Nicolo's Chicago Style Pizza

This place has an old school feel to a pizza restaurant - redefining Mom and Pop pizza shops. The menu here is also different than other pizza shops - that alone is worth stopping in to check out not just the business itself but also the delicious smells the restaurant also emits. I also can't forget that this business serves alcoholic beverages! Wow! The only thing missing here are TVs, salad bar and an actual bar!!!

The calzone was incredible. So was the fettuccine Alfredo. The sandwich was also absolutely incredible - the Italian Beef.

Courtney's Pizza to-go was also fire. I also might recommend that the calzones, pizzas and subs and possibly the wings be well done for the best overall review.

Thank you Avi for making our first dine in experience worth remembering. Avi was very attentive and gave us the best customer service in the corner of the pizza shop. Always refilling soda and always checking to see how we are doing!

I am also curious to see the delivery service here to see if it is as great as the dining in.

Much love to the Niccolos Pizza and we very much look forward to supporting this local small business!

From a well known local reviewer and fan of all pizzas alike,

Chris & Christina

Great food. Been eating here for years. They do a fantastic job of being gluten friendly (shared kitchen, so not completely free by my celiac wife has never had an issue). Never had a bad meal, and the times we've dined in have always been pleasant. 10/10 would recommend.

We went at a quiet time and enjoyed every minute. It was a Blast from the past...I felt like I was watching Marty McFly back home in my small room in Northside of Chicago in 1987. The pizza was so Chicago, the Italian beef was so Chicago, da pasta, da pizza sauce, da old-school macaroni, da WINGS...so CHICAGO!!! GREAT TIME!

First and foremost I received excellent service from Bella. She was extremely nice with an incredibly friendly personality. When I came in for my food I was greeted with a smile and was taken care of through and through. Secondly, the food was fantastic. I had a meatball sub and it has to be hands down one of the top ten best meatball subs I've had.

Great comfort food and excellent service! Bella made our evening really nice with her sweet and fun attitude! She has an exceptional sense of humor and handled everything that came her way with grace!

Our orders have always arrived sooner than expected and HOT. This time we had an error. It happens, we're all human. I called and both people I talked to were very polite and apologetic. I'm sorry, I didn't get their names, but they made things right. I won't go into details, as I believe each establishment should be able to do things on an individual basis. The fact is they cared and went beyond making it right. We have tried several things here and it's all been good. Everyone has different tastes, so if you haven't tried them, Please do.

I ordered take out through Uber Eats
The gluten free spaghetti is absolutely delicious! I will definitely get it again! If I am nearby the location I will definitely go to this restaurant and eat.

A very nice place for pizza and a selection of pastas with great flavor. I find myself going out of my way to visit Nicolo's at least once a week or so for their great cuisine and service.
I've been going for the pasta which is my favorite. The marinara sauce is great. Thick and not runny, very tasty. Next visit... the pizzas are my targets 😉
Update- pizzas 🍕 are awesome. I love they have a gluten-free option.

I recommend this place to almost everyone I meet (and end up in a casual conversation about pizza with.) It's my favorite pizza in Colorado and likely yours as well. I have only had positive experiences here; even though, I generally order to go. Just try it. You wont be disappointed.

Niccolos is the best! It’s a slice of my hometown and I would recommend to anyone from Chicago or the Midwest. It’s the only true Chicago style pizza I’ve had in the Denver metro area.

Best meatballs and Alfredo sauce you can get in a restaurant! ALSO the single best vegan pizza I’ve ever had…a lot of vegan za is like plastic melted on cardboard, not this one! It was almost indistinguishable from their meat and cheese version, except it might be BETTER!

I had not ordered here previously. I called our order in and the gal on the phone was very nice and patient. She didn't rush me at all. The chicken alfredo calzone was deeeelish. And the calzones are huge and did not skimp on toppongs. We definitely. Got our money's worth. The salad was very good too but the container is too small. The cannoli did not have enough filling at all. The cheesecake was very good but I think small for the price. The mozzarella sticks were good. I would get extra marinara next time. It was very flavorful.
They said it would be an hour for delivery and it was much quicker. I will definitely be coming back.

Stopped in for an early dinner and had an awesome experience. Delicious pizza and cold beer, gonna have to come back to try their pasta and calzones! Thank you!

Had an amazing $60 meal for 3. There chicken Alfredo calzone is to die for and they have a kids menu that's fair. Appetizers too expensive just order the meals! Have to say the New Italian Margarita was to die for.

Some of the best pizza in town!! I wish we had one closer up north.

We love our neighborhood Nicolo’s. The service is always great, the food is reliably tasty, and the atmosphere makes us feel nostalgic like the pizza places we grew up going to

Great family friendly atmosphere and yummy simple food! The service was fast and polite. They even gave me a free ranch for my pizza. The dining room is very clean as well. Will be back for sure!

Oh my gosh! If you haven't tried nicolos yet, you're missing out! I'm a huge fan of their calzones! Yes, they charge upwards of $16 per calzone but they're so big and full of ingredients, that you could easily feed 2 people with it! They're fresh and use the best meats and cheeses! We highly recommend this place! We've also dined in the restaurant and the staff is friendly and welcoming! Well be back again!

Megan makes the best Italian Margaritas! Pairs great with a GF crust Courtney (substitute the jalapeño for peperoncini).

I've been eating their delicious pizza for abou!t 15 years. I hadn't had their calzone till tonight. It was so big it filled both my wife and I! It was so cheesy, and the sausage and mushroom just melted in your mouth! Definitely a game changer.