Fatboy's Pizza Shack

Delicious pizza and wedges. Highly recommend the steak wedge. Chicken Parm wedge was 3/5 but steak was 5/5! 3 wedges was sufficient to split between 2 adults
Friendly staff, offers outdoor dining with a nice view.

Get on the western Maryland railroad from Cumberland to Frostburg. When you get to Frostburg, make the 5-minute walk up to Fatboy’s. It will be worth it. Good food. Good people. 3 of 5 on atmosphere because it was the middle of the day on a Saturday. Food is standard pizzeria fare, but very good. Good selection of drinks. Some good home made cookies and brownies. “These are SO GOOD,” was all my five year old could say. She didn’t leave any to take back home to mom. That’s how you know it’s good.
Owners are clearly Christian, but the good kind. Not pushy. Served people from different walks of life while we were there.

Use to get pizza. This time I got a steak wedge and it was fantastic! Lots of meat, very flavorful, I would recommend it. Great price too.

Ate here again, got a Supreme pizza and a 20 ounce drink for less than 6 bucks. Pizza was really good.

Update May 2023 : This time I got winds. They are amazing. $10.00 for 12 wings? Nobody has a deal like that!! And they are amazing! Not overcooked, great flavors, I cant believe how good they are!! I've tried two flavors and both were great! Plus, they are vey nice people as well. Not required but a nice bonus.

Hi - this is mstar pos. You still have our equipment, you arent answering our emails but I see you do respond to review. Can you get in touch with us and use the shipping label we created and send it back?

Great food and kind staff! They have a beautiful mural painted by Elijah Thane! :)

The food was really good, if you leave there not feeling like a fat boy or fat girl, that's your own fault 😂 I would recommend stopping there to eat. You won't leave hungry. And the pizza crust was thin just the way I like. And I loved the blue cheese dressing.

Food was great w/amazing service. They brought our food right to us, then came around afterwards to see how our meal was. Their house made Italian dressing was quite nice w/good prices on the food; recommended stop!

My favorite Frostburg pizza. Delicious food and friendly service done with family-owned pride. Always a satisfying experience. Always.

Really good food and I really like the steak and cheese wedgies.

delicious pizza and amazing salads! the cheese is always just right on the pizza and it’s always perfectly cooked. huge bonus that they love God and aren’t afraid to show it! we need more people like that! plus love how kind the owner is to do a toy drive and free pizzas during COVID. may God bless you infinitely!

We loved it. Great pineapple and sausage pizza. Big enough for the 2 of us and tasty. Only regret: my wife usually gives me her extra slice and no way this time. We devoured it equally. Very nice people with an ESCAPE ROOM next door. I want more of their pizza NOW.

Went here a week ago to order pizza and this is by far my favorite pizza place in the area now. The food was fresh and had incredible flavor. By far some of the best tasting pizza I've had from a local restaurant and I definitely plan on making regular visits here from now on. If you're looking for a place to dine in however, this place does not feature a dining room. However if you don't mind going for carry out or delivery, it is absolutely worth it. The workers are very friendly as well so that's always a huge plus. I highly recommend getting pizza here.

Fat Boys is a great spot to stop for lunch along the GAP trail. Most of our biking group (26 riders) opted for the lunch buffet+drink, which offered a wide variety to choose from including: soup, salad, pizza, and dessert sticks. This place is definitely worth the climb up the hill...those less daring can lock up their bikes at the train depot and walk up the hill. Would definitely recommend this place!

Really nice workers!! The food is awesome and the prices are better then most pizza shops. They also have escape rooms to solve with family or friends.

I like to go here when I ride the train from Cumberland, which is once or twice a year. The pizza was absolutely delicious! The owner (he looked like the guy on the box but was not fat lol) seemed like a great guy to deal with. The dining room was closed so we ate outside. It was very windy so that wasn't great, but overall this is a good pizza place.

I have loved this pizza joint since it was established. The family who owns it is very friendly and are locals. The food is amazing and the buffet was always great. I miss the buffet , no offense , but escape rooms don’t really have much appeal to me .

I'm not a pizza eater at all but I will say this place has the best pizza I have ever ate,very nice people Everytime I go in there everyone is so nice a polite now that I eat their pizza I eat there 2 times a month and enjoy every bite of it keep up the good work love this place if you haven't tried Fatboy's pizza you need to bye far the best pizza ever and the boneless wings are amazing also 👍👍

Great pizza and great service. Missed the buffet but have had it in the past. Great value for soup, salad, pizza, and wings

Was running a little behind on time and where we planned to eat had too long of a wait. We found this shop online and decided to give them a try. The gentleman up front was super nice and helpful. They had us hot pizza and cold drinks in about 10 mins and we made it in time to catch the polar express train we booked. The pizza was delicious and we would definitely stop in for food again when in the area. Thank you Fatboy's for the great service and food!

I live in Cumberland and will make the drive to frostburg with no hesitation to spend my money here. Your talking about a business that in the heat of a pandemic stepped up right away and gave meals for the kids knowing kids were going without sense school was out… Then stepped up and offered a “whatever is in your pocket” offer to people struggling during the pandemic. I will always choose to spend my money here. The customer service is always awesome! You can see the pride they take in the job they do and it reflects in every aspect of your order. From the presentation of the food to the amazing taste! If your ever curious of a place to eat and are in the Allegany County area make that trip to Frostburg. You won’t be disappointed!!!