Nancy's Pizzeria

Wow, just wow! I ate here for the first time on 2/16/24 and it was so delicious!! I want to start off by saying our server Trey, made the whole experience so much better. As soon as he got to our table we were already cracking jokes and having a good laugh!

Since it was our first time, we asked Trey for any recommendations and he was quick to give us some. One of the recommendations he gave us was to try the Parmesan pesto loaded fries. They were so good! I have never tried pesto and balsamic glaze with fries before but it totally works!! I would also recommend them to new customers or to the ones who have not yet tried them.

Alright now time for the main dish and the reason why we came here, the Chicago-Style stuffed pizza. Note, this was also my first time try this style of pizza too. This pizza blew me away. It was cheesy, saucy, flavorful, crunchy and just overall amazing. In one of the pizzas we ordered beef and hot peppers. That was a must have combination. The vinegar from the hot peppers cut into the richness of the cheese…I could not stop eating it was so good!! Also I was very impressed with the crust on the pizza. It had some much flavor on its own. I will definitely be back and will also bring others to try this place out.

Super friendly. I am an Illinois transplant who has been lied to about deep dish so many times. Everywhere tries to pass off Detroit style as deep dish and that is not the same thing. This place has it right. The quickest way you can tell is the sauce is on top where it is supposed to go. Someone brings me a deep dish and i can see the mozzarella i know i was lied to. Also they have Italian beefs we got the godfather because go big or go home right. You like The Bear? You want a beef. Thats what this is. Overall give it a go especially if you are a transplant who is homesick

Amazing food and amazing service. Grew up in the Chicago land and grew up eatting Nancy original deep dish pizza pies! This is CHICAGO style pizza! Deep with lots of cheese and the best sauce! Really happy we found that there is a Nancy’s here in the Raleigh area! With the new ownership (just about 1 month) they have done a great job to make the environment customer friendly and bring back the dine in atmosphere. Our server, Trey was great and really brought a great attitude and experience to our dinner! We will definitely be back!

The manager was great! My wife and I arrived a little earlier than opening time and he saw us reading the door and unlocked it immediately and let us in and took care of us. He was prompt and very helpful and we will definitely be back. The food was spot on also, but make sure to bring an appetite 😁. And he also told us about the app and we instantly got great rewards too.

OMG, the Best Chicago style deep pizza in Raleigh! To add the salads are fresh and plenty. The restaurant is clean, the staff are super nice. Recommend Nancy's is a great place if you're in the mood for pizza and TV screens all around for sports entertainment. Great atmosphere for anyone with a appetite.

I love Chicago style deep dish pizza but haven’t been able to find a good spot. Look no further this is the place to go!! GREAT food, quick service, attentive staff, and clean restaurant! All the pizzas we ordered were delicious, the wings were flavorful and crispy. Go check them out you won’t be disappointed!!!!

This was the most awesome place!!! The new owner has really done a great job making service and quality his top priority. Every server did an amazing job to give us the best experience. They went above and beyond for us!

The food and drinks were delicious. We went on a Thursday and there was live music and the atmosphere was a vibe. So relaxed but also lively!!!

I absolutely love Nancy's Pizzeria! I've been a loyal customer for years.

The new franchise owner, Nick, has done an amazing job of taking an already incredible establishment to new heights.

The customer service and food quality have been elevated to a whole new level! The pizza and wing combo is simply unbeatable - it's the best I've ever tasted.

Without a doubt, I highly recommend Nancy's Pizzeria in Raleigh. It's a definite 10/10!

Great place to dine in, take out or have delivery until 11 p.m. A wide variety of top quality adult spirits & draft beer. Many options of pizzas that will surely please all. Really clean place that has attentive & friendly staff. New ownership & management have raised the bar to what North Raleigh peeps expects.

New management and a total change in atmosphere/vibe. Food is awesome and staff is even better. Make sure if you are looking for great food and better service to check them out.

Hands the best pizza spot for NC. Nick and his team are phenomenal. It's rare you find a restaurant that has customer service that's as mind blowing as tge food. There stuffed pizza, which is like Chicago style deep dish is the REAL DEAL!

Visited Nancy's Pizza on Thursday and had a great experience. The thin crust pizza was fantastic. What impressed me most was the service. We had fast, friendly service from everyone working that night. The pizza is pricey but they sometimes offer specials on Thursdays.

We are originally from Chicago suburbs and were excited to find a Nancy's in Raleigh! My wife and I sat at the bar and loved the stuffed pepperoni pizza! It was delicious! We had a nice chat with the owner as well as the bartender and they were really friendly. I highly recommend!

This is the best pizza I’ve ever had! As someone originally from North Carolina. My boyfriend is from Illinois and said the original stuffed pizza was very comparable to Chicago. Our server was absolutely amazing as well but I sadly didn’t catch his name! 10/10 recommend Nancy’s Pizzeria. The new management is amazing! Also can’t forget the homemade fried mozzarella. Cheese pull was amazing on both 🤪

Nancy’s Pizza 2.0 is AMAZING! Incredible staff, fantastic food and the BEST old fashioned I’ve ever had. Love the new ownership and it’s my new go to spot. Highly recommend!

My first time having Chicago style pizza and it was delicious! The restaurant is clean and the staff are very helpful. Nick was our server tonight and he was fantastic!

We enjoyed our deep dish Chicago style
pizza. Delicious sauce and cheese, and a wide variety of toppings. Friendly service and a relaxing atmosphere.

OH MY GOSH YA’LL IT’S CHICAGO STYLE!!!! I’m from IL so when our waitress delivered the pizza and it was smothered and covered in cheese and sauce, I could have fainted! I wish I got a picture of the pizza being cut and separated because the cheese was so stringy we couldn’t cleanly get it off the plate… and I was A OK with that! The sausage thin crust was very nice and tasty too, but… Chicago style stole my heart. The sauce had good flavor, the cheese was so good and the crust had flavor! Not like another place I’ve been to. Be wary though, you will need a fork and knife to eat this pizza if you come here!!!

Authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza, what's not to love? Full of flavor, and some of the best cheese pulls you'll ever see! Be warned: because of the depth of the pizza, it probably will take a while to cook. Do yourself and the restaurant a favor and order about half an hour in advance even if you plan to eat in.

This pizzeria is fabulous!! We randomly stopped in for dinner about month ago and were impressed with friendly service and absolutely smitten with the food!! We enjoyed our first Chicago-style stuffed pizza which the owner described to us and had us drooling. We also tried the boneless lemon pepper wings which were amazing! We've been talking about our experience since and finally had a chance to order again this week. My mom was visiting and has to adhere to a Gluten-free diet so we ordered a GF crust veggie pizza and a thin-crust personalized pizza for take-out and were just has happy with this order as we were with our dine-in experience. My mom said the GF pizza was probably the best she has had! My boyfriend and I strongly agree that the leftovers are just as good as the first-day fresh order! We are in love with the sauce! And the crust...well everything! Nancy's is our number choice for pizza now! And we look forward to treating friends and family to this neighborhood gem! We've lived in the area for years and feel like we've wasted so much time with other pizza places. We look forward to trying the pasta dishes next -- sure they will be just as good!! Though ordering something other than the pizza make be a hard choice!! Worth the price for every bite!!