Carmella's Pizza Bazaar

This is some good pizza! Best I’ve had in quite some time. I literally had JUST found out about this place because another pizza restaurant I go to sometimes, was closed. I had a strong craving for some pizza and did a search for “best pizza near me”. I live in Richmond Heights but I’ve stayed in Euclid for about 15 years. Never heard of Carmella’s. I only ordered a medium pepperoni and mushroom pizza. It was so delicious!!! The crust was perfect and it just had the right combination of everything! Very reasonably priced! Cash Only

The last of a dying breed! Excellent PIZZA. My family has been eating PIZZA BAZAAR since the 70's. Still the same taste of great pizza I remember as a kid eating DIBELLA'S. THE SAME FAMILY. Carmella's the little pizza shop in Euclid. Well worth your time to grab a ZA there.

Carmella's is long established on the same corner in Euclid. All take out. Only cash. Great pizza!

The best pizza ever! Been going there since I attended Euclid H.S. Still as good today as back then.

If anybody grew up in NE Ohio and used to go to any Pizza Bizarre location (Streetsboro, or Carlo's in Aurora), then welcome to the "time machine"!!! This is the same pizza my brother and I ate back in the 80's! Same chain and same great people running it. IMPORTANT NOTE: CASH ONLY. So bring some green and enjoy a blast from the past!

Ordered a pepperoni's and sausage pizza. Honestly one of the better Pizza's I've had in the greater Cleveland area. Large pieces of fresh sausage and plenty of pepperoni. Also had that good tang that quality pizzas have. Place is a little hidden gem. Will definitely return.

Loved this pizza, ordered the Supreme. It was not greasy like other pizza I had.

This was a favorite of my husbands and now we as a.famoly see why. Great food that has been passed down from generations.

Excellent pizza, great old school.

I remember telling them my name and the first thing they said was Charles Bronson !! lol but I love mom and pops pizza 🍕

in this world of hipster high temperature stone oven pies, this pizza stands a true to their tried and true slow bake, old school ways … i dig it.
take out only … bring cash, no credit cards.

Another neighborhood classic! If you want great pizza look no further.

TOP TIER PIZZA- always friendly and consistently amazing pizza

Carmella's is a GREAT pizza. Every time. We moved into the area a few months ago and have probably ordered well over a dozen pizzas and there has never been a miss. That is hard to do. Ingredients out to the edge. Dough is always fresh. Dough is *cooked through*! Crust can support the toppings. Nice sauce, fine cheese. They do one thing and they do it so fricken' well. You want artichokes on your pie? Go away. Want something besides pizza? Go somewhere else. Want to charge the order? Nope, bring cash for the register that was probably used when they opened in '57. Classic.

Great pizza, place has been around for ages, so that comes with advantages and disadvantages. The good part is you get a time tested recipe with really good people running it. However, the place is cash only, doesn't have anything besides pizza, and doesn't deliver. That's not all bad though because it let's them focus on the pizza instead of credit card companies or drivers insurance. It is what it is. Bottom line is good pizza.

Best pizza I ever ate from kid to adult. Real Italian sausage not the hut nasty meatballs. This is the pizza you will enjoy eating ,even the crust is airy and crispy

Great pizza. I grew up in Euclid eating this pizza in the 80's and 90's, and now I live on the far west side, so I don't get there much anymore. Tonight I was in the area, so I ordered a medium pepperoni pre-bake, and finished it off in the oven when I got home. The directions to finish it off were simple enough (375 degrees for 6-8 minutes), and it was excellent.

The BEST Pizza I Ever Had ! . I've been Buying Pizza from Them Since 1966 !

I love Carmellas. BEST pizza in the Cleveland area. I always get a large deluxe and its always loaded with toppings and freshly grated cheese.
But to me, what makes them great is the customer service when you walk in. The workers are super friendly

First time customer and most definitely will not be my last time coming. The pizza was great and it brought back that old school/ childhood memory for me. A guy name Ken was nice and he accommodated my needs by adding on extra mushrooms at the last minute. Overall great services.