Reynold's Pasty Shop

Excellent. Know this the Hot-N-Fresh is very hot and real fresh. The pastry outer reminded me of pot pies of years long ago. We had beef gravy and sour cream. Sour cream was best but close 2nd was gravy. Some people park right on the street outside, we have a fat rear end so we squeezed into parking lot across the street. I hope we have time to stop in again before we leave.

Support local business!
Fantastic every time. Get the gravy and cheese to complete the meal with amazing flavor!

They are the best been eating them since the 70's. We moved to TN and when we come home we bring some home with us. I wish you shipped them or were in TN

Love this place. Best place around for pasties. Great childhood memories stopping here and getting one hot and ready to go.

Great place. Recommend all to this small shop,that has been one of Milwaukee's finest, for years. You can find this pastry in super markets, world wide. This place has been in business for years.

They really really really need to have a shipping service as they are not available anywhere out of Wisconsin and they are the best~~ truly the only pasties worth eating

The best pasty in the midwest!!!! If you haven't eaten here, you need too asap. Grab a pasty with all of the fixings!

These are so good. Sadly, I can't find them in the stores anymore. You have to go the shop. The hours make it difficult to stop by after work...they were sold out to 2 and I needed 4 lol. But they're that good. The staff is always nice though I never really talk to anyone in the kitchen. I really wish they deliver via door dash or something lol.

This place is amazing. Growing up my next door neighbor was from Superior Wisconsin and she has been making Pasties all her life and I remember they were delicious. These Pasties tasted Just Like Her Homemade. Flaky crust. Lots of meat and onions. They are reasonably priced. Great quick service and very nice people there. Very friendly and sweet. Try them with cheese sauce and sour cream. Me and my husband will be back soon.😉

I have been buying Reynold's Pasties for years in the frozen food section of our local grocery store. They are so good. Well I finally stopped and bought 3 fresh ones from their restaurant. I couldn't believe how better they are fresh! Don't get me wrong, the frozen ones are good it's just unbelievable how much better they are fresh. And everyone at Reynold's is so nice and friendly. Can't wait to visit again soon.

The pasties, as always, are perfect! The cashier is crazy as hell! Y'all be careful in there. She cursed out an old couple so bad it was disturbing and disgusting!

I travel from Waukesha to Milwaukee for this place. May not be the best looking and can use many updates to the building. BUT THE PASTRY never fails me. I love it !!!

ALWAYS a pleasure & they NEVER disappoint! When we come home to Milwaukee we ALWAYS grab a couple dozen Pastys' to bring back to Georgia. This year we grabbed 3 dozen...no issues no problems! With their new cash incentives I was able to save a few bucks & get one of my two Ready to eats FREE.
❤

These pastys are unbelievable. They are so good. I get them cheese, gravy and sour cream.

I’ve been coming here for years, and this review long earned its place. However this pasty shop has long earned its excellent reputation on its own. If they’re not open, I’d get the frozen ones. The stores that use to carry these always sold out and NO OTHER pasty compares. If you never had one or thought about it….. BEST PASTY you’ll ever have!!! If you do know, support the Pasty Shop, it’s MKE’s original. I bought 3 today just so I can have some for later. I’ll upload pics if I haven’t eaten it first. 🤷🏾‍♂

Really great tasting Pasty! Friendly and fast service. I'll be back again - oh and the gravy...YUM!

I went to Pick 'N Save in Neenah to get pasties and Reynolds was the only brand available, so I tried them. They are my all time favorite Pasties now! The meat is tender, the potatoes and carrots have a tasty freshness and the crust is yummy! Im SOLD!

Just like I asked call style bakery were you going in and they got beautiful cupcakes and a Lotta good sweet just like I asked call style bakery were you going in and they got beautiful cupcakes and a Lotta good sweets

My dad is from Ironwood in the U.P. (pasty shops everywhere) & his family was from Cornwall, U. K. where pasties were created. Reynold's has the best pasties! We always have them stocked in our freezer!

Best pasty’s in the world if you ask me! Fast, friendly, hot and fresh! I’m addicted and proud that are right in my community serving us for more then 30years!