Pizzarelli’s Pizzeria

Was reluctant at first, but I'm glad my better half decided that we were going to try as we have never been. As we entered, we were greeted with a simple and soft welcome, we looked at the menu and decided to try a NY style crust, best decision by far! The toppings were perfect for the pizza, not overwhelming, the taste was great and will definitely come back.

What a delicious place. Looking for a pizza place that wasn't a chain place we stumbled upon Pizzarelli's. Upon entering we were greeted immediately by the wonderful aroma and then by the staff. The staff was very friendly and they have many regulars as apparent by the conversations that were over heard. Staff knew customer names and drink orders with out asking. We ordered a 10" personal New York hand tossed spicy sausage pizza, a 10" Chicago thin crust pepperoni, and an order of fried pickles. The fried pickles were Pickle spears and not Pickle chip a nice change and very pickley. The chicken wings come highly recommended, and we will get them on our next visit. They have lunch specials under $10. Which we will also have the next visit. They have bottled soda & fountain Pepsi drinks. They also have bottled wine.
Both pizzas were very chessey. Everything was delicious. We each left with half of our pizzas There were a few booths and 3 tables. A good place to meet friends and family. this place is located in a strip plaza with plenty of parking. You need to check this place out and once you do you will become a regular 😉

I took one bite & I am already thinking about going back. The NY style pizza is just fantastic. Crust is perfect, crunchy, chewy. I am kicking myself for not going sooner. I grew up in Northern NJ and this just tastes EXACTLY like home. Their house Italian dressing is addicting.

This is by far the best pizza place around. I’ve ordered here several times and have never been disappointed. My go-to is the NY style and it is delicious! Tonight I decided to try the Chicago deep dish and omg it is soooooo good!!

Pizzarellis is one of the best around. Always enjoy their pizza and their salads. You can tell it's not the pre-cut bagged lettuce with cabbage and carrots in it. They load the garden salad up with mushrooms, white onion, housemade Croutons and much more! I'd be hard pressed if there is a better NY style pizza around.
Keep these family owned places around that make up the fabric of our towns.

Delicious pizza! My wife and I live about 5-10 minutes away and had never heard of this place until recently. We decided to give it a shot tonight and we both absolutely loved it - the pizza and the cheese sticks.

We will definitely be back.

Best NY pizza in the area. I order from them about once a month and it’s always so good. The wings and spaghetti are also really great!

If you're looking for a great local pizza place this is it! You can have New York style pizza, thin crush Chicago, or deep dish Chicago! The sauce is fantastic, the pizza is delicious, the mozzarella sticks were gooy, but more importantly the people who work here are kind and friendly! They provided a great service and wonderful atmosphere. I will be back ! :) - we got the Chicago deep dish meat deluxe.

This place is great! Best pizza in the area by a large margin. Crust is crispy but chewy like New York style should be. Cheese is flavorful and the toppings are fresh. And the prices! $10.99 for a large cheese pizza. You can't beat it for the quality.

Another unassuming gem of a restaurant. I split a 14" New York style Deluxe pizza and it was more than enough for two people. I also had an order of the jalapeno poppers. The poppers were tasty and the pizza was terrific. I like the fact that they use slide sausage and slided veggies. I don't see that a lot and I appreciate the extra effort that goes in to it. The price paid for the quality of the food was a total steal.

The appetizers were fried to perfection! The toasted ravioli had fresh ground beef, seasoned wonderfully! There was a nice CRUNCH!

The pizza crust was baked fluffy and everything settled so well! I will be back again!

Fantastic little pizza place! The margarita pizza was amazing 👏 and the Chicago deep dish was wonderful, both highly recommended!

They have the choice of new york style, thin and thick chicago style. All fresh ingredients! They get their sausage from chicago :)

I ordered a sausage and mushroom deep dish. It not 100% traditional butter crust for chicago deep dish. HOWEVER the crust was twisted and delicious.

Best in the area, if you like NY style pizza, this is the place. The team is fantastic, you're always greeted with a smile. I can't say enough about how delicious it is. The toppings, the thin crispy crust baked to perfection. They do have other styles of pizza, but for me nothing beats a NY Style.

Always fresh and delicious pizza and mozzarella sticks. Delivery is always on time !

Omg! Great, great, great pizza!!! I can't wait to visit again! We tried 3 of the 4 different types of crust, and they were all outstanding! Chicago thin was my favorite. Go there and dine in, you'll be happy you did! They also have beer and wine.

This is our family's new go-to pizza place! Our favorite is the deep dish meat pizza and an appetizer sampler! Weve had their pasta, meat balls, dessert....everything is fantastic! We love that they offer their own delivery (no third party) and the quality is always 10/10.

I can't say enough great things about this place. I'm very jealous of people who live close enough for pick up and delivery. The fact that 3 people run this place like a well oiled machine says so much. The food was sooooo delicious. Very fresh toppings, the sauce has a nice zip to it, the mozzarella is amazing and the crust....they make their own dough. It is chewy and crunchy. Perfection. Can't wait for another date night here!!! And the prices are pre inflation prices. XL pizza. 2 beers, mozzarella sticks for $40.00 that is phenomenal!

I’m a fan. Their Chicago thin is the closest to the real deal that you will find in St Louis. Made with mozzarella not fake provel like other pizzas here. Highly recommend.

I am rating this 5 stars even though our Chicago-style Meatball deep dish came without the meatballs; that is how good the pizzas we had were. We tried both the deep dish and the NY style and both were cooked to perfection. The dough on both styles was very authentic like you were ordering straight from CHI or NYC. We will definitely be adding this to our Friday night rotation.