Pizza Crossing Logan (HOCKING HILLS)

Just ate here for a 5 year anniversary and just like always, food was great! Pics are of an Italian all-the-way sub and a large extra cheese/pepperoni/mushroom/onion pizza.

I’ve been eating here since 2005 when I moved to the area from Columbus, both as dine-in and delivery, and the food has never disappointed me. The decor hasn’t changed either since 2005, which I personally love for nostalgia reasons.

Their subs are great, pizza is gourmet, and the servers have always been friendly. Their breadsticks rival Olive Garden to me as well, and their lasagna or pasta dishes along with a salad and breadsticks are sometimes all I get instead of the pizza because they’re just THAT good to me.

Service gets a 4 star rating because there have been a few times I’ve ordered delivery and they forget a food item entirely, but it’s never been a big deal and it’s always been corrected in a timely manner.

Overall a really good place to eat, despite their prices going up over the years (but that’s everywhere you go these days). Ordered 1 large custom topping pizza, 2 all-the-way subs, and 2 drinks, and the total came up to $56.

Would absolutely recommend to anyone, local or not! 👍

First and foremost, it's been months since we went to Hocking Hills and I still think about this pizza. It is THAT good. I came back to add it to my favorites and realized I never left a review. Great service as well as great pizza and the atmosphere had all the 90s pizza place vibes. We cannot wait to come back.

Pizza Crossing was our 8th stop on our Top 10 Central Ohio pizza tour. We are all family and drive from different areas to meet up to try different pizza places with high online reviews. We then review the establishment and the pizza. If you have any suggestions of new places just let us know!!

There were 4 of us tonight so I will be leaving everyone’s vote on a 0/10 scale at the bottom of the post.

Tonight we ordered: garlic bread sticks with cheese, pepperoni, extra cheese & sausage and pepperoni, extra cheese & mushrooms.

Positives: We didn’t have a wait. Staff was very nice! Our server Diana was pleasant and did a great job. We loved our pizza! It hard great flavor, crust was crispy and toppings were proportionate.

Negatives: I’m not sure this is a negative but the breadsticks were not what we were expecting. They are hot dog buns with garlic & cheese. They could have used a little more garlic.

Scores:
A - 8.1/10

S - 8.3/10

S - 8.5/10

S - 8.3/10

Overall, great pizza place!! Recommend giving them a try and we will definitely back here again for some great food!!

Chill atmosphere. DELICIOUS pizza. We had the bbq chicken pizza and the pepperoni pizza. We left 58 west for pizza crossing and it was the best decision we made for our 5th anniversary. It was busy, but they were quick. Please try this place out!!

I had read and heard good things about this place. Ordered a sub for me, my wife and daughter split one and I wished I had someone to split it with. They are huge and very delicious. We also ordered a pepperoni pizza that was equally as delicious! Cassie was our waitress and she did a fantastic job, was very polite and kept us up on sodas.

This is definitely a must try place of your passing by. Hometowns favorite excellent pizza.

We tried to have pizza here when we were hiking in Hocking Hills last year, but it was closed. Today, at the end of our hikes we decided to try it again.

Checked the menu online and made up our minds on the pizza to order. Called the phone number and was connected after 4-5 rings. Completes order in about 1-2 minutes.

Arrived about 20 minutes later and the pizza was ready. There was no line when we stopped by at about 3:30 pm.

The portion is about right. The pizza, All The Way, is delicious!

I would say this is definitely rated on the top of my pizza places.

Awesome pizza! It's looks beautiful and it tasted beautiful. Probably the best cauliflower crust pizza I've had in forever!

The food is really good. Our server, Shannon was fantastic. I had the Ruthies way sub and it was sooooo good! Everyone in my group loved their food. My only complaint is that we waited about 40 minutes to an hour our food. We were a large group there during the Bigfoot festival, so I'm assuming that is why. They were slammed. - so I'm still giving 5☆'s. If we weren't from out of town I'd go back for that sub again. It was excellent.

Heavily-topped delicious pizza with fresh veggies including the mushrooms, onions and peppers.
We ordered extra sauce and upon request got nice fresh packets of parmesan cheese. Pleasant phone service. Quick pick-up. Hometown ambience. Two thumbs up!

My brother and I hadn't heard of Pizza Crossing until recently which is very unfortunate as we would've already been steady customers. I read in 614now that it is ranked as one of the best pizzas in Ohio. We had to give it a try as we're always looking for the next best pizza, and have traveled throughout Ohio as well as several other states doing so. We were definitely not disappointed and must say it lives up to its hype. We had a medium meat lovers without ham and bacon. From the cut to the sheer size of the sausage, we couldn't help but devour our whole pizza. It has a typical Columbus tavern style crust with a bit of chewiness to it. The sweet and spicy sauce was equally balanced and this is something few pizza sauces are able to do successfully. We also had the Italian sub which was stuffed full of meat and fresh veggies. The bun even tasted homemade. We watch Barstool Pizza all the time and try to rank every pizza we eat. We ranked Pizza Crossing a 9.1 which is one of the highest scores we've ever given a pizza. Kudos as well to the location and service. Easy to park and get seated. Staff was friendly and courteous. We plan to be back soon and hope we'll have the same terrific experience. If you haven't given Pizza Crossing a try, you should and enjoy the beautiful scenery along I-33 along the way!

Great experience. Our server, Jen was awesome every step of the way. Going as far as doublechecking a few things for an allergy. Extremely appreciated! Everything is homemade. Put this one on your list to visit!

Normally I don't give 5 stars but because of the food and service this place deserves it. We weren't expecting high end decor and it was certainly comfortable and easy to have a conversation (the music was just enough and not over powering).

We are staying in Logan for a couple days and we got here on a VERY humid day 🥵. We were going to walk here but 1) it's very hilly and 2) did I mention the humidity!? It was a very short drive (2 minutes max) from our B&B (White Pillars, see that review once our stay is over).

Non-descript outside but very roomy inside. Nothing special but comfortable. We came on a Tuesday night and they were rocking...again that might have to do with the humidity 😳

We ordered 6 buffalo wings which were very good and a medium supreme meat pizza....that was AMAZING! I heard they were voted one of the best pizzas in the country by USA Today and they were not wrong (I don't care what your politics are re: the newspaper 😉)

With the frosty glasses of our Michelob lite we polished off most of the medium pizza 😳 but that is one delicious pizza for sure!!

Price is good, $48 for the 6 wings, medium pizza and (ugh) 6 bottles of 🍺. It would have been cheaper of course without the beer 🫤 but on this humid night it was a necessity.

Diane was a fabulous server. She was spot on for service, friendliness and answering our inane questions as non locals 😁

Be sure to get a pizza here, it is the best!! And give a shout out to Diane for her wonderful, friendly service

Wonderful service! Our server did an incredible job. She was very friendly, gave good recommendations, and went above and beyond with helping us.

The pizza was great. We had half bacon chicken alfredo and half "all the way" (supreme). Both were very tasty in their own way. Crust was crisp and thin, cut checkerboard style.

We also enjoyed the breadsticks and house salad. The breadsticks are hoagie buns baked with cheese and garlic butter and served with marinara sauce. Very good. I also got the small salad and it was a generous serving.

Really enjoyed this place!

Staff on the phone were quick and prompt. Our pizza was hot and ready for pickup when they said it would be.

We got the ‘All The Way’ and were not disappointed. So many toppings! Loved the large chunks of sausage. Honestly, best pizza I’ve had in a long time! Thanks!

Pizza was absolutely awesome although prices were a little high and our server was no where to be found I will give it another shot

The pizza was great we had the works the first time we visited and it was delicious then a few days later we ordered the pepperoni and it was awesome as well. Our younger waitress was awesome she was so nice and did a great job.

Pizza was fantastic! Highly recommend the bbq chicken pizza! Breadsticks are not your typical breadstick, but they were delicious!

I've always been a Massey's pizza fan...45 years worth. Rather than driving into Lancaster I'll be driving to Logan for this great pizza. They don't skimp on the toppings on their all the way pizza.

This place had great reviews saying it was the best pizza ever. It was most certainly the best pizza I've ever had. We had the Mexican pizza and some kind of chicken pizza. They were both delicious. The staff was extremely friendly. We came in close to closing time but they were more than happy to make a pizza for us to carry out.