Fish Tales Market and Eatery

Fish Tales Market and Eatery is a laid-back gem for seafood aficionados. Nestled in a relaxed setting, it's the ideal spot to savor ocean-fresh catches without any fuss. Whether you're into a casual dine-in or grabbing a bite to-go, the menu boasts delectable choices. The cozy atmosphere invites patrons to unwind, and the outdoor seating adds a breezy touch. From succulent fish tacos to market-fresh offerings, Fish Tales exudes a chill vibe, creating a perfect haven for those craving a low-key yet flavorful seafood experience.

Wow!! Conch fritters that actually have conch (see pics),

Tables open when we arrived, service friendly and quick,

We had grouper fingers snd s Johnny sandwich (catch of the day, with tomato and cheese), good portions on everything.

I would recommend this place, even if only to atop in on the way to Key West to get teal conch fritters.

Check out the fish market, good prices, if you have a cooler.

We stopped here for lunch and what a great find! Friendly staff and delicious food. We sat outside and interacted with a lot of locals who come in to eat. Food was fresh and flavorful. Loved their conch soup and swordfish was local-caught and grilled to perfection. Would absolutely come back!

I am not much of seafood person so when I see other food options like this place offered I will make it a point to stop and try it. Very good food. The lasagna tasted from scratch and the bread was delicious. Husband tried conch for first time said it was different not a fan. And we had their key lime pie for the 1st time. Not a fan, the taste is a big thing for me. I tried it at least. More room for those who do enjoy it! Would stop in again.

Amazing! Small restaurant on #1 in Marathon. The food was so fresh and not "fishy" at all. They have an amazing selection of beef, sausages, and various kinds of seafood. The waitstaff was amazing. We figured out our waitress was from close to where my husband grew up as a child. The prices are really great. 2 dinners of and 2 beers was about 50 dollars. I had the fried shrimp with slaw and steamed green beans. He had the blackened Mahi with fries and slaw. The Mahi was flaky but moist and the shrimp were done to perfection and not dry. Both were amazing!

Food was delicious. He had one of the specials, Hogfish blacked. I had the Johnny’s salad with grilled shrimp. Service was outstanding - friendly and attentive.

Genuinely one of my favorite meals I’ve had during my visit to the keys. The pretzel was amazing and the key lime pie was the best I’ve ever had. Service was amazing. Highly suggest!!

Absolutely the best for prices, food and desserts. Plenty of parking and has seating outdoors/indoors. Staff was friendly and attentive and the menu is varied for the pickiest of eaters. Lots of daily specials too. Iced tea is fresh and tasty. Wish we would have found this spot earlier in our vacation.
They also have other freshly made items and seafood for you to prepare at home.

This place looks like a small joint but it serves deliciously seasoned fish and fries! Grilled, blackened, or fried - you will love it. The service is great, polite, and fast. We went there for a quick bite one evening and we loved everything on the plate. I highly recommend it!

ONLY A MARKET REVIEW: We purchased some fresh snapper fillets at the Duck Key farmer’s market, went back to the store to buy some grouper fillets, ended up also buying cooked, chilled, peeled shrimp, one cooked, cooled stone crab claw he cracked for me (previous experience with them at a restaurant was - they were terrible). The cocktail sauce for the shrimp, and honey mustard sauce for the claw were both wonderful. The gentleman who served us was so outgoing and helpful. He helped me find out the fish spread has cracker meal when I asked because I have a wheat allergy and can’t take chances with unknown ingredients.

My husband and I stopped here for a meal while on vacation. I ordered the blackened mahi mahi platter with new potatoes, all of which were absolutely delicious. My husband got the blackened cobia with French fries and the taste I had of his was equally yummy. I followed with my first piece of key lime pie ever. I loved the frozen nature of this pie and feel like it was a great introduction!

Unexpected pleasure! Went to the market for some fresh fish. Was met with good conversation and delicious food at the local spot. The snapper and green tomatoes was outstanding. Clam chowder had a touch of lemon that made it something incredible. Hogfish sandwich was wonderful with the mashes potatoes. So glad we stopped in looking forward to dining here again!

If you want fresh seafood this is the place to go. Asked several locals and this is where they told us to come. Food is fresh and cooked to order. The plate was full, took the pic after I had eaten some. You must try the homemade key lime pie. It was better than the one we had in Key West.

I called in an order for take-out, but the atmosphere seemed very pleasant. I will say that the service was top notch and the food was excellent. When I return next year I will absolutely return here. Don't forget the key lime pie. Homemade and absolutely the best on the keys.

Food is fresh and delicious. Had both fried shrimp and blackened mahi. Good fresh fries. Had key lime pie also. Enjoyed so much we ate here 3 times in a week!

Fresh fish and good simple food.
The interior of the place has a nice feel. A feel of old times with life.
The fish is extremely fresh.
The grouper fingers are very good. I rarely had fried fingers of groupers (though it is rather large fingers) but these are perfectly cooked with very fresh fish. It is truly delicious.
The service is nice and prompt.
A no thrill but excellent place.

Fish Tales Market and Eatery is a “must stop at restaurant” when in Marathon, Florida! I just had the best lunch!!!
I ordered, and in the blink of an eye, my food was ready! Even during the lunch rush, the service was extremely fast and on point! I ordered a cup of New England Clam Chowder which was the best I’ve ever had! I also ordered the Hogfish sandwich and the Hogfish was so fresh, also the best I have ever had! Everything from even the sandwich bun, tomato, lettuce, all so fresh and delicious! Loved the side of coleslaw , collard greens, both so delicious! This is all accompanied by a very clean restaurant, very clean restroom and a family owned business. Josh, the owner, was right there to talking to all his customers. Shawn, too! They all treat you so nice there, great customer service!
Fish Tales is definitely at the top of my list!

Excellent food and drink options. Large portions. We had the Red Snapper BLT special and Mahi Mahi blackened sandwich. New potatoes, green beans, coleslaw and red beans and rice were very, very tasty. This has been added to our ‘must visit’ restaurants. Nice diner feel. Do note that the restaurant isn’t open on Saturday and Sunday. Very friendly staff too.

Best food in the keys, service is always good and you really get that home cooked feel in the food and atmosphere. Fish tales is my happy place.

The fish and calamari were so fresh and delicious. Brian our Bartender and server was very Knowledgeable and friendly
Definitely recommend and will be back!!