Timber Creek Pizza Co

Great food, fast, friendly service. Reasonable prices. Fun decor with a casual, rustic north-woodsy vibe. Clean restaurant and clean restrooms. Consistently good. We've been going here for years and have never been disappointed. We always get the BLT sub and a chocolate malt. I highly recommend both.

Timber creek is an excellent joint. The food here is great; our favorite at Howell Building Care is the meat lovers pizza. They do a family meal deal which feeds several people. The ice cream here is awesome too. It's an affordable stop, and they deliver high quality food for every meal. I highly recommend a visit here.

Awesome little place, super friendly staff, delicious food and reasonable prices. So much fun in summer to get the whole family ice cream during downtown festivals etc.

Great service! I ordered a surprise delivery of the take and bake pizza and shakes for a friend tonight. I ended up having to tell the recipient as they weren’t home after two delivery attempts. The employee I spoke on the phone with was super understanding, helpful, and friendly. They were able to deliver the order, and the food was quality and delicious (according to my friend). Thank you for your patience as I failed the surprise, and for helping me make a friend’s day from afar!

Had the awesome Cedar Creek Ice Cream. They looked to be a little slow at the time but also seemed like a good place for a Birthday party.

My first time there was very pleasant. The staff was personable, and helpful. The pizza was delicious.I will be going back.

We were on the road and decided we were in the mood for pizza. This place popped up right off the exit we took. This was exactly what we were hoping for! Nice cute little spot. The pizza was very good and had a thin crust. It was an extra bonus that they also served ice cream!! Definitely will be back.

Tried to eat the family meal deal 16in plus two loaves of bread sticks with just two people. Made it through most of the pizza and one of the loaves then almost died. Spent an hour on the toilet.10/10 would do it again.

Pizza was delicious and fast. Wasn't expecting it to be so good but was pleasantly surprised. A+

We ordered the Mac n Cheese and split a Tuna Melt sub. It was so delicious, just like you made it at home. Plus very friendly and helpful staff. Can't wait to come back for more. Thank you!

So happy this place exists! Lovely hometown pizza, Blue Moon ice cream is my favorite, and the owner is a really good guy. Keeps the love in town!

It was great eating here! It was clean and tables were well spaced, so we didn't worry too much about COVID. The pizza was AMAZING, and my daughter really enjoyed her gluten free pizza, as well.

Awesome place to grab a bite to eat or an icecream cone. The subs are amazing with fresh baked bread. The pizza is also delicious. Very friendly service and great safety precautions taken by the employees.

This place is a small town gem! :) Their in house lemonade was stellar and they had a great variety of ice cream flavors to choose from. Staff was also great. Would definitely recommend :)

This pizza is the best pizza. Also, the people who work here are genuinely kind. I just moved to Lake Mills in June and am so fortunate to live in a place where the pizza is this good. I'm from Racine, lived in Milwaukee for 7 years and in Madison for 10. This place is better than Falbo's in Madison and just as good as DeRango's on Douglas and 3mi in Racine.

I was really hoping to find a triple decker, but all they had was thin. It was a very good piza though!

All of their menu items are excellent! Food and service is consistent. Timber Creek is one of our favorite restaurants in Lake Mills!

Had pizza here with my family. They have many different pizza options for the fam. My daughter loved their cheese pizza. I had the vegetarian. It was lacking in the vegetable area. They have ice cream and a great atmosphere for family.

We had an awesome experience, great ice cream.

Great place to go to get ice cream on a hot summer day. Also have great pizza!