Mario's Pizzeria

Best place to eat in Orange for quantity and quality, we wish we saw more people in Mario’s because it’s insanely good, it’s got some amazing Italian cuisine and you feel like you’re walking into Italy when you arrive, it’s a great place! The portions are HUGE, out of the 5 or 6 times we’ve come here we’ve never been able to finish, and it’s a pretty darn good price too! The staff are all very nice especially the owner, he’s very kind and always friendly, it’s a small town restaurant with big town quality, and I’d recommend anyone to Mario’s any day!

Fantastic pizza in a clean, cozy environment. Our server was very personable and attentive. We had a large New York style pizza with lots of toppings. It was crispy all the way to the center of the crust without being over done or burned. Very flavorful, so much so that I kept forgetting to add the parmesan and crushed peppers to my slices. I would highly recommend this place for great pizza and quick service with a smile.

Great, fast service. Eggplant parm was great. Best spaghetti I've ever eaten. 😋 And excellent, fresh bread.

We travel from Louisa County to Mario’s. Their food is wonderful and consistently delicious. My granddaughter says they have the best pizza she ever had!

The service was really quick, and the food was delicious! I ordered a small sweet BBQ chicken pizza and still had leftovers! The garlic knots and cowboy bites were also delicious

Excellent restaurant. The food was more than plenty. We were surprised to see how big the portion sizes were. We had a party of eight and our server was great. Found out he is the owner too and took time to chat with us. The food was tasty and we really enjoyed the atmosphere. Loved it will be back many times again. Thanks.

Best pasta dishes in this area! Their sauce is delicious and their homemade bread is out of this world! Best we’ve had since we lived in NJ!!!

If you haven't tried Mario's, get here quick! Huge menu, excellent homemade fare from pizza to stromboli to delicious dinners. Our favorite spot!

NEW OWNERSHIP AS OF DECEMBER 2018 – EXCELLENT
Mario’s is now far more than a pizza place. It is a home of true Italian hospitality, where each guest table is offered a delicious warm, crusty, artisan loaf, made from scratch in-house that morning, and served with butter. (This is an age-old Italian welcoming tradition called Pane Sul Tavolo: bread on table.) If you came in for this bread alone, you would not be disappointed: soft white interior with tender-crisp crust and old-world flavor and aroma…heavenly. :-) But you will also find a hospitable owner, a full Italian menu (pasta, salads, seafood…please see photos), fair prices, friendly, efficient service (ask for Dawn, if she is there), and…awesome, literally-hand-tossed-crust pizza. A relaxing dining experience from start to finish. We enjoyed pizza this time (and watching them toss the crust)—a tender-crisp crust with savory, fresh toppings served piping hot--and we plan to return for gnocchi and other Italian specialties. Add to all of this, great hours and a group-friendly, family-friendly, large, airy, clean, attractive Mediterranean interior…a winning combination. We love it. :-)

Wow, I am Italian I have family recipes from Italy 🇮🇹, my cousin used to run the number rated Italian restaurant in Aspen for years. I know Italian food… I just ate half a plate (they give you a ton of food) of their paste primavera with a side of meatballs added to the food. OMG where has this place been hiding!! 👍👍The spinach, olives, and mix of peppers was perfect.

First time there, the fresh warm bread was the best! Very good pizza, great service, pleasant staff

Great pizza, some of the best I had in VA. The sandwich was amazing also.

Great food, love the vibe. Went with my mom amd brother for an early dinner.

The owner was very nice and welcoming, and the food tasted so good

Delicious food at a good price. I highly recommend it

Very good food and fast too. The service was a bit slow after we got our food. We waited a while for our check and ended up walking to the counter to pay because we had waited to long. Otherwise the food was great.

Always best option for pizza in Orange County, Va. Great prices, fast delivery, and top notch pizza!

Great pizza, have been a very satisfied
Customer for 22 years.

Yummy as always, great service, we will see them again soon

Loved everything about this place!! Very nice staff! Food was great, it was soo good, we came back the next day.