Eddie Martini's

We haven't been to Eddie Martini's in years. We got one of their last reservations on a Saturday to celebrate my mom's birthday. We started with the Stewed Escargot and Grilled Brie. Both were delicious. Everyone's dinner was amazing. I had the Pomegranate Miso- Glazed Salmon, and it was really good. Then it was time for dessert. The birthday dessert is a Chocolate Flourless Cake with Fresh Whipped Cream. So yummy. We also had Chocolate Cake with Vanilla Ice Cream. But the best dessert hands down was their Bread Pudding with Homemade Cinnamon Ice Cream. Unbelievable! Our servers were Sara and Hannah, and they were both excellent!

We had a marvelous time at the restaurant with the great food and great service. Enjoyed the evening dining at the restaurant. Thanks Mara for the kind hospitality!

Mara and Gabby gave us excellent service. We love this place. We ordered their escargot. Never had such an excellent presentation with incredible flavors including pine nuts. It was enough for a dinner and super inexpensive. Dan and Rick

Service is beyond description. The host he was very charming and remembered the reason we were dining (birthday) and congratulated right away and was so accommodating to make our visit so special. That was just the half. The meal we ordered was wagyu steak medium. PERFECTLY done. Melted like butter. Another we ordered was 45-day dry aged strip medium. Unfortunately it was done too well which they immediately corrected. The whole experience was platinum! The environment I rated as a 4 because the tables were too close together in the Club dining area such that you had to be very careful getting in and out of your seat. Otherwise, the experience and the service of the staff was beyond expectations!

On a whim my father suggested we go here. At 5:10 on a Monday night we got the last available table, so plan ahead! The food and drinks were fantastic - as a long time martini aficionado I ordered the Eddie Martini and it was exquisite. The lobster bisque was outstanding, and the filet mignon was divine. There's no official dress code but most customers were in business casual or better. The service was excellent (despite our lack of style), and if you're looking for something special we highly recommend it.

I have not had a bad experience here in the last 10 years. Everything is always cooked to perfection. We always get the brussel sprouts. The service is always on point. I enjoy the atmosphere and I love that everyone working is wonderful. They're more than willing to let you drop flowers or anything of for your table ahead of your reservation.

Eddie Martini’s wasn’t on our radar until a few weeks ago and I’m sure glad that we tried it out! It was such a great experience, across the board. We were able to get a seat in the dining room and had a filet and a dry aged rib eye. Both were incredible. We also had drinks to match the name of the restaurant. The staff did an amazing job and everyone was incredibly hospitable and accommodating. I would absolutely put Eddie Martini’s up against all the other steak houses in the area.

My first time at Eddie Martini’s and I could not have had a better meal. Started with hot spinach salad which was amazing. It could have been a meal all on its own. Followed up with the Roasted duck. My wife had the most succulent petite filet.
The service was impeccable. The drinks were great. All in all this was a five star meal and I can’t wait to go back again.

The benchmark for fine dining in the Wauwatosa area, Eddie Martini's always delivers an incredible experience. The service is refined, the drinks are terrific, and the food is divine.
Those in the mood for top notch steak need look no further than Eddie Martini's, but be sure to also try their seafood. The seafood pasta is especially decadent.

A client recommended Eddie Martini's for a get together and we absolutely enjoyed every minute. The staff was accommodating, generous, and fun. The meals were amazing and the cocktails were even better. When I forgot to pick up the itemized copy of my receipt, they were kind enough to send it to me via email. I can't wait to come back! Thanks for a fantastic evening everyone!

From the time you walk in the door to the disappointing time to leave.. is filled in between with a memorable culinary experience...fit for royalty. I ate the best steak that I have ever had the pleasure to introduce to my palate. It was the largest cut Rib Eye steak I ever witnessed. I literally succeed in cutting this steak easily with my butter knife. Honest!!!! It was tender, succulent, and tasted as if it had been infused with butter. Worth every dollar I spent: and that is saying a lot!

This place is a must go if in suburban Milwaukee or at the medical center. Had probably the second best steak (Australian Wagyu) I've ever had, and best in 15 years. Service was excellent too. Be prepared to park down the adjacent side street, this place and the parking lot fill up quick.

Great menu, meals met our expectations, and then some. Our waitress was a delightful and highly knowledgeable person named Mara. She was outstanding. Her suggestions were right on, and I enjoyed her amazing, fun personality.
I would highly recommend eddie martini's for an exceptional and wonderful upscale dining experience.
Anyone who is fortunate enough to have Mara for their server will surely have a great time and an awesome meal.
Bon appétit!

The service here is top notch!!! To start they actually call you to confirm reservation! Love it! All the staff is friendly and courteous. Your water glass never goes below 2 fingers gotta keep hydrated with the strength of their cocktails. That brings me to the 🍸.the glasses our pre chilled to ensure a perfect drink. I'm a big stoli fan and they our the only place I have found stoli gold served thanks Dr. Bob?😁 Seafood tower is a great way to start your meal no longer served in a big martini glass but stil delicious !! Steaks our large and cooked to perfection. Overall it's pricey but well worth it.!!

It was magical. We went for our anniversary and it was everything we could have dreamed. Extremely professional and personable staff. Light bread before the meal was warm and delectable. Even the salad was unique and great.

The meal was possibly the most satisfying jewel ever. I had the wagyu filet. The crust from the sear, the tenderness, the smell, and the flavor was perfect.
My wife had the duck which was cooked perfectly and extremely tender and flavorful. The potatoes served with it were fantastic.
We were also served a desert medley which ended the meal perfectly. Creme Brulee, spiced cake, and bread pudding with house made cinnamon ice cream. There aren't enough adjectives to capture the delight.

It was perfect. Wayne Bartz was a fantastic host and is truly gifted at his profession. He made our experience memorable.

Thank you so much Eddie Martini's team!!

First time going to Eddie Martini's. We arrived a little early for our reservation, so we were seated at the bar, which only had 4 barstools to accommodate for social distancing. It made me feel very comfortable. The bartender was friendly, and our drinks were poured just right.
Once we were brought back to our table, we noticed all of them were well spaced apart. I ordered the double duck, and my partner ordered the New York strip. His steak was cooked and seasoned perfectly. It had a melt in your mouth quality, which is always what we look for. My duck came with one leg and sliced breast. The leg was delicious. I will say the breast was just slightly dry, but still tasty. We ordered 3 sides: asparagus, mashed potatoes, and the Maine lobster mac. The asparagus and potatoes were wonderful. My only complaint about the lobster mac is that there wasn't much lobster in it, but the flavor of the pasta and sauce was delicious.
Our waitress was friendly, and checked on us just the right amount.
All in all, I'll be back.

Had dinner there for the first time tonight! Awesome food, service and atmosphere! I highly recommend Eddie's for your fine dining!

Great ambience, friendly staff and excellent food. Good for a family outing or for business lunch or dinner. Was here couple of times and they even have the wagyu beef steaks which is awesome. I am a raw oyesters fan and one of the best oyesters I have had in a while. They do not have oyesters in their menu so you have to ask specifically. The crab cakes were also delicious. Tasted real and not like any fake meat.

We were seated right when we arrived which was a little earlier than our reservation. Tried a new app this time, Tempura Shrimp. Went really well with the sriracha aioli. My filet was cooked perfectly. Mashed potatoes were a little too garlicky, but ok. Grasshopper was a nice finish, but tasted a little off/bitter. Probably due to the cosmo prior since my husband said it was fine. Overall the food and service were fantastic!

I enjoyed the experience yet there was a slow start but the appetisers made up for it. I did have crab cakes and Bruschetta. I did have a Caesar salad was greatAnd then I had wine with dinner which was amazing! I had a great time celebrating my sisters wedding she is getting married this weekend! They also had great lobster it was the best Maine lobster I had in a while but was worth it !

Glade we did it and went there! The dessert was great to! Anything you order here is great even people like myself who are on diets for gluten free!