the jalapeno crab poppers for an appetizer and they were quite tasty. Our server was very good too. All in all, it was great. I do recommend reservations though. It's not very big and it's very busy.

We drove in from St. Paul seeking out the traditional Wisconsin supper club experience - and the Laurel didn’t disappoint. The popovers were delightful - steaks were delicious too. Everything here is homemade.
Most of all, the atmosphere made the evening. The dim lighting, the dark colors, the wood paneling - and the old school vibe. Would love to come back!

This was our second time at Laurel Supper Club. Our first experience was as good as this time. The main dining area is small, but still plenty of room around each table to be comfortable and not feel like you’re practically in someone else’s lap! Taste of food was amazing. Our favorite is the Popovers with homemade honey butter they serve warm almost immediately when you sit down. They serve homemade salad dressing with their house salad as well. The signature Parmesan peppercorn dressing and blue cheese dressing are among the best we’ve tasted. Wait staff and service was phenomenal. We will definitely come back many more times even though this supper club is over an hour drive from our home. This club has an old time feel and is decorated with the same charm.

1st and foremost, our server Sophia, was outstanding! The whole experience was fantastic! From the great martini, to the most fantastic steaks we have experienced in the area! 10 plus score on everything!
From the old school weeks, to the great side salad, great dressings, to the top tier steaks! And the recommendations for ice cream drinks! Love love love this place!!!

All the starters, old fashioned cocktails, and entrees we had at Laurel Supper Club were excellent. The staff was always busy helping/serving all while wearing a smile at the same time. Awesome food, staff, and ambiance made for a great evening. Thank you.

We had a party of 5 and sat in a boot in the bar area. The food was fantastic and the service was exceptional.
Everything from popovers to bread, soup salad and entree's were delicious.
Our granddaughters are picky eaters and cleaned their plates. I had the king cut prime rib and I can't remember ever having better.
I didn't catch our server's name but have to give a shout-out because she was awesome.
This was our first time here but definitely not our last.

For those in pursuit of an authentic Wisconsin Supper Club experience, this establishment is unparalleled. As someone with a profound appreciation for meat, I can attest that it consistently meets and exceeds expectations in both the quality of the steak and the satisfaction of a hearty meal. This venue is designed to cater to guests ready to indulge in a substantial dining experience, making it less suitable for those who prefer lighter meals. The generous portions and exceptional quality underscore its commitment to delivering a genuine and fulfilling supper club experience.

You cannot beat Laurels! This place has it all: amazing atmosphere, great drinks, incredible staff, not a single bad option on the menu and so much more! We live about 40 mins away from here and we make the trip any chance we get! We always get the steak as it comes with a pop over, soup, salad, bread and potato! You need to basically fast before you go because the food just does not stop coming. It’s simply amazing. Their French onion soup is to die for. Their homemade salad dressings are incredible and their steak melts like butter. If you have never been, I 10/10 recommend you check it out! Make sure you call ahead and make a reservation because they get very busy!

We walked in sat at the bar and the bartender asked if we wanted anything to drink. She then asked if the 2 year old could have oranges. The little one sat there and was good. And the bartender was very nice. The waitress was fantastic!

Great 4 course meal experience. Ranges from $25-60 per adult. Chicken Kiev or chicken alfredo is $26. Steaks are higher but many options. Popovers are fantastic! Then they serve a soup, salad, and main entree. Roasted pepper soup is great and not spicy but flavorful. Family friendly. Casual attire.

Great food, great old-fashioned cocktails..

Definitely need a reservation.. we ate at 5pm and by 5:30 they were turning people away..

Excellent food and service on a Saturday night! Well-oiled machine of employees! Highly recommend!

Wow. Stellar dinner… warm popover with cinnamon butter, French onion soup, salad with homemade dressing and bread, insanely good prime rib and au gratin potatoes. Wow.

🍁We took a beautiful early Saturday evening drive to New Richmond Wisconsin to the Laurel restaurant 💛outstanding food… there walleye was Amazing, all of the sauces, soup are home made… delicious.. we brought our good friends to celebrate there birthday…. This place is a 10 Star💛Our Server Sara so kind, patient and Very Knowledgeable 🎉Thanks for another Fabulous experience 🍂

This establishment is amazing. Based on home grown roots and excellent service. They don’t rush anything; food drink or time. This will definitely be a place I will tell everyone about!

Stopped in for apps, drinks, and a couple popovers. Such an amazing staff and owner... definitely coming back with the people I bought the gift certificates for!! Love!

Had wonderful service, excellent food, and a great time. Prime rib, filet mignon, French onion soup, twice baked potatoes and popovers were all delicious. Would absolutely come back.

Delicious food, excellent service, high quality ingredients. And plenty of food with each order. First time here and we will be back!

I wish I had a photo showing how beautifully prepared my meal was. I had a ribeye with baked potato. I can't wait to go back again.

Stopped here on way to snowmobile trip. Saw on side of the road. We stopped in late they were very accommodating and got us sat and served fast. Didn't have and knowledge of this place before but I will know doubt remember for a long time. We will stop here on trips north again in future.