Sal's Pizza Cedarburg

Great slice shop serving up several varieties of New York style slices. The Mac and Cheese pizza is fantastic! 👌

My two friends and I went to Sal’s Pizza in Cedarburg for a Sunday lunch. It was really good! The servers were very helpful. You could eat inside or outside. There were lots of different options for unique pizza flavors. You could buy by the slice or a whole pizza. We loved the by-the-slice option—we all had plenty to eat with just one slice! Every pizza slice comes with a roll, too. Stop by Sal’s for tasty gourmet pizza!

This was my family first time and we will be definitely coming back. So We came in I took my kids to the backroom and had them sit at a table. I went to the front where the make the pizza placed my order. We got Philly Cheese Steak Pizza without mushrooms
(whole pie ),and a slice of pepperoni pizza along with garlic knots. It hit the spot. It was delicious and the staff was super friendly. It took about 20 minute to make so not bad on time at all. You can call in but we had time to kill and it was made fresh. You can also just go in get a slice and your in and out. We will be back if you are walking around come in and this place a try.

A great locally owned old fashioned shop. Friendly staff and the PIZZA WAS AWESOME. Guys are super nice and even gave us a couple of free garlic bread, since we were the last customers of the night.

While visiting SE Wisconsin from California I stumbled upon this place. Of course I was hungry from all the walking around and pizza seemed like the best fit at the moment. The pizza was fresh and crispy crust which I prefer, even the piece of garlic bread was so good. Service from Ian was excellent and his personality was fitting for the service industry. If you’re in town I would highly recommend this place. There was plenty of seating in the back of the inside and a few tables out front. Give this place a try!

Visiting Cedarburg Wisconsin for the first time today our group really lucked out in finding Sal's pizzeria. After being turned down at a few local spots for not having reservations we continued down main steet in hopes of finding someplace good for breakfast. After a few minutes walking downtown we crossed the street where the familiar smell of fresh baked pizza permeated the air. After a short discussion the group decided I should go inside first to check if they had enough room for the six of us and see if they made gluten free pizza. The answer was yes to both so we decided to give it a try and man are we glad we did! The six of us, all pizza snobs from Chicago had to agree Sal's makes an exceptionally good pie, literally among the best pizza any of us ever tasted. What makes admitting this so hard is the fact Sal's pizza is New York style, a hard pill to swallow for anyone from the Windy City. But hey, anything as good as Sal's needs to be celebrated so that's why we've decided to surrender this battle in the Pizza wars and share this amazing gem with the world.
Mangiare

We went to Cedarburg for a day trip and stopped at Sal’s to try it out. Early in the day my wife and I shared a slice, then after shopping we bought a full pizza. We ate some of it in the parking lot where we were parked, and it was fantastic. The employees were cheerful also, nice dudes to talk with. Great job!

If you are looking for atmosphere this may not be your first choice BUT if you are looking for great pizza in a simple atmosphere this is your place!

I live in MT. but was back in the area visiting Family.
My niece and I stopped at Sals for a slice of pizza for lunch. My tastes were lit up with absolute delight. I just closed my eyes every time I took a bite of pizza and reveled in the tastes. Thank-you Sals for the BEST pizza 🍕 I have ever eaten!!

I make this a stop on my visit to Cedarburg. Mainly because they people are amazing and the pizza is out of this world. Love this place!

Sal's does NOT disappoint 👏.

Kudos to the team for all the deliciousness 😁.

I spent the afternoon walking around downtown Cedarburg and worked up an appetite but still had an hour ride home, and it was snowing 🌨. First snow of the season and I was in unfamiliar territory driving alone, so I needed something quick but really wanted to get a local food. #shoplocal #eatlocal.

I saw Sal's sign earlier in the day, so I was anxious with the anticipation. When I walked up you could smell it outside and my mouth started watering! It smelled soooooooo good!

My mouth was watering so much I couldn't wait and ate my slice right away in my car. I had to go back in for another one to take home.

Everyone working that night was the best 😁 Very kind and helpful. Had a great conversation about how it's sacrilege to microwave pizza 👍😆 (I didn't catch his name but he was just making sure I wouldn't microwave my slice when I got home). Who does that?🤦‍♀

If you're anywhere near downtown Cedarburg don't drive past Sal's ❤ They're pizza masters.

My wife and I will drive from the southwest side of Milwaukee for the sole purpose of taking out two or three slices of pizza from Sal's. We have never been disappointed in the flavor or quality of the pizza. They offer unique toppings, and the young men working behind the counter are always helpful and courteous. This is a must stop for those hungry and visiting downtown Cedarburg.

Good food, garlic roll comes with a slice. The veggies in the supreme pizza is good!

We tried Sal's for the first time tonight. Omg, this place is AMAZING!!!! Ordering was a breeze. The prices were phenomenal. The portions were gigantic. The food was to die for. And the service..... It was the best of the best! Sal's is a must try if you're in the area!!!!

Small little pizza joint in a small town with BIG flavors - better than most places in the closest large city of Milwaukee. You looking for a crispy bite, smooth cheese, and fresh toppings? This is the place.

Pizza was authentically great. We had one with everything and one with spinach/feta. Garlic knots were divine, clearly from scratch. This will become a regular stop.

Amazing New York style pizza best in the midwest hands down! Keep it up

Great New York style pizza, by the pie or by the slice.

Great pizza available by the slice! Great guy

I never want to Sal’s before, but that all changed on the night of April 17th, 2023. So good pizza, definitely one of the best around. Everyone inside was very good pizza and hand it to me HOT and always READY. Oh lord (if I can say that) is delicious! Please go if you can, if you can’t, I break your legs with a tire iron. So good, on the par with vine and instagram, git er done!!!!