The Castaway On Phantom

Great Friday, Fish Fry! We had the cod and perch. Baked cod was flakey and tends. Perch was taste. Coleslaw was homemade and delicious. A great little place for food and drinks. The server was kind and knowledgeable.

Outstanding fish fry! I had the perch, 2 large filets, 2 potato pancakes, homemade slaw (nice and crunchy), and homemade tartar sauce. Breading was just right. My friend had the cod and was equally pleased. Ate at the bar with several other diners. Bartenders are friendly and mix a proper old fashioned (tall boy) from scratch, no pre-mix! For sure we'll be back!

We had the prime rib New Years Eve dinner and it was amazing! Delicious food and friendly people every time we come. Thanks for everything, we’ll be back!

Castaway was a great time! The staff was super friendly and made a consistent effort to check on us - probably the best service I've ever had. It's an interesting place, feels like a fusion of supper club, dive bar and has a vibe of a restaurant that sits on the shores of a lake. The food was great and the appetizer of cheese curds was massive. While it is a full service bar they don't have beers on tap and primarily serve cans/bottles of beer. In all honesty, you may not think of it being a great place by looking at the outside but trust me, you'll be treated great and have a fun time. They have live music on Friday nights.

Great food - my burger was amazing. Very nice and accommodating staff. This place has a ‘local crowd’ vibe (meant in the best way). We came on a beautiful October day by boat for a Packer game. Our child was assumed by some of the (supervised) entertainment machines - lol. Good time!

OMG!! The food!! The service!! I can't tell you how wonderful this place is!! We all had an excellent time there!! Will definitely be back!! The karaoke singer was excellent too!! Thank you for a wonderful experience!!

The food is super good, the view is awesome looking out the windows while sitting at the bar. You’re surrounded by water. Very pretty. And the staff is very welcoming. Definitely coming back!

Super fun, laid-back atmosphere! Great food and drinks. I have had the fish fry a few times and been there for some adult cocktails and all of the bartenders and customers were welcoming with lots of laughs! Also, great location and prices!

We've been there twice and have enjoyed the people who service folks and the food
I'm looking forward to trying their fish fry in the future. We've had their prime beef sandwich, which was delicious, and their grilled chicken Hawaiian and beef sandwich.
Their fries are very good. I don't like saggy fries, and theirs aren't.

Our new favorite place! Great burgers & the fries are perfect! Owner was super friendly too. Live music sealed the deal. Check it out if you haven't yet!! It's a gem.

Omg. Battered cod. Latkes. The perfect accoutrements. And the cheese curds were DEVOURED. Best dinner lakeside ever. Friendly folks. If they ask “how are you”, the appropriate answer is “living the dream”. Cause you are.

Great food and fun atmosphere. I'll be back next time I'm in the area

Food was excellent. People were amazingly friendly. Owners are very appreciative. Will definitely go back.

AWESOME fun place, great food, nice bar staff, and right on the lake. What more could you want??

We stopped here because it had the best reviews in the area. They were right!! Great food and even better service. Owners are top notch. If they lack in one area, they make up for in so many other areas. Stop by, you won't be disappointed.

We didn't eat, but the cocktails are made well and service is fast and friendly. The prices are average for the area. A "stand out" feature of this place is their outside patio that overlooks part of Phantom Lake! It's a beautiful setting.

Delicious food. Blackened Mahi wrap, loaded French dip, Castaway burger, wings and seared ahi are some of my favorites. Can't really go wrong. Live music Friday and Sundays.

Excellent meal, pleasant view.

Great place! Good atmosphere, and great people. Chicken wings are solid, and come with a deliciously made side of asparagus! Sounds odd, bit it works! Also, a cool tucked away location. Can't wait to get back!

What cozy, cool place to dine or just to have a drink or two .. or t'ree! The Phantom Lake setting is gorgeous and the bar/restaurant is inviting and warm. Brian, the beer tender, is a great guy and has a fun sense of humor. My wife and I shared a burger, fries, and some cheese curds! Hot and yummy! If you haven't already been there, you should give the Castaway on Phantom a try!