Cusumano

Absoutely amazing! Everything tasted very fresh and prices were fair. The apps, entrees, and desserts were all very good. The downstairs is a nice relaxed atmosphere and the bartender was super nice and helpful in sharing information about the restaurant and town in general. Will certainly be back!

I have been going to this restaurant for some time now and absolutely love it. On some weeks, I am there more than once, and as I read some of these reviews, I can pick out what tables there are just by their behavior and the way they treat the staff. I have not had one bad experience here and will continue to be a customer. If I had to describe this restaurant in one word, it would be awesome, awesome food, awesome portions, and awesome drinks. Keep up the good work to the entire staff.

One of the best meals I have had in a long time. Definitely a top tier restaurant. Veal Marsala was fantastic. White pizza spectacular. Cannot wait to return

Great service and fantastic food.
The homemade desserts are amazing!
Waited a few minutes for our table but that is expected and absolutely worth the wait.

Food was excellent and the service was fantastic. Wait was a little bit long but it was a Saturday night. This is to be expected. We dine out all the time & this is one of our favorite restaurants. :)

My wife and I went there for our anniversary. We are quickly created and see it in a friendly manner.

Restaurant was extremely clean. Food was very good and the atmosphere was very relaxing.

I have a stake in my wife had the chicken franchise. Both were extremely tasty and filling.

Service - 10
Cleanliness - 10
Speed - 10
Quality - 10
Value - 10

Overall dining experience - 10

Came tonight for the first time, and was extremely impressed. The wait was a little long, which is to be expected on a busy saturday- and the food was well worth the wait. The servers were very attentive, will definitely be back!

We ordered Thanksgiving Dinner for our family, and let me tell you we may never cook again! Everything was delicious.. top notch! And they provided detailed, step by step instructions for reheating. Highly recommend!!!!

Me and my husband have been going there for about 2 to 3 years 2 nights a week every week, sometimes a 3 rd visit for oysters on Wednesdays , the staff is amazing, most became our friends, the food is amazing , the atmosphere, we go out for amazing food and drinks, lots of laughs meet new friends, we enjoy our nights out.

I loved the atmosphere here. The food was delicious and the service was impeccable. I recommend checking this place out!

Food was delicious our waiter was super attentive and fun.

Omg what a fantastic place to eat. Our Server was wonderful. He was extremely attentive and had a great sense of humor. An absolute wonderful experience

Great food, awesome drinks, and the friendly staff was beyond accommodating. Will definitely be back!

Food is always excellent!
Espresso martinis are my go-to here! They make a mean one
The tiramisu is delicioussssss

Great American Italian food, best part you can split since they give way to much food... or plenty of leftovers

03/03/23: We dined in as a family and there were nine of us. Maddie was fabulous! She took care of everything throughout our experience with such a pleasant, politely, and graceful manor. Our food was also prepared to perfection, so delicious! Our time together for our family was an emotional time as we came together on the eve of our fathers memorial service. Your restaurant was his favorite place in town… and your team provided excellent service, we were relaxed, and very much enjoyed our evening. Thank you!

Worth the trip, detour; whatever. Some amazing pasta and wonderful service from the staff. Location is neat and has a very cozy vibe. Will be coming back for more.

Been several times and can say this is my favorite spot in Old Forge along the strip. Veal parm and clams Cusumano are personal favorites. Pizza is exceptional. The atmosphere in the cellar is warm and inviting. Warning: this place is not a great option for a "quick" bite. Service is always good, but the food can come out VERY slowly.

Great place.. We actually stopped just for takeout and a drink.. They found us a table even though we didn't have a reservation and the service was amazing...We will be going back to have an actual meal there soon.. 😁

This was my first time here, and I was meeting up with some old friends. I had the absolute best time, and I was in the basement! I will definitely go back and check out the rest of the place. The people I met here were amazing and friendly and I loved them. 😊