Brotherhood of Thieves

Love the brotherhood!! A wicked cool downstairs pub open year round with outside dining in warmer weather! The sushi has become a favorite! Great food and friendly service! Burgers, fish&chips, French onion soup etc.
Happy hour is great. Wish they had sushi on it.

Awesome place. I loved their cheese burger and curly fries. We also got a brown butter lobster roll. That was delicious. I had their rum punch, whaleship Essex, and painkiller cocktails. They were awesome. The location is great. Right downtown. Also their prices were great for the value of food. The air conditioning felt great, it was a 95 plus degree day. Our waiter was great. He was friendly and attentive. Clean and welcoming place.

What a fabulous recommendation our hotel (Union Street Inn) staff made for us. This was our last night out on Nantucket and we sure hit the jackpot. Super upbeat atmosphere and a very friendly staff. Our server, I think she spells her name Erris, from Albania was fantastic. I started with a specialty gin cocktail and it was tasty. I liked it because it wasn’t too sweet which I like. For dinner my husband ordered a lobster roll and I opted for a side Caesar salad. His lobster roll was delicious and my salad was full of very fresh romaine with a flavorful classic dressing and the grilled croutons were a nice touch. Hubby still had room (not really though ha!) for dessert and loved their carrot cake. Every person working there seemed to enjoy their jobs. A very good sign!!! I highly recommend Brotherhood of Thieves.

Absolutely amazing! We loved the clam chowder, a little different than the average chowder. It's my favorite clam chowder ever. And the fish sandwich!! Now that is a great fish sandwich! Went for lunch at a slowish time and service was excellent! Nicely decorated inside

Delicious clam chowder and lobster roll. Great atmosphere and you can just feel the history with the old wooden ceilings.

I was on the island a few weeks ago for work and ate here several times. Burgers were top notch but the braised short rib is living in my head rent free. Best meal I think I’ve ever had at any restaurant. 3 weeks later and I’m still thinking about it!

Absolutely delicious. Cool atmosphere inside and incredible food, everything tasted fresh and flavorful. Was not expecting sushi at a place like this but it was so good! My husband and I shared a roll between our mains. Highly recommend you do the same! And I definitely recommend their cookie dessert. Will be coming back the next time we’re in Nantucket!

The sushi was out of this world good. Very fresh, and you could tell it was crafted by someone who cared. The presentation was stellar...and the taste... o my god.. the Toro roll was beyond tasty. And the angry dragon stole the show completely... crispy, succulent, and great sauce. Check out the apps while your here as well. I highly recommend the cheessteak egg rolls.

The staff are welcoming and helpful. The Chowder is excellent and the short rib sandwich also tastes great! Large assortment of drinks from the bar. Very chill and cool atmosphere.

This was an old favorite spot we were sad to see shut down a few season ago… but they are back and it is good. It is one of the better lunch or dinner values on the island. We had the wings, burgers and fish and chips and everything tasted great… the Burger is hands down my favorite. The drinks were also really good! We had heard rumors of it being slow and we did not think so at all and and we had amazing service from our waitress. We will be going back again.

Best local of island Steak and sauce so good and of course Old fashioned

THE BEST French Onion Soup I have ever had.
Very fast service and amazing cocktails. One of the best places for food that feels like home on the island.

Had an amazing dining experience with Martin, he was super knowledgeable, friendly, and recommended amazing drinks!! Food was amazing 10/10, it’s my second visit with him, I’ll be back 🙂

GET THE LOBSTER ROLL W BROWN BUTTER SAUCE...IT WILL CHANGE YOUR LIFE!!! Service was great. Had also the fish & chips battered which was well made! Highly Recommend.

By far the Traditional Lobster Roll was the best I have ever eaten! The roll was toasted and came hot off the grill while the lobster meat had the absolute perfect combination of chopped celery, lemon and a slight amount of mayonnaise. A must have every visit to ACK.
The clam chowder was pretty darn good too!

Service was a little slow but they were very busy so I can't fault them for that. I had the Cod sandwich and it was GREAT! This thing had a massive slab of fish and everything was fresh and tasty. The Truffle fries were awesome and a nice cold Guinness to wash it all down.

I picked this spot because of the funny name. Expecting average American bar food but what I was treated to was one of the juiciest and most delicious fried chicken cutlets I've ever had. Food, drinks and service were all excellent.

I was in the Restuarant on April/12/2023.
Food was delicious and service was top notch. Boom boom shrimp is top of the world. Ask for Karen and she gives best recommendation.
Thank you guys and will definitely come back.

Decent sized menu with plenty of options for anyone. Great prices for portion size on Nantucket. Helpful and friendly staff waited on us efficiently and brought out food quicker than expected. Enjoyed the fish burrito! Options for seating (inside downstairs (dark), upstairs (bright), and outside (breezy)) were another highlight.

The worst part about this place is that it's usually 4 people deep at the bar. Otherwise, it's flawless. We love the upstairs bartender. I think her name was Kay. The food is excellent and the three bars each have their own vibe.