Ultimate Pastry Shop

Family favorite. We love their flamingo shaped cookies. The icing is truly the best. Their shapes and designs are always so fun. My family is always looking for an excuse to get these cookies. For my bridal shower my mother in law got cookies from here that were shaped like teacups. They were a huge hit! I recommend everything here but especially the buttercream icing cookies.

My daughter and I have ordered about 5 cakes within the past 5 months “just because.” Love your cakes, they’re absolutely delicious, especially the chocolate chip filling and whipped cream frosting. Started ordering from your bakery back in the early 2000’s and will continue to do so.

The cookies are absolutely amazing. The banana one and the frosted oatmeal are to die for. I went in last minute for a holiday party I needed to bring a dessert to and these were a huge hit. Also $11 for a dozen of huge cookies is extremely affordable! I’ll definitely be back.

Bill and his crew are awesome and truly value their customers. We worked with them for our wedding cake and couldn't of been more pleased with it. It was a work of art.

Excellent Bakery w very friendly Staff, go to place for cookies, brownies & muffin tops and not overpriced

I ❤ this bakery! The staff is warm, friendly and accommodating. Everything in this store is delish. I had them make and design the cake for my daughter in laws baby shower- it was both delicious and beautiful! See below!

I was recently introduced to The Ultimate Pastry Shop when a student brought in a Kings Cake for class. IT WAS AMAZING! We ate the entire thing between four people. I took a chance by ordering a birthday cake in March and it was such a hit with the entire family it has now become our go to for all family cakes movong forward. I called on a Wednesday to place an order for the upcoming Saturday. They were happy to make a dinosaur cake which I left the icing flavor up to them to best accommodate my 3 year olds request for dinosaurs. They even asked me if I wanted realistic or cartoon type! They are top notch. The cake tastes as good as it looks. I am looking forward to placing orders this coming holiday season. One thing, due to the pandemic, they have limited hours and selection. Best to call ahead!

This place is amazing! I have gotten my sons birthday cakes from here the last 2 years, and I will not go anywhere else! The prices are good and the cakes are delicious!

Wow this is hands down the best Bakery in the United States Amazing iam very impressed. Good prices. The staff is extremely friendly .keep up the excellent work iam glad iam just down the road.

Absolutely love, love their Gluten Free options!!! I do not have celiac disease, I have an intolerance, so I can risk the possible cross contamination. If you are in the same boat GO GET SOME!!!

Everything I've ever gotten has been fresh and delicious. I love the variety of baked goods. My very favorite is the lemon cupcakes, or the iced cookies, or the thumbprints or...pretty much everything, lol.

We had the bakery shop make us six dozen macaroons for a graduation party in all different flavors. Not only were they delicious, they were reasonably priced and large. All of the macaroon connoisseurs at the party said they were the absolute best macaroons they had ever tasted. Highly recommend. They also make delicious and large iced teas

We ordered a birthday cake and were pleasantly surprised with the decoration of the cake. It was fresh and the icing and cake tasted great! 😋

Super delicious pastries! Everything tastes like it's from fresh and real ingredients. If your craving a flaky pastry you have to go here.

Really love coming here. The staff is always extremely friendly. Our kids love their cookies, and my wife loves their cheese danishes. If we are going to visit any of our family nearby, we always pick up something here to bring with us. I think what really keeps us coming back to this bakery is the day old section which is so reasonably priced. Definitely keeps us coming back!

After doing a tasting, the cake was just so good we ordered our wedding cake AND my bridal shower cake from here. The staff is very friendly and helpful and they worked with me to come up with a beautiful design for my wedding cake. Even guests at my bridal shower were asking where the cake was from because they loved it so much! In addition to the cake, their pastries and other goodies are delicious too. Each time I stopped in to discuss the cake, I walked out with a bag of goodies! In addition to the food being amazing, the pricing is great too!

Great Bakery! Cookies are fantastic !!! Have a nice selection of dairy free and gluten-free items. Can also order dairy and gluten-free cakes with advance notice. Stop in for a real treat!!!

This place is sweet! With a family split across various levels of gluten tolerances, they have something for everyone. The pastry selections and cookies are delicious. Their cakes are very good and they always get the order perfect. Added bonus: my daughter's favorite animal is the flamingo and the Ultimate Pastry Shop is loaded with them!

A Sewickley staple… Some of the best treats in Pittsburgh!

Over the past 15 years I have ordered all my birthday and special event cakes from the Ultimate Pastry Shop. They make the best cakes! My family and guests are always impressed with not only the cake decorations but also, and especially, the flavor. I love their whipped cream icing and different choices of cake filling. I highly recommended this local pastry shop for their great product and friendly staff.