Joey Gerard's - A Bartolotta Supper Club

Top-notch steakhouse! Never disappoints. Celebrated with family & each had an amazing steak cooked to perfection. Excellent & attentive service but not intrusive. Worth the price! Reservations highly recommended.

Been to Joey's numerous times. It is consistently good.

Made a reservation for a Monday night (I used to think that they were closed Mondays?). Arrived on time and got seated right away. The dining room was busy, but not full. We waited a little bit for our server, but everything after that was timely and efficient. Our server seemed to be relatively new, but did great job of explaining any specials and getting our drinks and ordered. (thanks Sophie).

Didn't get any appetizers, but we were served warm bread, with butter and a couple of cheese spreads. Our entrees of Lobster and Lamb Chops arrived, perfectly cooked and seasoned well. If I had any suggestions, I would have wanted to sides (Garlic Spinach and Sweet Potatoes) hotter.

Finished off the meal with a complimentary Schaum Torte, but a birthday, and an additional Brandy Alexander. Both were amazing good.

Except for the small complaint with the temperature of the sides, it was a perfect meal and perfect evening. Thanks :)

Classy restaurant located in a quaint shopping plaza. Serving a well-balanced menu of options, Joey Gerard's had a good option for everyone in my party of 3: a MASSIVE rack of ribs, delicious cedar plank salmon, and a great burger. The sides that came with each plate were also excellent. Even the French fries had a unique flavor I hadn't experienced before. And our waitress, B., was friendly, funny, and accommodating. It was a great experience overall.

Overall, food and service 5-stars. A Tuesday night with below zero temps there wasn’t many customers (~ 7 tables) so the atmosphere was quieter than we would have liked. Not Joey’s fault other than maybe they could be creative, e.g., putting us all in the room closer to bar. That said we understand some like it quiet so present setup would work for them. Overall 5-stars. Picture is their side salad-was wonderful as all our food was; presentation and taste.

The prime rib was excellent. Atmosphere was beautiful. Mary and Sharon treated me
For dinner. They came all the way from Mequon to eat here. Very generous and loving friends. They picked the best restaurant. Wonderful evening

I went there with 2 coworkers last Saturday and what a fabulous experience! The village was decorated so beautifully and was so festive! Jason our waiter was amazing and you could tell he’s been doing this for years. Very seasoned waiter! He spilt our bill separately for all of us, and we decided to share the Schaum torte and he divided that three ways and put it on all of our bills. The food was nothing short of amazing everything including the cocktails were delicious! I had the bone in fillet with the double baked loaded potato and glazed carrots. I seriously can’t wait to go back!

Top notch experience. Very detailed orientated, food was perfect down to the exact amount of seasoning. Loved the cheese curds, burger, drinks. Entire experience was wonderful. It was our server Shannon who really took it over the top. She was detailed, friendly, knowledgeable and on top of it all. Made for a flawless experience. Hard to find this level of talent these days, she’s a gem.

Great food and service
Definitely delicious
The raw beef is to die for
Prime rib was out within an hour on Saturday this was the only disappointment but the food we chose was great

Our server, Kim, was super! She was very nice and thoughtful. Our food was so good! We love the relish tray and crème brûlée!! I always get the lobster and it was awesome…I also tried the deluxe stuffed potato which was great! My husband loves the ribeye (and saves a bite for our dog). Thanks for a super anniversary dinner!

The food, service, and atmosphere are great. It is a very nice restaurant to have a birthday or anniversary dinner. During the holidays, the village is decorated, which gives a nostalgic vibe walking in - if you arrive on the hour, you'll hear church bells ringing. Jody is our favorite server- always friendly and remembers us. The steaks are great and really good old fashions.

My husband and I were celebrating our 38th wedding anniversary. Let me just say that Joey Gerard’s is our favorite Supper club. Everyone did a wonderful job providing us with a night to remember! A nice Anniversary card signed by staff, a delicious dinner (our compliments to the chef & staff), and beautiful and delicious Schaum strawberry torte, & a wonderful waiter, Bo. Thank you all for an enjoyable celebration!

A really enjoyable evening at a Milwaukee-area supper club. It’s only about a decade old so it doesn’t have the well-worn atmosphere of most supper clubs but the staff was fantastic (bartender, hostess and our waitress) and the food and drinks were excellent. Good choice of classic old-timey cocktails in addition to the regular fare.
The menu was perfect- not too much selection so you’re overwhelmed- but not too few selections either.
We both had steak - perfectly cooked - along w delicious sides.
It’s not inexpensive but I would say it’s about what you’d expect for a good meal out.

We were lucky to be there on a night their special was bone in pork chop and it was, as always, perfectly done and delicious. Our waiter Jodi was the best and made my husband's 70th birthday just as he wanted. We hope they put the pork chop back on their regular menu, we miss it.

The food was fantastic! I had the shrimp pasta, and hubby had the cider honey salmon. There was plenty of food with both the dishes.

The service was phenomenal!!

There was a wide range of attire from jeans to dresses and suitcoats.

It was very easy to use online reservations. We were seated as soon as we arrived.

Overall, everything was excellent!

We go to Joey Gerard's for special occasions. We love having Jody take care of us during our dining experience. He always goes above and beyond to make sure everything is perfect. The food and drinks never disappoint. We will be returning!

Excellent service and attention to detail. Food was outstanding as always. We especially appreciate the specially made vegan dish and the birthday torte.

Celebrated our 54th wedding anniversary and from the commaraderie at the bar with great drinks to the leisurely,
wonderful meal and dining service that was excellent.

If you love steak...you'll
Love coming here.
You leave with food.
They do NOT! Skimp
On servings. Excellent sallad...Excellent sides
And did I mention
Steaks?... bring your
Wallet...but my wife
And I both agreed it
Was worth every
Nickle. Enjoy!

Recommend!

They are known for their old fashions and steaks... I see why. They were very good. I ordered the filet 12oz and it was cooked to perfection. It did have some char on the outside (which I like), but I know it's not for everyone. Also had chance to try the lamb chops, probably the best I've ever had. Will definitely be coming back.

Always enjoy coming here and grabbing a table in the bar. Always get the same bartender serving our table and he is great. Love that you can get the raw beef and Schaum tortes here.