Tomaso's

We absolutely LOVE Tomaso's in Cedarburg. They have my absolute FAVORITE pizza - perfectly crisp thin crust with the perfect proportion of cheese, sauce, and toppings. Their pizza is wonderfully flavorful and I love that the sauce is on top of the cheese.

Tomaso's in Cedarburg has a pretty extensive menu. As much as I would like to try other items on their menu when their pizza is your favorite you eat the pizza. We are also partial to their garlic bread and pickle fries; they are very delicious!

Tomaso's is a table seating (seat yourself), order at the bar, and pick up your food at the bar establishment. Service is quick. The restaurant is clean. Prices are reasonable.

As I stated, we love it here and will continue to frequent it! I highly recommend their pizza!!

My first time here and when I walked in and smelled that fresh aroma of garlic I knew I was in for a treat!! I'll cut to the chase. The pizza was the best I've had in a long, long time. Thin cracker crust that held up. A slight buttery flavor to it. The sauce, which is on top of the cheese not vise versa, was sweet and fresh. Sausage, mushrooms and onions were also fresh and added to the abundance of flavor. I honestly can't find one thing to nit pick about. The pizza was flawless. Garlic bread was fantastic and left you craving more. Wonderful ambiance. It had that old school Italian restaurant vibe. Service was fast and very friendly. Prices are extremely fair. I had such a great time here that I will definitely be a repeat customer no matter how high the gas prices get. Salute!!

THE BEST thin crust pizza I have ever had!!! This is definitely worth going out of your way if you have to. All of the toppings are unbelievably fresh and flavorful. Ask for fresh basil and or fresh garlic for a real treat! We just left I am already looking forward to returning!!

We've been living in Cedarburg since 2020 and Tomaso's immediately became our go-to spot. The joy my two daughters have on their face when we say "it's a Tomaso's night!" Is second to none.

I can't emphasize enough how high of quality the ingredients are - from veggies, to sauces, to the meats. I have not have as good of a thin crust pizza anywhere in the U.S., as it's always served with a perfectly crispy crust and bubbling cheese.

Incredibly underrated spaghetti too. HIGHLY recommend making the trip here.

very good pizza and brusetta! wish booths were bigger and wasnt so cramed. not their fault since the building is small but shoulder to shoulder with people basically.

Nestled into downtown Cedarburg this place is a not so hidden gem! Both the pizza and pasta are amazing and the service is phenomenal. Lovely place for dine in and take out.

Ordered a pepperoni, sausage, mushroom and green pepper thin crust pizza and we absolutely loved it. Packed with fresh toppings. Ready in 20 minutes. Highly recommend!

The food and service was awesome. Nice small restaurant with big flavor. One thing that was a little different was having to go to the bar to order and pick up the food, but the food make up for it. I would definitely recommend the spinach artichoke pizza with white sauce, and the calamari with aioli.

Always a pleasure to dine here. Even after a festival day we were able to be seated in about 20-30 minutes. We’ve always enjoyed the pizza here for take out, so we decided it was time to try the pasta. My daughter inhaled her kids spaghetti with red sauce and my wife and I both thoroughly enjoyed our specialty pasta. Her spicy chicken and spinach cavatappi had it all; spice, flavor, meat, and just enough sauce. I had the chicken carbonara with mushrooms, onion, bacon and a delicious cream sauce that wasn’t overwhelming or too rich. For the price, this is a great dining experience with a friendly atmosphere.

Great food, you serve yourself but so worth it. Very fun place. Parking can be a hassle. Mom loves the pizza and beer.

My dad and I have been coming to Tomaso's for 30 years plus. It is as good today as it was the first time we came way back when. I would recommend the deep dish, it is absolutely outstanding!

What a find! Pizza was outstanding! Appetizers were delicious! Great vibe and considering how busy they were, service and food were truly amazing. Well done Tomaso’s. We will be stopping again!

Had a slice at Harvestfest... It was "WOW" good. This is great pizza both my wife and I are addicted... One bite and we knew we had to come back. The cheese, toppings, crust, sauce are all on point.

The thin crust pizza was nothing short of phenomenal! I would highly recommend this cozy place!

Our favorite thin crust in town!

"Oh, fruit on your pizza is gnarly, you say? Well, I say try before you deny."

Love the food is so good only thing is you have to order at the bar, not a big deal and is a small place so it's very crowded but still enjoyable

Very consistent quality. Been eating here my whole life and it’s always been fantastic!

Bartender is fantastic along with the staff! If you haven't been here, it is a must! Check in with the bartender he'll make it right for the night!

This tiny pizza place in the heart of Cedarburg has some of the best pizza I've ever had. They have a unique method of putting the cheese on top of the crust before the sauce so that the crust stays crispy longer.

Best pizza anywhere. Dine bar is small but staff is always friendly and drinks aren't to pricey. Been going here for years the deep dish is simply fantastic.