Beach Bum Bakery

Always a pleasure to visit the bakery! I don’t go too much (i try to watch my sugar intake 😂) but they have the absolute best gourmet cookies you can get in the area, lovely owners and staff, had the pleasure to even order a custom “Ice fishing themed” cake which was beautiful artistic and delicious!! Oh and on Sundays they have hot ham and fresh rolls!

Having a local bakery that delivers donuts and hot ham and rolls on a Packers Playoff Sunday in subzero temperatures is an actual dream come true. Please never stop. ❤ Everything is always so delicious. I recommend scheduling an order ahead of time through the DoorDash app because they (understandably) sell out pretty quick!

We celebrated our granddaughter, who turned one and our youngest, who turned 21 (literally 19 years and 364 days apart), and we couldn't have asked for better cakes! Sarah did an amazing job on the fondant work and took our vision, and made it a reality! Our second cake was champagne flavored with strawberry filling and buttercream frosting, and it was delsh! It was a little light on the champagne flavoring, but that willl not stop us from coming back. Thank you, Sarah & Crew, for such wonderful creations!

Good customer service and absolutely delicious cookies. I'd definitely recommend the s'mores and kitchen sink cookies. Crispy edges, soft chewy centers, tons of flavor and a absolutely divine taste.

Beautiful views, delicious desserts and overall great experience.

This is a must. The cookies are amazing 💥. Have to say they are better then the big chain cookies🍪. We had the kitchen sink, p.b. cup, double chocolate chip, lemon blue berry and salted caramel. All were hands down awesome. Didnt try the slushy, cakes and other baked goods but of they're anything like those cookies then im sold. Don't forget if your having a birthday and need a cake, they do it too! If you're at the lake and need a snack head over to Beach Bum Bakery and let me know how the slushy are. Might need to get one next time 😃

Went there for hot ham and rolls. The ham was delicious and I got great customer service. They had unique bakery option and they were delicious. They recommended getting there early bec they only have some much hot ham and typically run out and even though I got there a little after 10am, I was thankful they still had some available. I would definitely go back, food was great and staff was friendly.

I ordered a cake for my daughter's first birthday and couldn't have been more pleased! I gave minimal direction (colors & theme) and it turned out so great. Not only was the design Awesome - it also tasted delicious :) We will most definitely order again from Beach Bum.

Excellent job with custom cookies! The designs were exactly what I envisioned, plus they were super soft and very tasty! Highly recommend for any kind of occasion, I will definitely be back!

We decided to get a treat after swimming at the beach and this place looked perfect! It's a beautiful store right across from Pewaukee beach. They have a good variety of treats such as cupcakes, cookies, donuts, homemade desserts, ice cream bars, and bottled drinks. I wish I had taken a picture of our purchases. My kids got the vanilla cupcakes and I got the lemon raspberry cupcake. My husband tried the M&M cookie. All were delicious and reasonably priced! We will definitely have to come back!

Beach Bum Bakery saved me when another baker ghosted me with my order. They made beautiful birthday cupcakes that tasted as good as they looked. I also recommend the macarons, they are to die for.

This is one of my favorite places to support on Pewaukee Lake. Pricing is more than fair for a small business and you definitely get what you pay for.

We have tried a variety of items and everything is amazing. The lemon blueberry cookie I tried this week was out of this world!

Hot ham and homemade rolls on Sunday are always a great choice but make sure you get in early before they sell out.

Love that they rotate things in seasonally like the Girl Scout cupcakes, holiday decorated cookies, etc.

Beach Bum Bakery is an awesome bakery with delicious and adorable cakes and other treats. The owners are awesome and continuously give back to the community. The food's delicious and is really reasonably priced. I highly recommend them.

We used Beach Bum for our daughter’s third birthday. It was a Minnie Mouse birthday theme and they delivered! All the party goers raved about how it was the best birthday cake they’ve had and I could not agree more!oh, and their donuts and cupcakes are delicious as well 🤤🤤🤤

Beach Bum Bakery made a 2 tier cake for my daughter's baptism. I gave them creative freedom for the design that turned out so beautiful! We received so many compliments from family on the cake design and taste. We also ordered hot ham and rolls that were perfect for the occasion and so delicious. Easy to order over the phone and pick up went smoothly! Thanks for helping in making her day special!

Beach Bum is beyond phenomenal. I have has almost everything they sell at least once 😂 always delicious! And if you get the peanut butter cup cookie, ask them to warm it up for you (they frequently offer to). AMAZING!

Delicious bakery items that vary almost by the day. Inventive flavors and generous sizes.

I was so pleasantly surprised to stumble upon Beach Bum Bakery! I was on a desperation hunt for last-minute birthday cupcakes for my daughter with hopes to avoid resorting to the grocery store; and was so fortunate that my Google search led me to land upon this lovely, laid-back bakery on the lakefront strip with such delectable treats.
When I walked in, there was a display case full of various different baked goods (priced on par with other bakeries), including a lovely assortment of cupcakes that were adorably decorated by flavor/theme.
It was nice to see a small seating area, which is convenient for those who want to pop in for a quick treat like the dad and his daughter who were sitting down and enjoying an after school treat together.
I was not at all surprised to see that there only a few left of the white frosted cupcakes I was seeking, as my expectations were very low for any bakery to have a dozen left in the afternoon. I was ready to walk out until Sarah asked if there was anything in particular that I was looking for, so I sheepishly said that I was hoping to find enough cupcakes for my daughter and her volleyball team…by tonight. Much to my delight, I was told that she had some more in the back that she could frost for me…12 at that! And a huge plus that she didn’t seem annoyed in the least to offer this even though she was closing soon. She even put on sprinkles to match my daughter’s team colors:). Then the taste test…the girls raved about how delicious they were! Another girl who has an upcoming birthday even told her mom that she didn’t think they couldn’t beat how good those cupcakes were:).
Talk about an impromptu success! I will definitely be going here again… with better planning of course;). Highly recommend checking out Beach Bum Bakery for yourself!

Beach Bum is my favorite local bakery to visit! I take my kids there at least once a month, sometimes more. I have done multiple custom orders with Sarah so far and have been incredibly pleased! She offers everything from HOMEMADE donuts, to oversized cookies, and fluffy quiche. I guarantee you can find at least a handful of treats to enjoy.

Amazing!! Can't wait to get a cake. Donuts 🍩, cookies 🍪, coffee ☕, and croissants are always delicious!!

Owners are very nice and they have a great selection of items. We've purchased two cakes from the case and both were fantastic. The cupcakes are delicious and the flavors were great! My kids are huge fans of weekend doughnuts. If you need a birthday cake this is probably the best in the area!!