Island Fish Company

From start to finish our dining experiences were fabulous! When entering the hostess was always so friendly and always did her best to seat us where we wanted to be…the tables with the best views! The food was delicious, the service was top of the line, friendly, efficient and helpful! We went back 5 times within the month we were here! Yes, we were happy each and every visit!

First time trying Island Fish Company, and Kelly was an amazing server. She made our experience that much better and was very attentive, knowledgeable on the menu and gave great recommendations. We had the Caribbean Special with Grouper, rice and beans and a delicious mango salsa. It so delicious! And finished it off with a Deep Fried Key Lime Pie. This was my first time having a KL pie that was fried and it did not disappoint. Great mix of tart from the key lie with sweet from the churro style coating. Great ambiance, great food and amazing service ! We Will come back !

The food here is exceptional! I think this was the VERY best meal I’ve had during my time here in The Keys! Our server was EXTREMELY personable, kind, and friendly. My 6 ounce sirloin was cooked to perfection! The fries were really great too! This restaurant is also located right on the water in a beautiful area!

IMO, this is one of the best restaurants in the Keys, and the best in Marathon Key! First, the Grouper bisque! Nice, large chunks of grouper in the soup. Nicely seasoned. Then, the Conch Fritters; 1 inch thick, and 3 inches wide. Perfectly deep fried with no filler. This is all conch meat! Next was the Yellowtail Snapper. I had mine prepared blackened. With just the right amount of Cajun seasonings, the snapper was light, flaky (but not fall apart flaky), and moist. It came with mixed vegetables (cauliflower/broccoli) and a rice pilaf. The bread was sourdough, yet a softer crust and light and fluffy inside. So good! I have had other items as this is the third time I've visited. They offer steaks as well, burgers, etc... I have been more than satisfied with all of the food I have eaten at Island Fish Company
Highly, HIGHLY recommend making this a stop along the Keys! You will not be disappointed!

On our recent trip to the Florida Keys we stopped in here to watch the FSU game and get something to eat. The food was amazing. Our server and the bartender were amazing. And the key lime pie was out of this world.

Dan is the best bartender ! Attentive and friendly, He gave his opinion on mixing the clam chowder w the conch chowder 💣!! Shrimps we’re a lil dry for the cocktail but still delicious sauce. Dipped my crackers in them too. They have about 5 different crackers to choose from, pic for reference. Only came in for sides but the vibe was great ! You can also feed the fish outside on the dock.

Excellent water front eatery/tiki bar. Half hour wait. Limited parking. Huge bar. Good service. Excellent frued cod fish fritters

I wish I could remember our waiters name. He was wonderful! The food was delicious! And we also tossed some crackers in the water for the fish. Our waiter threw in some and got a shark to come out! He told us Blessings as we left. This was my favorite lunch spot on our vacation. ❤

They are so popular they probably don’t need my review anyway. It has great vibe, great view and the food there is just superior. Had to wait for around 30 min to get seated but definitely worth the wait. The conch fritters is a must try. The next day we drove to Key West and tried the same thing at conch republic seafood, then we realize the huge difference. Pro tips: don’t trust restaurants at tourist sites.

Stopped by this place for some after dinner drinks. The island drinks are fantastic!! Staff was very friendly and the atmosphere was perfect as we are able to sit right along the water.

Flew in to Ft. Lauderdale end of July. Drove down to vacation in Key West. I knew we were stopping to eat here. The last time I was here was in 03' I can remember the food being really good. I ordered the wahoo, which was fresh caught that morning. The whole meal and drink was top-notch. Our waiter, Sorry, I can't remember his name, was fantastic. An all around perfect experience. And as you can see from the pics, the view couldn't have been better. Wish I lived nearby, I'd probably be doing dishes to pay for all the meals I'd eat there. 😄

Came for a quick dinner tonight. Got very prompt, friendly service by the bartenders. I tried the Cajun Fried Chicken Salad. It was more than filling. The best way to describe the Chicken would be Chick-fil-A with a Cajun hint. Probably one of the better salads I’ve had. Especially the chicken being so tender. I also tried the She Crab Soup which was good, but I was a expecting a red-hint soup with shredded crab meat. It was more of a crab chowder. They have a full wrap around bar with Ocean view patio with plenty of seating. I do want to come back and try some actual seafood next time. Which I will be back. Curious to see how that would be. They have happy hour here. I would like to post much more, due to lighting it will have to wait. Marvin recommended I try the Blackened Fish Mahi Tacos. The Fire Hog Red Lager was tasty and complimented my meal well. Probably some of the better service I have had on the Island. Didn’t feel treated like a tourist or rushed. Stay tuned for more pictures:)

We loved this first stop to eat on our family vacation! We came for a later lunch and it was excellent! We ordered the seafood tower which was great (well I'm not sure about the oysters because I don't eat those). I also got a mimosa which was IMO overpriced and the shrimp tacos were just ok. We loved the atmosphere and the water just outside which made the view just gorgeous. We were glad we went on a bright sunny December day. I imagine it would be cold on rainy/windy days.
Costly for our family of 8 to eat there, but most places right now are costly (inflation). The only bad thing I can say about this place is the smell outside. It was a nasty sulfur smell that was really gross! Thankfully we didn't smell it when we were inside.
We would definitely recommend this place to anyone.

Honestly the best place my family and I are on vacation… a great spot on Florida and even when things aren’t perfect they are very close to it. Absolutely delicious food and the 2 servers we had on vacation were amazing. We had Rebecca and Ryan!

One ☝🏻 of my Favorite 🤩 places to visit in the Florida Keys! If you are in the vicinity or on your way to Key West you should stop and check this Fabulous place out. Views Amazing Food Delicious Drinks Fantastic

Fantastic place! I can't recommend it enough. We got take out one night and dined in another, and our kids wanted to go back again. We were here a couple of years ago, and it was phenomenal then as well. The staff is extremely kind and friendly, it is right on the water with a beautiful view, and the food is delicious!

Just an easygoing, fun, beautiful place. Food comes out quickly. Don't forget to say hi to the cute little friend by the parking lot. Absolutely 1000% recommend Island Fish Company, and will definitely be back on a future visit! Thank you!

Food was great, service was amazing. The views are so nice by the Keys beautiful waters. Can't wait to return.

Conch fritters are excellent, baked oysters are good but nothing special, chef salad is ok. The pelicans around are wonderful. Efficient service

The food is so good. This is an awesome place right on the water. The staff was great.

Great place to start the day. We had an amazing time enjoying our breakfast in one peacful morning. The place was nice, clean and quiet with a beautiful view of the sea.

The server was friendly and food was great as well. I highly recommend to try this place.