Papa's Pizza

New Haven style pizza, half mushroom, and it was delicious! The staff was very nice as well and was able to make it for me as a walk-up. Best pizza in Milford!

Have been a papas fan for years, but this cheese I just got (6/16/23) was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Better than recent pizzas from Wooster street. Can’t go wrong here!

Pizza is always great. They can stop taking orders pretty early, especially on weekends when they are slammed with phone orders. Call early, like 3:30, if you want for 5 or 5:30

Came up from NY to try this NH style pizza. It did not disappoint. Pizza was cooked to perfection, great ingredients, and that brick oven crust 👌🏽. Very Friendly Staff!!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!

I grew up around the corner and have had their apizza since they opened in the mid eighties and I've always loved their pie. I put it on par with the more well known greats in New Haven. Definitely the best in Milford. Always great.

Cute place, no line. Placed an order at the window and was ready quickly.

Dave Portnoy gave this a good review. Meets New Haven pizza standard. I would say for those passing through the area without much time, but interested in authentic flavor, this is a good spot for takeout.

Fantastic hole in the wall New Haven style apizza. The A'Pizza di Papa had a fantastic char.

Great pizza and service with a smile. Papa's is top 3 pizza in Milford, CT!

Great meatball pizza. Loved the flavourful crust.

I was absolutely blown away by their eggplant pizza. Lots of times you get frozen flash fried eggplant at pizza places, not here. Definitely home made. big slices perfectly fried. Hands down the best.

This is the best pizza place in Milford hands-down! Also, one of my favorite shop in southern Connecticut super good super quality ingredients. New Haven style, thin crust quality quality cheese. You gotta check this place out.

From a Celiac, this is the Best Gluten Free Pizza I have ever had in my life! It is 14 inches and comes in a large pizza box. I got a plain cheese (it was still good even without any toppings) and the white clam, they were both fantastic! Almost cannot even tell it is a Gluten Free Pizza, will be my go to place for Gluten Free Pizza! Papa's has it spot on to a New Haven Pizza!!

This place is my FAVORITE for pizza in all of New Haven county!!!! Highly recommended. They cook the crust just right and use the perfect amount of cheese. I'm second generation Italian and this place is top of the line!!

I'm not sure why I have never left a review for my favorite pizza place I've been coming to for 22+ years but I wanted to rectify that. This is by far the best pizza in the local area on par in my opinion with Sally's and modern.

I've had the same pizza from Papa's since I was a kid. Been eating there foe 22 years now and sometime the consistency varies but the flavor, quality, and friendliness are always the same. The pizza is and will always be the best in my book. Their cone grinder are HUGE and packed with whatever fillings you want. Small local business that is worth the wait and the prices.

Excellent Apizza spot! Will definitely be back soon.

Great pizza pick up spot I have been going to since I was a kid. Perfect to pick up a pie then eat it at Walnut beach

Our original food order for an event never arrived. We called Papa's Pizza and they bailed us out big time. 15 pizzas were ready within an hour. Not only did they come through, but ended up being some of the best pizza I've ever had.

Some of the best pizza I've ever had. My family has gotten papas pizza every Sunday for years and they never disappoint. Friendly staff, incredible pizza - there's not much else left to say.

Everybody in Milford knows about Papa's Pizza. I lived on Wooster street in New Haven for four years and went to Pepe's, Sally's, Modern and BAR as often as possible. The pizza in New Haven is some of the best in the world. Honestly, if Papa's Pizza were located in New Haven it would be a strong competitor. It's very good pizza and I'm happy to have it so close to home.