Cornerstone Pizzeria

Landed here by chance but it was our lucky day we did. The service and the food was phenomenal. Marianna was a sweetheart, and she attended to our needs very nicely.

We had Muscles and two different pastas, and they were all out of this world! We live in North Jersey and I have not eaten such fresh and delicious food up there. Yes it’s a hole in the wall but you can go to a fancy restaurants that overcharges you but will not give you this kind of authentic flavors!

Looking forward to coming back every time we come near here.

This place was not even on the Pizza Hunters App list for the day, but we are glad that we had the chance to stop. Ronaldo was an amazing host, even took the time to bring 2 slices of pizza to the car. He was worried that if the plate from one slice touched the other it would ruin his slice. Wow. Talk about Pizza Pride. Well his slice really delivered. Hot, fresh slice with a delicious sauce and crust. The cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. This could be the best slice in Chester for 2019, but we will see what the final grades reveal on the Pizza Hunters App. The Customer Service and experience was excellent and we will be back. Thank You.

Ordered "The Special" pizza... Fantastic!!! Did not skimp on any of the toppings. I'm a new regular customer now.

Authentic Italian food, very good food, good service, it feels like family owned, because they are very accommodating and friendly, loved this place and its been like our 3rd time here, appetizers ,main dish ,and dessert, great food and great prices, see you again soon.

This place is the hidden gem in Long Valley. It's small, but the pizza is the best in town. What people don't realize is how fantastic the food is - definitely worth coming in for a sit-down dinner.

They're also involved in supporting the local community with sponsorships, etc. Such a great group of people!

I had the Buffalo Chicken Tenders and Chicken Parmesan over Capellini. First time there and I'd definitely go back.

Our family had a delicious meal here this afternoon after pumpkin picking. Our crew of six had yummy potato balls as an appetizer, then salmon, chicken balsamico, chicken roll, meatball sandwich, children’s spaghetti & meatballs, and bow tie pasta with butter. Service was great too. Would definitely dine here again!

After looking for a new pizza place due to increasing prices, I found Cornerstone Pizzeria which was recommended by a friend. And I gotta say, Cornerstone is definitely my go to pizza place from now on. I've only had to go, but it looks like and tastes like authentic jersey pizza. Delicious and great priced. Definitely worth the drive for their pies.

This place is amazing. The owners are originally from Sicily, and they serve up Jersey Italian food just like Mama would make it. Sometimes they even bring you free slices of pizza just because. The decor is nothing fancy, but it somehow ends up being cozy anyway and is part of the charm of the place. Their homemade soups are perfect on a cold winter day--especially the Tuscan bean!

We had a lovely experience for dinner here this evening. Sitting outside was so serene and relaxing compared to the hustle of NYC. We ordered the pasta fagioli soup, homemade lasagna, and special and capri pizzas. The food was definitely homemade and the ingredients so fresh!! When we are in the area again this will be our go to spot. Thank you for a wonderful dinner!

Solid pizza. Restaurant smelled great, but we only had a pie. Bottled beer only, but a good selection of it. Great staff. Owner's a true gem. Nice little patio area on the side too.

Their pizza is great and is our go-to. Prices are reasonable. Took our family here for a sit-down dinner, and it was absolutely fantastic. Couldn't ask for nicer food, or a better family/community restaurant.

The owner (or one of them) was nice enough to make a fresh pie for the two little kids I was babysitting even though they were set to close within 10 minutes. For being that last annoying customer with two tired and hungry children - I'm glad I ran into this place ❤

I've ordered so far from cornerstone pizzeria and both times I've gotten the Penne carbonarra and both times it was delicious like out of this world delicious the 2nd time was even better then the first, I would highly recommend them to anyone. And I've tried other pizzeria places in the Hackettstown long valley area and cornerstone is the best!

I've only ever ordered food for pickup and it's always been fantastic. Authentic Italian food made by authentic Italian folks.

The clams marinara is awesome. You will not fail to love this one. Love this place

Best Italian food, and pizza in the area, food is always fresh too. Friendly service, and a good choice of beers. Prices are very reasonable. Bring the whole family. Kids welcome.

This place is always a comfortable, low key, tasty place to get a meal. The owners are friendly, and the prices are reasonable. They also have an okay selection of beer, and cocktails. The only complaint is that it can get a bit loud when it gets crowded, because it's a small place.

Great pizza, and the staff was really friendly. Great place to stop at if you're driving through the area like we were. Sit by the windows and enjoy the view. :)

Stupendous and bellisimo! What a hidden 💎. The no thrills decor brings delicious pasta to the table and isn't that the point. Feels and tastes home-style. Yum! You certainly can't beat the prices.