Anna P. Jay | Fine Jewelry

Anna designed and crafted all of our jewelry for our wedding (wedding bands, cufflinks, earnings and a tennis bracelet).Every piece came out stunning and she was a joy to work with! Not only did she help us through our jewelry journey for the wedding, but she also consulted with our moms to design custom cufflinks, earnings, bracelets and more. We highly, highly recommend going to Anna for all things jewelry - we will be forever clients of hers!

Anna helped me find the perfect first piece of jewelry for myself - working with Anna has been phenomenal! Finding men's jewelry can be tricky but Anna helped me narrow down to the exact right piece based on my style, expected wear, and price, providing custom options to meet my interests. I very much appreciate Anna's perspective and her help answering all of my questions and recommend her to all. Anna's knowledge helped me find the right design and I very much appreciate her prompt and professional direction, making every step seamless and exciting. I look forward to my next piece with Anna!

Anna's profound gem expertise and custom tailored consultations resulted in a truly memorable and positive experience as a first-time high-end jewelry buyer. From our first conversations to delivery she took into consideration all of my requirements - from price to personal style, she was committed to finding me pieces that complemented exactly what I was looking for. Anna's mastery of all things gemology eased any reservations I had, and I am beyond thrilled by the final product - I would recommend Anna to anyone looking for the next best piece to start or add to their collection of forever keepsakes. Thank you Anna!

I cannot speak highly enough of Anna's work! Her customer service approach is second to none and the quality of Jewelry that she produces speaks for itself. I worked with Anna to design my fiancés engagement ring and she knocked it out of the park!!! It is an absolutely stunning piece.

Ring shopping is intimidating, Anna's approach to educating her clients is what sets her apart. We designed this ring 100% remotely and I could not be more pleased with how simple and informative the entire process was.

Looking forward to working with Anna on many more pieces to come!

I worked with Anna to create a customized wedding band with a personal message for my husband - it was a fantastic experience from start to finish! I had no idea how the process would work remotely and I was worried it would be difficult to accurately size his finger remotely. However, thanks to Anna's guidance and tools, it was extremely simple for us to do at home. She even handled engraving the personal message in my own handwriting! I will recommend Anna to all my friends and family and can't wait to work with her again!

Anna was amazing. Look no further for your jewelry needs. One thing that immediately drew me to Anna was her flexibility and guidance on style and design. I know the process of finding the perfect engagement ring is normally pretty stressful and difficult, but honestly with Anna's help, I felt like I immediately found the perfect ring to use to propose to my now fiancé. I provided Anna with some ideas I liked and she designed and built our ring even better than I had imagined. I couldn't be more satisfied not only from the process perspective working with Anna, but also seeing how happy it has made my fiancé has meant the world. Thank you!

I had a wonderful experience creating a custom ring with Anna. She is professional, kind and is an exceptional jeweler; everything from. her attention to detail, the gift packaging and the lovely enclosed note card are first rate.
I would recommend her without hesitation!

Anna is the BEST! From start to finish, Anna provided a personalized and fun experience, all while delivering expert advice as a certified gemologist. After discussing my tastes and preferences, Anna selected a perfect pair of rainbow sapphire and ruby huggie hoop earrings that were just what I was looking for. The earrings arrived in a beautiful giftbox with a handwritten note. I will definitely be going back for all my future jewelry needs! Thanks Anna!

I received Tahitian pearl earrings from my husband for our anniversary from Anna P. Jay and they were so beautiful! My husband said the process was great; her attentiveness during the transaction made him feel like he was the only client. She kept in communication through delivery and the pricing was extremely fair. The packaging was very elegant and I absolutely LOVE the earrings!

I could not be happier with our experience at Anna P. Jay. Anna helped us craft our dream wedding bands with her concierge ring service. The rings are stunning and are even better than we could have imagined! Anna was so kind, prompt, and professional throughout the entire process. Her streamlined approach to sizing and trialing different styles of rings remotely was perfect for us, as we are not local to the Nantucket area. Anna has our highest recommendations, and we will treasure our APJ rings for years to come!

Anna is the absolute best! She helped me design the most beautiful wedding bands for me and my fiancé. Not only does she have an eye for design, she’s knowledgeable about gemstones and was able to guide me in the selection of the perfect stones for my band. Her service is unparalleled. She took the time to have multiple calls with me to discuss the design, give me ideas, and even sent us a set of samples to try. She’s incredibly professional and super responsive. It’s comforting to be able to consult someone so trustworthy with such an important purchase. I will continue to go to her for all of my fine jewelry in the future!

I worked with Anna on the purchase of my Fiancée’s engagement ring and Anna was amazing to work with every step of the way! She took the time to educate me on what to look for, listened to my requests and hopes and delivered a perfect engagement Ring!

I would highly recommend working with Anna on any purchase and will definitely be coming back for additional jewelry purchases in the future!

Anna Jay is the best!! I've worked with other jewelers before who were not transparent, took longer than expected, and tried to upcharge me. Nothing like that with Anna - she was extremely communicative about costs and possibilities. I saw the design every step of the way and understood my options throughout the process. She made shipping my items feel safe and secure, and I received everything quicker than I expected. The final product was a stunning custom wedding band for my husband, and we couldn't be happier with the results.

Anna was fantastic to work with. We worked together remotely and she was extremely helpful every step of the way in picking an engagement ring. As intimidating as ring shopping can be, Anna took as much time as I needed to talk through all of my options. She did an amazing job sourcing diamonds and presenting me with my options, all without putting any pressure on me. It was very easy to communicate with her and she promptly answered any questions that came up as I was making my decision. Highly recommend.

Anna was great to work with - thoughtful, responsive, and enthusiastic! Her collection of items includes something for everyone, and she takes care to ensure you get exactly what you are looking for. I LOVE my necklace and truly feel like it's the perfect piece for me. I would never have picked it out myself, but with Anna's help, found something I get to wear and cherish for years to come. Cannot recommend supporting this woman-owned business enough!

Anna made a beautiful ring that i purchased and have worn daily since. Her esthetics are unmatched and she sources high quality gems. She listens and her focus is to deliver exactly what you want. She is patient and her customer service is excellent. I highly recommend you visit her website. We are working on a custom ring together and it has been a very easy process. She has a great eye and makes one of a kind pieces. Thank you Anna!

It was a delight to meet Anna at Nantucket Stroll earlier in the month. I immediately fell in love with her designs and couldn't leave the store without bringing home a new tanzanite ring.

Not only is the design beautiful, Anna's customer service was impeccable. She sized the ring at no additional cost and shipped it to me as soon as it was ready. Even with the holidays, I got it less than a week after returning home.

She was communicative throughout the entire process and I cannot wait to add future items to my collection from APJ.

Cannot recommend enough! This was the perfect Christmas gift to myself:)

I worked with Anna on my fiancée’s engagement ring and couldn’t recommend her services any more highly.

At our first meeting, I had a family heirloom and some vague ideas. Anna guided me through the creative process of repurposing the old stone in a new design, providing invaluable insights and advice along the way.

She is fun to work with, draws on a wealth of knowledge, and makes it easy to work remotely with good communication and fast and secure shipping.

The result speaks for itself — we’re both thrilled with the ring, and will turn to APJ for wedding bands and more in the future!

Anna is extremely knowledgeable and was a total joy to work with! She took some old, sentimental diamonds and reset them into two beautiful new pieces. All throughout the process she went above and beyond – sharing ideas with me, helping me create a customized piece, and being extremely patient with all of my indecision. She was also very transparent, telling me when certain designs would cost too much to make, being frank that they might not be worth it, and proposing great alternatives instead. And her prices are incredibly reasonable to boot. 100% recommend!

I discovered Anna Jay on a visit to Nantucket; everything she creates is beautiful and sparkly but perfectly dainty and just want you want for everyday wear. She was such a pleasure to work with when I had some special requests and it’s clear that she is very passionate about her customers finding exactly what they want. Anna’s work is at the top of my list for when I need to treat myself to something special and it’s very easy to get in touch with her/her studio which made the buying process even easier!