Cafe Rinaldi

Food was excellent, pace of dinner was perfect. Server Sydney was outstanding. She was friendly and very efficient. The only thing I wish restaurants would do is when they read you their specials,they never include the prices. If it's a special you would think that means a special price. And to me that means a lower price.

Went for a birthday dinner. Not an extensive menu but good choices with pasta, chicken and veal. Portions are huge. Next time may opt for a side order of pasta with meatballs. Nice atmosphere and great attentive service. Don’t forget to make reservations because you won’t get a seat.

Can't say enough about this place. First time my wife and I were there. Got an app that they said was for 2 but I think they meant for 2 weeks. The chicken rinaldi was fantastic!!

We sat at the bar and both bartended were running around busy as can be but still were super nice and we never waited for a drink.

I would give this place 6 stars if it would let me!!!

You Need To Know? Arrived at 530 on a Friday night with reservations. Service was rapid & extremely pleasant. Ordered the chicken & cheese risotto balls, a tray of Old Forge style pizza half meatballs, & manicotti. The risotto balls were absolutely delicious. Wish they would have given more. The manicotti had an amazing red sauce & they gave you 4 of them & was very filling. There pizza was airy & light with a crispy crunchy crust! Very tasty & no need to order Xtra cheese as it is loaded with it. This place is a must eat! Now You Know! -TBH

Went here for my sisters birthday. Good food and the service was fast and effective. Super Italian atmosphere with an old school menu. Go get some.

Absolutely love it here, great, friendly service, family atmosphere, excellent food & big portions, highly recommend & get there soon.

Amazing food. Great service. Love this place and will definitely go back!

I grew up in Old Forge and came back to Cafe Rinaldi for the first time in ~10 years last night and everything was so good! Linguini with clam sauce and a couple cuts of red. It was even better than I remember and our server was so kind and attentive. This really is the taste of Old Forge.

This is a delicious Italian restaurant located on Main Street. Every dish in the place is amazing. Friendly staff, great drinks, and plenty of seating. Whether your looking to dine in or take out you can't go wrong, just bring your appetite

Top notch food and service. Bar staff was friendly and attentive. Definitely recommend.

Stop #1 - Cafe Rinaldi. My wife had the special which was white rissotto w scallops. I had the Rinaldi Chicken w side of pasta topped with Rinaldi sauce

I would highly recommend the penne pasta with vodka sauce. The pizza is phenomenal as well.

The quality of the food and service was outstanding. We could not get a reservation at the last minute so we arrived right at 5pm when it opened. Sat at the bar and enjoyed everything.

Just a real good italian restaurant. Never had a bad meal here. Huge portions. Good atmosphere.

Fantastic dinner and service! Best shrimp cocktail around!

Best risotto ever ! The desserts and pizza and chicken Marsala are good too ! Such great Italian food & a staple in old forge !

Risotto is still the best I've had anywhere. We had dinner here on a Wednesday evening, not at all busy. Service was very good. A few slight negatives: no Bianco though it was on the wine list, salads with dinner were just a tiny bit of ice berg lettuce, a couple cuke slices and a couple of cherry tomatoes. Also add a fee for using a credit card.

One of my family’s favorite places to eat!!!! Food is always amazing!!! Tracy our server is the best!!! We Love you all!!!

Old Forge distinctive style pizza is fresh and cheesy. Side of broccoli has garlic!! Portions are very generous Service casual and friendly.

Had a dept. Xmas party here 16 people. Everyone raved over the food. Portions are LARGE and presentation is everything next to taste.😋.mmm Delicious! I would not be so rude as to crawl over people to take photos of their plates..but like I said presentation was exquisite. People all offered tidbits of their very lg. Portions including appetizers. I sampled many! I could not find anything to complain about. Some of the appetizers could be meals themselves. The mushrooms risotto is the signature dish here.👍❣