HMC

Fork & Anchor

Restaurant in Shelter Island

Updated: February 13, 2024 07:22 AM

Fork & Anchor is located in Shelter Island (Town in New York State), United States. It's address is 8955 Main Rd, East Marion, NY 11939.

8955 Main Rd, East Marion, NY 11939

4MG5+PC East Marion, New York

Questions & Answers


Where is Fork & Anchor?

Fork & Anchor is located at: 8955 Main Rd, East Marion, NY 11939.

What are the coordinates of Fork & Anchor?

Coordinates: 41.1268328, -72.3413918

Fork & Anchor Reviews

Molly Homchenko
2019-01-14 22:53:54 GMT

Absolutely love this little shop. Great for a quality, quick bite before or after the ferry ride! Great sandwiches and coffee. Breakfast sandwiches were amazing, as were the pastry. I appreciate the local goods for sale - not sure if the rest of the food is locally sourced, but it is delicious. Service was always fast and accurate.

Diane Katsikas
2017-09-25 23:32:08 GMT

I recently had a wonderful of experience dealing with Erin at fork and anchor for our after dinner party at my daughter's wedding and then brunch on Sunday!
When the food arrived on Saturday evening you would've thought no one would have room to eat more , but if I tell you that six-foot heroes were gone in 30 minutes and they were talking about it all night after that!!
Then we had the most fabulous five Acura has with bacon and mayo and fresh tomatoes and salad's on Sunday that I can't say enough good things about!
I would highly recommend them for any party event or just go in for sandwiches they are delicious !!

Joe Jarvis
2020-08-08 20:02:03 GMT

Great place to get quick and amazing sandwiches. They have really cool takes on traditional fare like adding their delicious basil mayonnaise or using farm fresh veggies. Just delicious.

Jacqueline Tinant
2018-05-11 13:55:53 GMT

One of the best BEC sandwiches I've had - its apparent from the taste alone that they're all of high quality/organic products. Coffee is just as good!
Anytime I'm on the North Fork for work, I'll always make an effort to stop here!

Orridgenal
2016-06-24 23:40:17 GMT

Great breakfast and lunch spot! We stopped in to pick up sandwiches to take to the beach and weren't disappointed. Roast beef sandwich and crispy chicken sandwich great value and delicious.

Tom S
2018-07-20 15:06:26 GMT

Breakfast burrito was probably the best I've ever had. I couldn't recommend this place highly enough. I'd make the hour and a half drive out there from my house to eat it again. The only downside of the place was I was not from the neighborhood and I felt a lot of eyes on me, that's through no fault of the place though.

Fran Levine
2014-07-09 19:21:25 GMT

nestled on the side of north road, this oasis of epicurean delights is home of 2 women who really know how to prepare gourmet foods. their grocery selection matches their ready to eat and custom cooked food items like a glove. their generous sandwiches are full of fresh stuff that will make this a regular stop for you. i have enjoyed their food since they opened and continue to be amazed by their ability to satisfy. great stopping place.

Zach Roman
2021-06-03 19:34:45 GMT

Very good sandwiches (highly recommend the crispy chicken sandwich). The baked goods are also amazing (Apple fritter is hands down my favorite).

Jared Ring
2021-03-18 18:53:48 GMT

Why do you have customers standing outside in the cold on the street to order and wait for food?

Yes, I understand your concerns for safety however it's now 2021. Your staff utilize disinfectant, masks and gloves. No other deli on the North Fork acts like your staff. I can understand if it was March 2020 and people were unprepared or had no PPE, but turning your store in to a 'food window' by barricading the front door is completely ridiculous behaviour and I'm not standing on the street like a fool waiting for food. What next? Order by smoke signals? Food bags on a fishing pole?

Wilfred E Joseph
2015-12-08 15:13:47 GMT

Fork and Anchor offers some of the best sandwiches on the North Fork. My favorite of the BLT.
I have also had to utilize their box lunches nd my guests have been blown away by
the quality, variety and the taste of their pfferings.
The staff is always courteous and friendly

Stu.
2020-10-30 15:49:43 GMT

Best breakfast sandwich ever!!! Not enough superlatives ....order the fork and anchor sandwich and just let the enjoyment begin. Even if you have no reason to be on the N. Fork Drive out there anyway

TGeorge Walkden
2020-03-03 13:48:07 GMT

Looks are deceiving! Went in with reservations and came out a convert. Terrific sandwiches and excellent selection of other munchies. Will definite go back next time I'm in the area.

Marie Barron
2021-03-28 15:16:41 GMT

Best croissant I've ever tasted! Can't beat chocolate and almond paste together in a flaky pastry.

Jeanne Adams
2017-06-22 18:56:07 GMT

Fabulous coffee and croissant. Killer cinnamon rolls. Great service! I truly appreciated the assistance booking the ferry.

Vincent Esposito
2017-12-19 17:38:18 GMT

Stopped by for a Sandwich on the way to the Ferry in Orient. It was one of the top 10 of my life. Well done and thanks from a hungry traveller.

Michael F
2019-05-26 11:19:41 GMT

Great spot. Local eggs and coffee were delicious way to start the day. Friendly people too

Bruce Hoffner
2017-12-08 01:27:54 GMT

O M G LOVE love love it. I'm hooked fast and Spactacular food! Wish they had Sign I could see I'm 64.

Damian Benitez
2019-11-19 23:16:12 GMT

Get the spicy chicken sandwich!! Might seem pricey but it's a big sandwich and fresh made chicken

Lydia Irving
2017-06-01 16:15:47 GMT

A lovely little place to stop for coffee, delicious sandwiches, sweets, snacks and other household items.

Liz Gillooly
2019-09-13 16:19:38 GMT

Fresh, delicious food. An excellent place for breakfast and lunch.

Write a review of Fork & Anchor


Fork & Anchor Directions
About Shelter Island
Town in New York State

Shelter Island is an island town in Suffolk County, New York, United States, near the eastern end of Long Island. The population was 3,253 at the 2020 United States census. source

Top Rated Addresses in Shelter Island

Addresses Near Shelter Island