Mary MacGill

Honestly, 5 stars is not enough! Mary and the team helped pick and source an engagement ring for my now fiance, and she and I both seriously could not have been happier. Maybe most impressively, this ring was chosen without input from a very picky fiance, and again - she could not have been happier. Absolutely amazing, stunning, perfect, all of the above. They do an amazing job from start to finish - helping identify the style, finding the right diamond and pairing, making the ring unique and personal, making themselves available for questions and consultations. Between the simple band, unique setting, range of diamond choices and pairings - the ring feels very classic and elegant but uniquely personal and different at the same time. Everyone has been blown away.

We bought a custom engagement ring from Mary last year and could not be happier with the experience and final product. Exactly how one hopes to feel with a forever piece of jewelry. The ring is gorgeous and classic yet still somehow so unique. I feel Mary's personalized touch every time I look at the ring, and I know my husband felt the same way about his experience working with Mary to design the ring. She helped him to think through different different designs, based on our lifestyle and my sense of style, and she helped him to source the right diamond to make their vision a reality.

We have also been long-time customers of Mary's jewelry from her Block Island location, and it is amazing how diverse her work is. I love that you can wear it to the beach or on the most elegant of occasions.

I absolutely Love everything I’ve bought from Mary MacGill - clothing and jewelry for myself and also jewelry for graduation and birthday presents for the daughters of friends. When teenagers take the time to not only write a note but send pics of themselves with their new earrings, you know you’ve hit the sweet spot!

The things I have appreciated most about the Mary MacGill organization are their refreshing and stunning designs but also their customer service. There have been a couple of times when I had specific questions about jewelry and I truly had personal service and knew the pieces that would be delivered would be perfect - and they were! I can also say that making a return is just what one would hope for in a business. There is immediate attention to seemingly everything and no waiting around for a credit card reimbursement. In today’s world, this attention to detail stands out as such a positive!

Mary MacGill has become one of my favorite “Go To” places to shop. They and their products are wonderful!

My partner and I had the best time finding the most beautiful engagement ring from Mary MacGill. Mary and Marion were so helpful throughout the entire experience, and sourced several stones for us to look at. The experience was intimate and personal - exactly what I had dreamed of for such an occasion.

Tastefully understated, statement pieces that you can wear every or any day and feel simply stunning. That is what a piece of Mary MacGill jewelry evokes. Plus the entire universe she’s curated in her home & lifestyle & clothing collections — well you could just move right in & trust you’d be in timeless, great taste. Also, on a super practical level, it’s a one stop shop for a gift at any price range!

I have been a fan of Mary MacGill's work for a long time now. There's nothing quite like her pieces, each unique and special. I love the thoughtfulness around the curation of both the jewelry and the art & curiosities of her shops. Everything feels so intentional and special. I love to go into the Germantown shop as a treat, to bring someone who is visiting, or just to chat with the girls. Mary has effortlessly created a warm and welcoming community spot for the every day AND the special occasion. The care her team brings really makes a difference in my day!

The most beautiful jewelry store and the kindess team. All the pieces are so unique, high quality and absolutely stunning. Most of my collection is all different styles mixed together and it goes so well. Such cute gifts and forever pieces for all ages and styles.

Absolutely beautiful shop/gallery in Germantown. Some of my favorite jewelry pieces are from here, each one unique and timeless. I also love their selection of artwork, art/design books, and clothing. Highly recommend.

Mary MacGill is brilliant! Visiting her studio in Germantown is blissful. The clothes, the jewelry, the art - simple and beautiful. Her team is knowledgeable and kind. A visit should be paired with a delicious meal at one of the Hudson Valley's finest dining establishments (Gaskin's, Otto's). Mary MacGill = under the radar awesomeness.

Mary is the sommelier of awesome clothing and hand crafted beautiful jewelry of the Hudson Valley. Hands down top pick for all my wife’s presents!

I had a terrific experience working with the MM team! They were so helpful in designing the most perfect and beautiful piece for my daughter's graduation!

I could honestly buy everything in this beautiful shop- from art and sculpture to clothing and of course, the most beautiful jewelry, I will definitely be back!

Well curated shop/gallery in Germantown with a lovely and helpful staff - ceramics art books jewelry and clothing

Some of my favorite pieces I wear daily!