Goodfellas Pizzeria

I got the wise guy & a regular pepperoni and sausage with a little bit more sauce. The cheese pull is insane. The ingredients taste super fresh. The sausage is definitely a must on any pizza here; the sauce is so savory. I also went upstairs to their bar and got a vodka with cranberry. The bartender was very nice and informative. The staff is great and friendly across the board. the atmosphere is great and it reminds you of a Prohibition era 1920 speakeasy or a old mob movie. A must stop if you like pizza in Cincinnati 🍕

The best, largest, tastiest NY Style Pizza in all of NKY! Whether you're looking for lunch/dinner or a slice after bar hopping in Mainstrasse Village, it's Da Bomb. You can never go wrong with a Goodfellas Pizza. One of my absolute favorites. Not to mention, they have an awesome Speakeasy upstairs called "Wiseguy" for all your cocktail cravings. Amazing drinks and really cool bartenders, too. Fuhgedda Bout It 🤌!!

Excellent pizza, huge pieces. I had a banana pepper and red pepper slice, and their Marti Gras Pizza and it was amazing. I also had a bread stick that was the size of a small baseball bat and was the length from my elbow to my middle finger. I had cheese sauce and garlic butter with it. The inside is a little tight as you walk in and order then move to the bar/lounge upstairs to relax, sit and eat. The bartender was extremely nice and asked me if I needed anything multiple times as I was only eating and not drinking. He still checked on me to make sure I was good with everything. I do not drink anymore, but they had a massive beer selection with local and niche beer. They had a very large bourbon selection that was visible also. Great place, totally recommend it.

We definitely fold our pizza! It's my favorite by-the-slice style in the area.

The pizza was definitely big and delicious. I had a plane cheese and an onion and pepper slice. The site has a bar upstairs and outdoor seating.

The workers were a bit curt but ok. The food was great!

Hadn't been to this location in a long time, but it's still as good as ever. Love the outdoor seating. Limited indoor seating for eating. They do have a beautiful lounge/bar area that looks like it could get crowded very quickly. Staff was very friendly which made the experience that much better. The pizza was so good. We ordered 4 large pizzas for 15 people and no one left unsatisfied. We had a New Yorker in our group who said this compared to pizza in NYC. That's a great compliment. Can recommend this location and I also like the ones in Lexington. Haven't been to other locations.....yet. we'll be back.

Best pizza in town, in my opinion. The staff here is very friendly and pretty entertaining at times. Inviting atmosphere, and again, the food is on point. The pizzas are normal sized all the way up to oh my goodness, that's so big! That is...what she said. The crust is amazing. It has great taste and a nice 'snap' when biting in.
The meatball subs are pretty good as well. In my opinion, it's pretty hard to find a great one, and theirs isn't an easy one to best.

When Michael Scott goes to Times Square and gets "a New York slice," he's going to Sbarro's. He should have gone to Goodfellas in Covington, Kentucky. It's that perfect foldable slice of pizza.

I've taken my wife, girlfriends, exgirlfriends all to Goodfellas pizza and the staff was smart enough to never pretend they recognized me.

This place was soo good! The food and service was perfection-the guys serving were great and so nice! Thank you! Next time we are in town we will definitely make this a stop! Good prices too. Pizza by the slice, I wanted to try the desserts but was too full-maybe next time. The pizza slices are HUGE and look at the breadsticks are soo long! Like 2ft!!!

($20 for All the items pictured below)

Always a great vibe here, the bartenders who took care of me, Chris and Chase, are experts at their craft! Highly recommend a mezcal Old Fashioned. A great place to chill after a long day, relaxing with solid music/atmosphere and of course the pizza is delicious! If you live in the area or are just visiting, check this place out!

The pizza's and breadsticks are HUGE, fresh, and delicious. This was my first time eating at this establishment. The people were very friendly and welcoming. You can bet that the next time I am back in the Cincinnati area, I will be stopping back in.

Such a cute restaurant! Super friendly staff, especially Chris! It was clean and everything smelled so good. The upstairs took us back to the 1920s and again, the staff was so sweet! It was my first time here and definitely not my last! I am incredibly satisfied with my experience! Oh, the outside was just precious too! The crummy photos I took do not do it justice. If you're in town you should most definitely take the time to stop by. Be sure to look for Chris, he's such a sweetie!

This location has turned it around significantly over the last year. Great slices always, they usually have a pretty good variety too. Also, one of the only places I’ve ever seen in the US where the toilet is reliably clean enough to sit down on. You’d be surprised how far that goes.

Bruh. Amazing This place is the kind of place you are afraid to ask for any special requests. What I mean by that is you know they legit. Note the picture. All gone (ignore my friend who didn’t eat his crust)

These fellas were slammed on a Friday night. My order accidentally got given away to another customer. These things happen the staff remade the entire $70 order and we're so nice about everything. What good customer service should be! Great food!

Best pizza in town! Atmosphere is great plus a nice bar upstairs. Service is fast and friendly!

The lunch special is a great deal. Just walking by outside you can tell its going to be great pizza. Seating is pretty limited, but otherwise a nice place.

Best Pizza In Town!
The cheese was amazing pulls away just the way you want it to.
Perfect amount of sauce.
Medium will feed 4-6 ppl
Giant Breadsticks are amazing!
Patient with my kids and even offered to help me to my car after we were done.

Great place to grab a slice! They have slices ready or you can order your own! Every time I get pizza here it is always delicious!

Best pizza in town! The cocktails are top notch as well.