Something Natural

I’ve only been here three days, but this was the best deal going on the island. The large sandwiches are enough for two people.

Six of us ate here and all were more than satisfied.

I got a BLT on French bread. Fantastic. My wife got whatever has sprouts and hummus and loved it (particularly liked the chunks of chickpeas in the hummus).

The setting is beautiful. It was odd there was no sign out front, so being with a seasoned island visitor was key. But the place was pretty busy, even in late April, so somehow people know where it is.

If you like fresh sandwiches, this is your place.

(By the way, there’s an odd feature when using the electronic kiosk ordering system that it *looks* like you’re paying extra for particular add-ons when ordering, but in the end, if it’s on the menu, it came off the price. They should probably fix that because it looked like an up sell as we were ordering but actually wasn’t.)

If we’re ever back on the island, will definitely return here.

Best egg salad sandwich ever! The bread was insanely perfect as well (oatmeal). Pretty sure the mayonnaise is homemade and the tomatoes were from their garden. A gem of a find on Nantucket. 🩷

Delicious, huge sandwiches. Loved the curried chicken salad on french bread. Nice lawn to enjoy the food on, so bring a blanket for a picnic! Plenty of parking too.

Beautiful scenery, tasty sandwiches, and pretty quick service for the amount of people there.

You can order online or through on a tablet located on the side of the restaurant. The menu is very vegan friendly. The bread slices are giant, the whole sandwich is about an 8"x5" block. So if you're not a hungry hippo, I would opt for the half sandwich or share the whole.

A lovely place to relax on a summer day, get lunch, and enjoy just being.

The food is fantastic and they give you extremely large portions. So you could easily split a sandwich— and I eat a lot!

If you are looking for a place to get food and just enjoy yourself with people you care about. This is the place you have been looking for.

Highly recommend it.

Great place for a sandwich and enormous cookies. Half sandwiches are the perfect fit for a hearty lunch. The thanksgiving sandwich is perfect if you’re missing your November feast.

Sandwiches are always delicious and generously sized. Paired with one of their huge chocolate chip cookies and you're completely sated!

GREAT sandwiches and excellent service! Long list of options for all dietary needs. Really glad we came here. The half size was perfect for lunch but the sandwiches were so good, I would have still finished a full size easily.

Fabulous sandwich shop with the freshest bread (love their challah) and the BEST chocolate chip cookies. A must-do on every trip to Nantucket. There is plenty of outdoor seating and the staff are always super friendly. If you can't make it to the shop - they sell their bread and cookies in the Stop & Shop on island.

Inventive curried chicken salad, turkey salad with chutney and a BLT. Their bread loaves must be gigantic because the sandwiches are enormous. Take them to Dionis Beach and fall asleep under an umbrella.

I am very picky when it comes to sandwichs and this place makes perfeft sandwiches and very very fresh lunch meat. Atmosphere is adorable. We ate outside on picnic tables.
The bread is very very fresh snd good! The roast beef was perfect! The chocolate chip cookie was so good!
Thsnk u for having fresh lunch meat
So good
🫶
Gina xx

At least twice this summer the kids working lost our order and we spent almost 45 minutes waiting. The next time when we kindly asked to make sure things were running on track, they were rude.

Love the owner, the scenery that's why I'm leaving a 5-star review, but the workers are usually new to working and consistently make mistakes when we have gone here for lunch.

The only place to go for sandwiches on Nantucket. Bread is homemade and everything is absolutely delicious. Order ahead and don’t forget the chocolate chip cookies.

This place has been around for decades and is still one of the bargains you can find on the island. You want to order a half sandwich not a whole sandwich. A half sandwich is the size of a normal sandwich and will cost you around 10 bucks. Delicious and fresh. It is a must do when you visit the island. I also recommend the matte fee tea.

If you don't stop by to get a sandwich and take home a loaf of bread, you haven't had a complete trip to Nantucket. The fresh baked breads are absolutely amazing. My personal favorite is the Portuguese. The sandwiches are packed full of fresh ingredients. And if you have a sweet tooth, make sure to get a cookie or slice carrot cake.

This location is amazing! The sandwiches are huge and fresh. Lots of sandwich combinations. There are picnic benches for a nice outdoor meal. The yard has a large green area for kids to run around plus a boat for them to climb and play. Will visit every time I come to the island!

They have great sandwiches, salads and soups. The sandwiches are huge so unless you are splitting a half should do it. The cookies are TO DIE FOR! Highly recommend. Call ahead and/or walk or bike during peak lunch times on beautiful beach days to speed up your wait and avoid waiting for parking.

Amazing bread and the sandwiches are huge! You can share between three little kids. The ambiance of their property is amazing and eating one of their baked goods outdoors on a nice day is an experience everyone who travels to ACK should put on their list to try! Great for a packed picnic too!!

We went there 5 minutes before they were closing. Staff was still very friendly. Prices were decent.

I had the 1/2 alfalfa, veggie and cheese sandwich on herb bread. Plenty of food and made to order. Good. The blondie was also good.

They had lots of homemade salads (chicken, past, etc) and they all great. The bread was fresh and made in house.

Great find (but extremely hard to find). Google was able to find it but zero signage and set far back from the road(not visible). It is right next to a park.

The sandwiches our group had were all amazing. As a mixed group with vegetarians, we all completely enjoyed our lunches. The half sandwich is the normal size of a whole sandwich most other places. Everything was incredibly fresh from the sprouts to the pickles. Plus, the cookies are to die for.