Gumby's Pizza

Late night pokey sticks are amazing when you're in college and when you're reliving your college days! They haven't changed and may even have gotten better. Delicious!

The best wings I've ever had in my life. Like eating angels wings. It's as if the wings were touched by Jesus himself before being fed to me on a golden platter. Genuinely the happiest day of my life since the birth of my child. 50/10.

This place was super good. The pizza was hot and yummy. One of the workers here is super sweet and got his daughter a pink switch for her birthday. Service was great

If you go in person, the bufflo wings are super good.

Gumby's is awesome! The employee at store in Greenville NC night shift is so caring and animated, he remains professional but makes me laugh lol. He works hard and is a one man pizza making army. I never seen someone run a whole restaurant by themselves. HE SHOULD BE MANAGER!

Gumby’s is great!!!! Food is exceptional and service is great too. Staff was friendly my order was ready quickly the food was fresh the store was very clean. 10 out of 10 I highly recommend they literally have the best pizza in town.

Everyone is super friendly! The staff definitely makes you want to come back. The food is also tasty.

Updated after messaging with owner and trying again.

Pokey Stix are amazing, been enjoying them since the old place staffed by stoners 20 years ago. Had some trouble but it seems the new ownership:management is getting back to basics and doing a good job. I’ll leave my old review for reference, but this is definitely back to being one of my go to’s for comfort food. It’s greasy, cheesy, high calorie goodness, as it very well should be.

Old Review
Used to be my splurge to get pokey stix until my last interaction this spring. Delivery driver didn’t show up to his shift I guess, had to go pick up my order and wanted the delivery fee and tip removed from the charge. I was told I could either take the order or get a refund, no in between. I told them I’d take the refund as the delivery fee and tip was over $20. I was told it’d take 5 days for the refund. Two weeks later they still hadn’t started so I had to do a charge back. The manager was rude, didn’t do what they said, haven’t eaten here since. I hope management changes because I’ve stayed away since. Sometimes people have bad nights, but that doesn’t mean they can take it out on others and trying to steal.

Update - Ownership reached out and acknowledged my experience, sounds like they’re making an effort, I’m gonna give it another shot and will update my review then.

I honestly don't have much to say other than the pizza was so good! It was made fresh, came out nice and hot, and the flavor was on point. Do come check this place out. You wont regret it, trust me!

Great place to eat prices are such a deal better than dominos or papa johns

My first-time to this restaurant. I got a slice of pepperoni pizza. It was so good. They have great prices and they sell wings also. The young lady who waited on me was so nice, with good customer service skills, I had to tip her, I love great customer service.

People here are so friendly!!! And the pokey sticks are delicious! I had a wobbly tire and one of the employees helped us out with a jack and lug nut wrench. So nice!!!

The service is great and the gentleman that helped me is a very nice gentleman.

He said his name was kait. Highly recommend.

Don't let the appearance fool you, this is great pizza. Good quality and amazing taste. And don't just get the pizza, some of the lesser known menu items are da bomb diggity. The pastas are a favorite.

Jeremiah was on point, good place to grab some food late nights

your great worker Patric was amazing and very patient with me

Went there just last night and can confirm, it's the best spot for hand tossed pizza locally. When you need good pizza at or before 2am, they've got you covered.

Best shop around!! Great food n service!

The guy that we order from was very nice and polite

Came in and was immediately greeted by a warm welcoming atmosphere. Customer service was excellent and payment was quick. Fantastic as always.