Tonyboy's Sandwich House (Madison)

The food here is sooo delicious!! Tried it tonight with my husband and we highly recommend it. The sandwich bread is perfect (usually my husband is super picky about that) and they’re super generous with the portions. We got the Oreo milkshake too and omg it was so yummy. Try it!! 10/10. The staff was also extremely friendly and helpful.

Awesome quick spot for lunch. Price point and value are great. You get a lot for what you’re paying for. Got the angry bird which featured vodka sauce and honey on a chicken cutlet sandwich. It was amazing and unique combo. Will definitely be back to try more of the menu since it’s so close to the office. Staff was great too.

From New York and was just passing through Maddison, NJ. Was hungry and saw this place so I stopped. Well, Hell I was glad I did. I ordered the west coast chicken sandwich. All I can say is, these guys perfected a chicken cutlet. Thin, breaded just perfectly with the right blend of herbs and spices on a fresh hero with bacon, avocado and Swiss and a bit of mayo. It was off the hook. I’m sure the rest of their robust menu is equally as good. They should franchise this place. Go check’m out. You won’t be disappointed. Thanks fellas! CW from NY.

I was feeling like a Turkey sub and picked Tony Boy sandwiches on Grubhub. Boy was I surprised how good it was. They gave a lot of turkey and added the oil and vinegar perfect. I ordered again the next night. For sandwiches Tony Boy is the best!!!

Really good cheesesteaks. Got the Boardwalk and The Doozer and both were great. Was impressed by the quality of the meat and that it was a bit of a thicker cut. Definitely excited to try the other types of sandwiches they offer, especially some of the weirder sounding ones. The service was quick too, even on a busy catering day like the Super Bowl.

This is a great new Madison establishment. They have a good menu (some more vegetarian options would be nice, though) and the prices are reasonable. I got the Dodger, and it was very good! Chicken was juicy and the portion was generous! Will definitely back soon.

Welcome to the neighborhood!

Neat sandwich shop in Madison. Made while you wait, and their own brand of soda.

Love all the food & drinks from this joint ! The chicken cutlet is my favorite. I’m happy they added milkshakes to their menu.

We put in an order for pickup and got everything quick and easy. The food was really good, we ordered a roast beef sandwich and an eggplant wrap with coleslaw and Mac salad and everything was great. I’m looking forward to trying more of their menu!

I love the west coast it’s my favorite sandwich. Everyone working treats me with the utmost respect and fulfill my requests for sandwiches for perfect.

Yeah, this place is the real deal. Fantastic turkey sub. Will be returning soon to try a chicken cutlet sandwich.

I come here almost every day for lunch and get the same thing most of the time. Dan, the owner, is one of the reasons that sets this place apart and above other places in town. He makes you feel special because he not only knows me by name but also remembers my order. You can tell that he cares about his product and his people. He is constantly smiling and upbeat. He is always cleaning every table right after the customer leaves and making sure everyone is happy. I've tried a few things here, but my two favorites are 'The Dip' and the 'Lumpy'. My favorite side is by far the 'Hand Cut Fries'. They are easily the best fries in Madison. And last but not least are the drinks...they have their own sodas! My favorite is the Vanilla Soda. One of these days I will be courageous and try their Meatloaf special.

This place is awesome. I recommend angry bird, west coast, and drunk chicken. This guy is a savage and runs a clean business

Ordering Tony Boy's delivery has become a weekly staple in my house. I'm not someone who will typically order a salad, but my go-to is the chop chop sandwich with eggplant and Caesar dressing. It's basically a monster Caesar salad with thin, crispy eggplant on a sub roll. And it's incredible. We've tried a few other sammies and eat happily every time. Thank goodness they deliver all the way to Randolph, as there are no decent sub spots left out this way. Don't miss the fries or the vodka sauce, both are great.

Came here for the first time after a coworker recommended them. The chicken cutlets are thin and seasoned perfectly. You can tell they use high quality ingredients especially because they use boars head. I ordered the #10 and it was really good. The bread is sooooo good. The guys at the front were friendly and fun. THEY HAVE A HUGE PARKING LOT!!!

Stopped here while visiting NJ. Wish we had these back home, great subs, one of my favorite tuna subs I've had. Tasted like the nostalgic tuna subs from my childhood but improved. My fiance was very happy with her sub as well, everything tasted very fresh.

We've really enjoyed Tony Boy's sandwiches for take out and recently had a great experience with their catering! They offer much more than just sandwiches (which are delicious) and everyone raved about the food! It was so easy to communicate about our catering order and they even customized some things for us based on what we needed. We were so impressed!

I was at event nearby with the kids and the parents were trying to figure out lunch when one mom mentioned this place. My daughter looked up the menu and sent me right away. We got their Modern Cobb salad and it was GREAT. My daughter is very picky on her salads and said this was one of the best salads she's ever had. The staff was very friendly. I also got one of their homemade vanilla sodas and it was delicious.

Love this place. Cutlet sandwiches are the best. My favorite is the West Coast. The avocado and chicken always taste so fresh. Can’t wait to try the whole menu.

The Madison location is the BEST! Not a fan of the quality of the food from the Livingston location. I only mention that with hope for improvements at the Livingston store. This is the type of local sandwich place that I search for. Place that take note and care of quality. I don’t mind paying for good food. So you’ll never hear me complain about price. I have a problem with bad food at high costs.

Madison’s Tony Boys is the truth!