Sara's Sweets

What’s not to love about Sara Sweets?! Sara puts her heart into the food, her employees and this business! We get cookies or cupcakes for every holiday/family get together and our out of town guests always rave about her desserts! A staple in the community for the quality and their charitable hearts! Thank you, Sara Sweets!!

I wanted a simple naked cake with fall leaves for my moms 50th birthday, and Sara’s Sweets did not disappoint! It was beautiful all by itself! I did add some extras to it but by itself they did an amazing job!! And the taste did not disappoint! I highly highly recommend this place! Also when I went inside to pick up the cake they were very busy! One of the girls behind the counter stopped what she was doing to come help me! She was super friendly! I wish I had gotten her name! Take my word for it! This is the place to go if you need a custom cake!

Great locally owned bakery. I've always had fantastic treats here. Don't hesitate, stop in!

The cupcakes and cake for my granddaughters first birthday were perfect! The cake was a bit too dense to be used as a smash cake so we just let her tear it apart. Beautifully decorated and it fit the birthday theme "Wild One" perfectly!! This is my go to place for birthdays and will continue to be in the future. We were new to the banana cream flavor but it was amazing. My granddaughter proudly ate and wore it in her hair and tutu.

They also have a great variety of treats to avoid a lot of allergies. Best gluten free cookies I've had!

I needed a last minute cake while traveling through Ohio for my daughters 14th birthday. I have always made her cakes myself but couldn’t this year because we were away from home. I was hesitant to break tradition and also weary ordering from a bakery I knew nothing about—but we were not disappointed. The 6” cake was pricey ($44) but it was absolutely adorable and delicious. It was the highlight of our trip.

Sara’s Sweets Cupcakes are to die for!! We had Strawberry Crunch, Buckeye, Vanilla Raspberry, Half Baked and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. All of them are so so delicious. They looked amazing, tasted amazing. There were so many compliments for them on their flavors and appearance. The Strawberry Crunch is so freaking delicious!!
I HIGHLY recommend them.

Our family loves coming to Sara's Sweets! The staff is friendly, the treats are delicious and we love supporting a small local business!

Best bakery in Allen county and beyond.
Cupcakes, brownies, cookies everything tastes gourmet and well made and the best part it’s all super affordable. It’s so great to see a locally owned shop that keeps prices decent for all occasions.
The staff was super kind and the owner emailed me back right away with answers.

My wife rarely says if she truly likes something. If I ask, she usually responds with “ it’s ok” or “it’s alright”. We recently purchased some of Sara’s chocolate covered strawberries. As soon as my wife tried one she turned to me and said “that’s good”. I was shocked. All I know is if my wife says they’re good they must actually be amazing.

Very delicious items and everyone at our graduation party loved the mini cupcakes (Churro, Raspberry Vanilla, Blackberry Lavender and classic Red Velvet) and her fruity pebbles flavored cake!!

I've had some of the famous Georgetown cupcakes from D.C. and these are better! Worth every penny and the staff are so kind! They always have the best weekly specials, fun social media deals, and amazing decorated cakes. I always get these cupcakes for any celebration to share with everyone!

Excellent local bakery. Friendly, helpful staff. Extremely clean. Great selections. Cake decorating classes are so much fun. Support your local business.

Smells delicious. Tastes delicious. Customer service excellent!

Gluten free baked goods..... Yes please!

The gf chocolate cupcake with peanut butter frosting.... Woah, so good!

Chocolate chunk cookie (gf) is everything I want in a cookie.

Thanks for yummy products!!!

Simply awesome. Lemon sugar cookies are the best.

I ordered several cupcakes for my daughter's grad party and these were hands down the most moist and flavorful I have ever ate! All of the flavors were amazing and each one was beautifully decorated. We were all blown away with how tasty they were.🤤 The cupcakes were a hit at the party--folks wanted to eat those instead of the other food catered. 😂 Will definitely be ordering from here for any of my cake/cupcake or treat needs from now on! ❤ The Rumchatta was my fav!

Sara and her staff are always great. Loved the dark haired lady that helped me put in my sons cake order.

I placed a large order online for cookies for my office, expecting them to just be shipped the following Monday. We’re a good 45 minutes away from Lima. Sara called me shortly after and asked if she could deliver the cookies, and which day and time would be best. She also offered me a wider selection than I was able to select online, so I was able to get some St. Patty’s day cookies as well as another flavor that I requested. She drove all this way to hand deliver them and they were of course AMAZING. Can’t recommend this place enough! I plan on ordering again in the future, hopefully for our whole company next time. Thank you!!!

Great cupcakes! They are a great way to say thank you, birthday presents, or just when you want something sweet! The staff is always friendly and love the fact that they are so close by! Also my dog loves their pupcakes!

Best cupcakes in the area. They made our wedding cake and cupcakes and everything was amazing. We still stop in at least once a month to get sweets. Staff is always very polite. I recommend that everyone try it. You won't be disappointed.