Stagecoach Inn

Everything wonderful, but i was disappointed that you were out of chicken by 530! Our server was Madison and she was so nice. A bit loud and we loved the relish tray. Thank you.

This was my first time checking the restaurant out on a whim. We did not have reservations but got seated right away. The food was delicious! My steak was done medium like I asked, which rarely happens. I also ordered a side of French fried lobster which was one of the BEST bites of food I have ever had! Light, crispy, perfect. We also had 2 old fashion sweets and split a peanut butter pie dessert! Excellent! I highly recommend! Besides the rude customer who reach over our table it was a great experience. Thank you, it is rare these days.

Perfect place to celebrate any occasions. My hubby's family fave place to go every Thursday. Good food, good place, good service. . 5👍❤

We've driven by the Stagecoach Inn for years and have always wanted to try it out. We finally had a chance to eat here tonight and it did not disappoint. As soon as you walk in, you're greated by a warm, lodge-like atmosphere and smiling, friendly faces. I started out with a Brandy Old Fashioned that was made to perfection. In true supper club style, our dinners were served with relish tray, salad, soup and bread. All delicious! I had the broiled scallops as my entree with scalloped potatoes on the side. The scallops were incredibly tender and the potatoes were very flavorful. Be ready to leave very full if you opt for a dinner.

Great WI super club experience. We will certainly be back!

Love coming here! Food is always delicious and staff is friendly and efficient. You can tell that the staff has great communication with eachother. Best supper club in the area!

Great dinner at The Stagecoach Fort Atkinson. The wife had Broiled Cod. I had the Lake Perch. Both were top notch. The au gratin potatos we’re hot and flavorful . The coleslaw was super creamy and fresh. The tarter was the perfect complement to the fish. Also served with a slice of marble rye. Shawn the owner introduced himself and made us feel welcome. Tasty Old Fashions and The Bleu Cheese stuffed Olives were a bonus. Great spot!

My first time dining at the Stagecoach Inn.
I'm telling you, it did not disappoint. From the relish tray to our steak dinner. The food and service were fabulous.

Went there for the Wednesday night Prime Rib special and I was NOT disappointed!! I had a bowl of Baked French Onion Soup first, which was delicious, along with a superb Korbel Old Fashioned! But the Prime Rib!......Medium rare with horseradish and probably the best I've ever had!! I also had the Au Gratin potatoes which were also delicious! Emily was my server and I was the first customer she'd ever served. She was great. This is one of my favorite supper clubs and I look forward to the next time I go. HIGHLY recommended. FIVE STARS.

Our service and food were excellent. I had the steak and jumbo shrimp. Plenty to eat. We were seated as soon as we came. 1 suggestion put some lights in parking lot. Maybe solar lights, so very dark out there.

We go here often and tonight I tried the filet mignon with blackened seasoning with crumble blue cheese and it was absolutely amazing! Angel our waitress was amazing too!! I have never rated them before but tonight, everything was so perfect I had too!! Definitely a must for supper clubs!

Rachel, our server, was very attentive and helpful. She's a superb waitress! Prime rib was excellent and the atmosphere was warm and cozy! Would definitely recommend. Will be back again.

Great hospitality, the prime rib was cooked very nicely medium rare. The horsey sauce was very, very tasty. Great staff, great service all around wonderful experience. Also the Jumbo shrimp my other half had was cooked to protection golden brown and crunchy!

This is one of the best Supper Club's in Wisconsin that we've been to. The food was excellent as well as their Bloody Mary's!! The service and the precautions taken for guests were exemplary too. Can't wait til our next visit!!

Great WI supperclub. Food was excellent and our pickup order was ready exactly on time.

The Stagecoach Inn is a true Wisconsin supper club. They have great food, great Old Fashions, and great service. Our waitress, Madison, kept things moving and was very attentive to the six of us. All but one of us had the Thursday special, which was steak and shrimp. We all agreed it was delicious, along with a salad and rolls. My husband had the pork chops, which were tasty and tender. He got the relish tray, French Onion soup, a salad and rolls with his meal. We had a wonderful time and we will meet there again next month.

I have been here a few times while visiting friends nearby. The vibe is great! Friendly staff with a supper club vibe. Everybody is social and welcoming. The food is traditional steak house fare. On my part visit I had the ribeye special which was outstanding!

Good, cocktails, great staff and wonderful food. I'll come back!

I always make a point to go to The Stagecoach Inn when I'm in the area. Always busy! Saturday is prime rib night and if you want succulent, tender, juicy prime rib, you'll love it here. A Wisconsin tradition, a relish tower, pea salad, creamed beets, coleslaw and three bean salad. The service and attention to detail earn high marks from all staff involved, they are absolutely great even tho they are sometimes subjected to customer demands. Just a really great Wisconsin supper club!

They treat you like family. Running a little late, but our table was held as reserved. Food was enjoyed by all. Will definitely be back.

Great food..Very pleased with the service.. This place is the bomb.. I highly recommend it.. Please call head to make your reservations because they get busy..

First visit - Ron Faiola's Wisconsin Supper Clubs book brought us to the Stagecoach Inn. Super fun visit started at the bar with a couple of Wisconsin Classics - Brandy Old Fashioned, delicious. This place bustles with energy - from the greeting to the table service - everyone is on the move, some of the best teamwork I've witnessed in the food service business - congratulations for creating a wonderful dining experience. I have the pork tenderloins, cheeseburger soup, au gratin potatoes, house salad, and it all started with warm bread and the "salad tower". Fun presentation and delicious food. She had the deep fried shrimp and a baked potato - both delicious. We loved our visit, the serving team made us feel welcome and well treated, the food was delicious, and the locals provided us with great "color" on the history of the supper club...clearly the Stagecoach has earned the right to be included as one of Wisconsin's classic supper clubs - Enjoy your next visit, we sure did.