The Old Bag of Nails Pub - Upper Arlington

Best fish and chips in town. Excellent fried pickles too!! Try the bread pudding if you have room for dessert.

Fish and chips are always the best in Central Ohio. You really can't go wrong. Going there getting fish and chips. On the side note it's also shareable. They give you enough where you can share and still leave not hungry. I also enjoy the fried mushrooms as well

New location is SO much better than the old one. I’ve always liked the food but the old location didn’t have many windows , was so dark and getting run down. This new location is a breath of fresh air. It’s a little tricky to find with the current construction but they have a huge parking garage real close. Fried pickles starter was awesome. Definitely will be visiting a look more frequently now!

Was craving fish and chips and Olde Bad of Nails didn’t disappoint!! Started with hand breaded mushrooms 🤤 🗣 to Ashley !! Amazing service!! Will be back!

Love the new location. Lots of charm. Same good food.

Big shout-out to The Old bag of nails crew. I ordered the Philly cheese steak and the fish n chips. Let me tell you something the food was 🔥🔥🔥 I've never tasted a Philly like theirs and it was cold. The fish as well cooked and seasoned to perfection. I plan on visiting soon! Thank you!✌🏿

The new attached pizza joint is excellent!

This is a great place to go for fish. They have very good food, and it is very large portions of fish that they serve. I have never left you're hungry as the portions are so big. The waiters and waitresses are great, as well as the bar staff.this is a great place to go whether as a family, a couple, a group of friends, or alone. If you love fish and chips, you cannot go wrong at this restaurant. Give them a try, I guarantee you'll be satisfied.

My Wife wanted to go here for her birthday and to meet with a friend from work. I ordered a pub salad with no bacon, and shredded cheese instead of blue cheese. I got a salad with chicken on top of it. I did not ask for chicken, I am pretty sure chicken is an option, but not one I as a vegetarian would use. I sent the salad back and the next salad was fine. My wife and her friend ordered fish dinners which both enjoyed. The battered fried mushrooms, one of my favorite dishes, was excellent. I also got a carrot cake which was also excellent.

Fish and chips were really good! A little more expensive than your church’s fish fry, but definitely tasty.

Had lunch there yesterday after attending the arts festival. There was only one server. I didn't catch her name. A young girl with her hair pulled back. She was exceptional. She had a smile on her face the entire time. She did not look stressed. She was kind and professional. Just wanted to say under the circumstances, she did an awesome job!!

Liked . Back in the past at other locations I was not happy with.

Excellent food and wonderful service!!

Additional visit: same wonderful service and very consistant in food prep. Had the shrimp and fish dinner and both items were cooked perfectly with crunchy coating and perfectly done seafood. Hot when brought to our table and tasty, tasty, tasty!! Love this place!!

Was told to try their Philly. We tried their fish and chips. Great. I would order them again and again. Was told we missed it that their Philly is so go and so is their French dip.

A gem of a location, so close to the library. Devin, I believe, was our server, and despite the healthy crowd of lunch-goers, we had excellent service and food.

One of my favorite haunts of all time! Bag of Nails delivers -- HANDS DOWN -- the best fish 'n chips in town. ANY town. But their signature dish is not all that is the superb. The menu supports a wide range of entrees and sides that are ( if not unique to this warm-hearted pub) ALL good. You can't go wrong, food wise, but the charm doesn't stop with the menu. The staff specializes in meeting your needs and requests with smiles and humor, and the variety of fine beer selections has something for everyone's personal quirkiness; and Bartender Kirk is knowledgeable, fun and able to easily handle requests for something beyond the extensive beer selection.

If you are looking for a place where you can kick back, relax and indulge in fabulous food, served with the plus of a true pub atmosphere -- look no further than this local Old Bag if Nails!

Best fish and chips ever. Go early for dinner

The Old Bag of Nails is always a good choice but the new Pizza Club @ the Tremont Center location with is the best. Excellent NY style pizza. The CSG girls that work there are very courteous and professional. Try it out!

Went on a friend's recommendation to try the businessman's lunch special, fish tacos, a side, and any beverage included. All for 9.99!! What a great place! Great server, food was excellent, I had a beer with my fish tacos, my friend had a milkshake, included!! My husband had a fish reuben, which was excellent. Don't miss this hidden gem, great food, great drinks, great service! Try it!

I love this place. It has a wonderful atmosphere and the food is great! I love the Fishermans Platter. The fish is AMAZING and they know how to cook shrimp and scallops. Not to mention that the staff is always the best. Can't wait for our next visit!