Mustang Pub

It's a bar, so that is the surroundings you will have. We were surprised by the menu. Our orders were great and served very fast. We would definitely go back.

Stopped in to grab dinner and watch some of the Superbowl before heading back to our hotel. The food was great (the wings were HUGE, and so reasonably priced), the beer was cold and the service was great, even though our server was also the bartender.
And the owner (I'm assuming) was a lot of fun. Apps on the bar and my very own LA pom pom! We will be sure to visit again next time we are in the area!

Camping at Keuka Lake SP and came into town for a drink, bite to eat and free wifi. Had the hot wings and they were awesome. We have a favorite local wing place at home (Guelph, Ontario) and these were even bigger and very tasty. Came back again before going home. Food was quick and staff were super friendly. Would definitely come back if in the neighborhood.

Great food and service. Also delicious mules.

The waitress was super kind with us. Besides they have the Tuesday chicken wings day that you have 12 wings for just 8$ with a wide range of sauces. We definitely would come back

I've had two great meals here during Wednesday Trivia night. The service is very good - friendly and attentive. I ordered a special sandwich and they didn't give me attitude at all - they were very happy to make me happy! I had them make me a grilled Buffalo chicken panini with blue cheese crumbles - it was awesome. Their beverage prices are very reasonable too. I LOVE the trivia done by Finger Lakes Entertainment on Wednesdays. We use our cell phones to turn in our answer dozens of questions. Nate keeps things fun and moving along.

I wish I would have got our bartenders name. We were visiting from NYC on 8-1-20 and saw they advertised their wings. Our philosophy is "the closer you get to Buffalo the better the wings" I can't believe how delicious and perfect these wings were! Also a very amazing selection on draft. Our server was very pleasant and was quick with everything. We will be passing through again in 2 weeks and you better believe we will be stopping by this gem again. Well done guys!

Loved the trivia experience, even though we didn't win. Very fair prices.

Hidden gem with a wonderful staff and atmosphere. They also have the best wing deals I have ever seen. Even if you're not a drinker, the food is what pulls me back every time. Some days, a dozen wings are only $5 and they're GOOD.

Great local pub. The service was friendly and helpful. My wife had a burger and I had the wings. Both were delicious.
They have a good selection of local beer and specifically IPAs.
Great place to visit if you are an out of towner like we were.

Christa runs the most amazing buisness. She cares and takes care of her customers. I have been a local for years and never have I had a good experience in the former establishments. Now, since she bought it, it is the place to be. Between the great food, service and selection of alcohol, places to smoke and eat and the overall great staff, I would chose 20x over.

My group showed up, unknowingly, about 5 minutes before the kitchen closed. The bartender let us know that they were closing the kitchen soon so we should order quickly. Food was good and had a decent sized beer selection. If I'm back in the area, I will stop by here.

Nice and friendly staff, very reasonably priced drinks. Hamburger and grilled chicken sandwiches were very tasty.

Just dropped in for a cold one and bite to eat. Awesome! A friendly "hi" as soon as we walked in the door! Great burgers and fast service. Ken and Christa are so welcoming. We'll be back!

Decent size menu for a pub. The food was great, portions generous and the staff was very friendly and inviting. When I am back in PenYan I will definitely stop back to eat here

My friends and I stopped here after a weekend of winetasting looking for some beer and bar food.

The bar had a lot of people but service was great and speedy.

Excellent selection of beer and all the types of food you would expect at a pub.

Delicious food. Definitely a bar atmosphere. We were able to sit tucked away to avoid the noise. Our waiter was super sweet and friendly.

Went there for first tonight...GREAT wings, best fries we ever had and wonderful service. Will definitely be back!

Very nice place, good food and service.

Johnny is the best bartender 🍻