Betsy's Bagels & Deli

I don't understand the 1 Star reviews for this place. I am assuming it was an off day for this place since everything I ordered tasted fresh and was definitely worth the price. The portion size was pretty good.

Strawberry Cream Cheese was less sweet than you get from other Bagel joints but that could be easily fixed, so I was fine with it.

I believe it’s the owner working the counter every morning. She was alone this morning and she hustled! She was taking care of three customers plus a door dasher on her own. When she was making my coffee, she had it all set but then didn’t think the milk was fresh, without even waiting for me to try and then return it. She made a fresh one with a new gallon of milk. That attention to detail is so rare these days! I love this place!

Staff is super kind, food is always delicious and thoughtfully prepared. I've gotten breakfast here a few times. Bagels, breakfast sandwiches, and omelettes are great. Also love the detox green juice made fresh, not too sweet, and very much worth the price.

Absolutely delicious bagel! I ordered the Lox on an onion bagel with jalapeño cream cheese. It was delicious! The staff and very friendly and welcoming; my only complaint is that they did not have a sign out front were you could see the store name. I'm not from the area so I walked past it twice. But I highly recommend this small but delicious place .....😋

Staffs are very kind, and working sincerely.
We had two types of bagels, a bagel was dance but not chewy, fillings were tasty 💗
I usually can't eat a lot, however I ate up totally! We found a new favorite shop✨Thank you!

Fast, friendly service. Prepared as ordered, bagels were fresh and overall good experience. Nice addition to the neighborhood and I’m looking forward to trying their lunch sandwiches.

Everything Is fresh and delicious! The bagels have the perfect bite and chew to them, and my smoothie was bursting with flavor. Our personal faves are the sun-dried tomato bagel and blueberry bagel.

Thank you Betsy’s Bagels for being a consistent store on Main Street. This store is ran by dedicated young entrepreneurial individuals with a vision and strong work ethic. It serves delicious sandwiches that even the little one will ask for. Working through the pandemic and staff shortage they never closed and always made sure our orders were fulfilled correctly. I wish this shop much success and highly recommend it to anyone in the area who can and would like to support a small business with a lot of potential. Let’s not loose another small business to the big names! We will continue supporting Betsy’s Bagels in the new year. Cheers to big things coming in 2023!

OH MY GOD!!! I just tried this place for the first time and I was sad because II forgot to write that I wanted the bagels toasted. Regardless it was still amazing. Me and my sister absolutely loved the bacon egg and cheeses. I’m also not a fan of egg and I loved the way that they were made. The home fries are also delicious. I will definitely be ordering here again. Highly recommend 10/10

Bagel, egg, cheese, turkey bacon, avocado. Delicious. I found them through Uber Eats. I will order directly from them next time.

That was one of the most delicious breakfasts I've had in a long time! I just picked up a BEC on a bagel with hash browns - wow! That was delicious! Everything was so fresh. I will be heading back to support this local spot as often as I can. Pro tip: they have a lot of orders coming in, so order ahead online for pickup!

Ordered from here numerous times and am always pleased!
Had some hiccups with my order today through Ubereats but the employee that assisted me over the phone both times was super accommodating and friendly.

Lox on onion bagel, jalepeno cream cheese, with tomato and onion. Plenty of lox! Definitely didn’t cheap me out, it was nice thick slices of lox on it. I forgot to ask for capers though.
Iced coffee is great too, friendly service.

Do yourself a favor and maybe just grab 2 sandwiches. Because it’s really sad when it’s gone.

I got a turkey bacon, egg, and cheese on a whole wheat everything bagel. The portion size was perfect; good cheese, egg and turkey bacon ration. The sandwich was very tasty and the staff was friendly. The store was extremely clean. 10/10 would recommend.

Cute spot. I was looking for a quick lunch that wasn't greasy or fried. Got an egg bagel w/ chicken salad 20 min till close. Good service and the bagel was very good. They have a lot of other options and breakfast sandwiches as well. I would stop here again.

Always been happy with the service and the delivery of the food. Have been going every day for the last year - and my friends tell me when I bring them the bagels that this IS a New Jersey bagel!

The breakfast sandwiches are amazing and they have an authentic old-school deli taste that is so hard to find these days. So much flavor literally! If you’ve had Dunkin Donuts’ breakfast foods, you know how commercial the food tastes, but Betsy’s “TurkeyBaconEggAndCheese” with “SaltPeppaKetchup” is nothing short of amazing!

They make the best breakfast sandwiches and their bagels are tasty! Service is friendly, place is clean and food is fresh. Will definitely be going back.

I saw a sign in their window that said “vegan options available” so I stopped in! I had a FBLT sandwich and it was amazing! They’ve got good vegan options and the customer service was great. I highly recommend Betsy Bagels!

Had a Pastrami, egg, cheddar on an onion bagel. BANGIN’!