Lenny's Pizzeria & Trattoria

Great place to grab a slice or two while taking a break from driving. The slice were very hot, just the way I like them. The crust was thin and crispy, the sauce had a nice, fresh taste. The waitress was very nice. I would eat here again.

I’ve been coming here since 2003 - was 2 years old the first time. Lenny’s Pizza has been my and all my friends go-to slice for as long as I can remember. Same people still running the place after decades. Don’t know how this place could receive anything but 5 stars: providing an authentic & classy atmosphere for anyone dining in or stopping by and plenty of fresh options for anyone.

Come for the pizza and you won’t regret it!

This is a wonderful local pizzeria and Italian restaurant. We usually go for the Margarita pizza, which is thin-crust with very fresh toppings. A simple place, clean and friendly, with upbeat decor. A little pricey but fun, with a wall covered with old photos.

Great pizza, whole or by the slice. Also good menu of pastas and various Italian entrées, though they sadly removed all their veal dishes from the menu, which were excellent.

We ordered two pizzas to go from here and was told 20 minutes. I arrived at about the 19 minute mark and they were about to pull the pizzas out. The timing was sensational!

Also the pizzas were piping hot and perfect! The margarita had a good amount of basil, cheese and sauce. I hope to come back here every time I am in the area!

Best Margarita pizza ever, period. The Lazio chicken panini is amazing as well. They are consistently great for as many years as we know them. Really nice staff!

Great food! Their Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad is the best! Fabulous meatballs...a hard find...and great pizza. Their white pie is, again, one of the best!

This has become our new favorite neighborhood spot. Great pizza and lots of other great tasting items on the menu. Our kids love it too! The service was also great, food came out quickly and our server was very friendly.

All the food at Lenny's - not just the pizza - is fresh, extremely flavorful, and fabulously delicious. Try the Lazio panini, the square Grandma pie, any of the Stromboli, or the veal or chicken florentine; they're all worth every penny.

Wanted to say that Lenny's Pizza is the place to go! Friendly vibe from everyone there and you can't go wrong with anything you order. Had the wings, but always enjoy the different slices - margarita slice, the deluxe pie - these are among my favorites.

Always tasty. Order on line and quick pickup. When things are better, I look forward to eating in again. Nona's pizza is great. They have slices if you want a quick snack.

I am rarely impressed by NJ pizza. This one not only impressed me but I will certainly be going out of my way to return to eat here. Great Pizza, Great Crust, Great Customer Service, Great decor! As of now, my favorite pizza place in NJ. Highly recommend for casual dining and families.

Can’t go wrong here - Best pizza in this town! Going here for as long as it has been in business. It’s a community staple. Hours of operation are good. It’s always busy during the week and weekends day and evening.
Very good food!! No kidding the sauces are delicious! So many styles of pizzas! So many sandwiches and entrees to select from on the grand list of entrees. Food portions are amazing! Can’t finish - take it all home in their containers. They want to make you happy ! Background speaker music is faint and seems like old world Italian tunes. Menus are at each table and they are easy to read .
(One thing I will comment on that I don’t prefer or see is large margarita pies pre-made in advance by pizza crew and stacked to go into the oven & exposed to the air etc.. not covered and customers see this stacked display below the counter to the when at cash register.) I think all pizzas are made fresh when ordered. Most recently this restaurant has been updated on the interior of the restaurant. Looks terrific! The menu is really expansive and excellent. Welcoming atmosphere, call your order, or drop in - seems no reservation needed. Hot & cold food, drinks are cold, refrigerator or serve yourself from fountain or the glass case. The place is clean, working crew is polite and easy. Booths accommodate 4, front and back dining-room is accommodating for large groups. In winter don’t sit by the entry it’s a cold draft from customers opening and closing the entry door. CC or cash accepted and waitstaff is very attentive. Parking is avail in large lot in a redesigned shopping center Bernsrdsville PA. You can BYO as well, they will open your bottles or you can ask for an opener. Overall - it’s a family place and neighborhood restaurant that does donuts best to feed you their best food.

They have just excellent Margherita and meat lasagna. A few months ago, the quality went a bit down and the lasagna became fatty, but recently all came back normal, eg, great! Hey - has the cook came back? ;)
Hint - consider grilling the bread for lasagna. Just a bit.

I get their white pie with mushrooms, and it’s always good! Great local pizza place.

Really nice pizza. Several, maybe a dozen premade interesting selections. Hawaiian is great. The pepperoni is better than the normal. All good. I go once a week for lunch. Always good

Great food & Great service. We have loved Lenny's since the day we moved to Basking Ridge. It was our go to place for dinner while we demolished & renovated our kitchen in our new home. We've been going here for nearly 7 years now. <3

Flaco and Matt loved their pizza 🍕. I had a delicious roasted tomato soup. Place is clean, staff friendly. Will be back.

Very fresh roll excellent steak sandwich

I had a man named Bodie serve me. He was extremely helpful and made my experience wonderful. I will be dining here again.