Carl's Pizza Kitchen

So my girlfriend and I decided to check this joint out. First, let me say the owner was very friendly. Second, I ordered a large pie. Well, let me just say I was NOT expecting just how large it was. I will say the pizza was very good. But what really impressed me the most is something that pizza shops don't do anymore. When I went to pick it up, the owner opened the box to show me the pie. That tells me personally that he cares about his products that he makes and wants the customer to be happy as well. Well done sir, well done, indeed. I will definitely return and tell my friends and neighbors too. Carl's Pizza Kitchen may be small, but they serve big taste. Just to give you an idea how large it was, I placed a standard dinner plate next to it.

Review update 11/7/21
I posted the prior review 6 months earlier.
I meant to post this before, but I forgot, too. If you like white pizza, then you must check out this joint. As always, great service, great pizza, and wings among other items on Carl's menu. The second photo is a medium white pizza.

Superbowl LVII - large supreme pizza with 2 dozen wings. As always, great food made by the man Carl.

Just ordered delivery from Carl’s this afternoon and was brought here in a very timely manner. The pizza and wing portions are awesome for the price, and is some of the best local pizza I’ve had. Also if you’re a fan of blue cheese then their blue cheese that comes with the wings is to die for. Highly recommended and will definitely be ordering here again!

Awesome pizza, very cheesy! We tried meat lovers, pepperoni, and chicken bacon ranch. Will definitely be going back.

Fresh dough made daily thin Ny stlye and delicious home made blue cheese and jumbo wings as well as homemade chx fingers ,mozz stick(logs)

I don’t know how else to put it, other than they make really damn good food. Large portions, excellent taste. To give you an example, there buffalo chicken pizza is by far the best version of it, my family or friends have ever had. The calzones are HUGE and full of toppings. I could go on and on. Just know you’re getting a really high quality product, that tastes damn good, and is made by some great people, that really are passionate about what they do!

This is our favorite pizza place in Webster. If you’re looking for a delicious thin crust NY style pizza—look no further! We’ve been here several times and the pizza has been perfect every single time. I can tell the owners really care about what they do!

My father passed away recently and this was his favorite place too. We just ordered a pizza from here tonight to share and although it was weird to eat it without him, it was just as delicious as usual!

This place is legit…country sweet chicken pizza one of my favorites. Same with their garlic parm traditional wings/boneless. Good boneless wings too, not the normal cheap junk at other places. Good app’s and desert items I saw on there too. Stopped in there once, nice people who work there and their delivery drivers are very kind.

I hope to see this place thrive for a long time.

I was in Webster on business and looking for a local pizza place and went to Carl’s. Glad I did!!!! The food was amazing!!!! I ordered the cheeseburger sub, two slices of pizza, and fries. The owner was crazy nice… he was trying to fix his front door. The prices are great and the amount of food you get will satisfy the largest appetites!!! I will most definitely be back the next time I’m in Webster on business!!!! Just AWESOME!!!!

I was at Burke's having a cocktail, I went next door to order a sheet pizza for the Superbowl.... 1/2 meat and 1/2 veg....the owner was so nice and they even delivered the pizza next door to the bar for me! It was yummy!!! I was impressed and will be going back for sure!!! :)

New to the Webster area, and in searching for a new "home" place, I've found Carl's. First thing that drew attention was that they offer free delivery. Have tried a few various things from different sections of the menu, and thus far have had zero complaints. Pricing is reasonable, deliveries have always been well within time, and the staff is very nice to work with. The food is really good, especially their homemade mac & cheese!

I called to ask about last minute catering for the next day and didn’t realize they were closed on Mondays. The owner was still more than happy to go in and fulfill this order for me! Not only was I impressed by the excellent service, but the food was absolutely incredible! Every single person at the event I hosted commented on how amazing the food was. This place will definitely not disappoint, and I’d highly recommend to anyone looking to get some food catered!

Phenomenal food! Order the lobster bisque when it's available and you won't regret it. Pizza is top-notch and the crust is tasty and more than just a delivery vessel for the toppings. Carl himself is very friendly and eager to share his love good food. I've tried the 'most recommended' places in Webster and Carl's stands out in value. Bigger portions for equal if not less than what you will spend anywhere else.

My only complaint might by that the toppings seem to have gotten slightly more skimpy than when they first started out, however; the value is still above and beyond what you're gonna find elsewhere.

Keep up the good work, Carl!

Great pizza shop. Family owned, reasonable prices and amazing food. I haven't had one food item from here that I haven't disliked. Staff is always super friendly and accommodating. Always my go to pizza shop when I'm craving pizza

I order from Florida to deliver to my sister in Webster. Carl is always very accommodating and friendly, she loves the food, delicious soups and Mac and cheese. Highly recommend!
Sgtusmc

This place is by far the best value for your money. We ordered a large and it was HUGE! We had left overs for two days. You wont find nicer owners too. All around best choice in Webster, this is a must have. We ordered half white with olives and peppers and the other half crispy chicken with the country sweet sauce, done perfect! and give huge cups of blue cheese.

Purchased their large pizza along with 30 wings. We had 10 barbeque, 10 Hot and 10 medium hot wings. They were excellent! It was our first visit today, 9/1/2018, as we're new to the area. Our family members were in agreement with us.

We've had many pizzas through our 30 plus years of marriage and Carl's is one of the best. You gotta try them... Believe me. Superb!!

I ordered a sheet pizza with a bunch of different toppings, and everyone who had a slice said it was the best pizza ever!!! Great price, and they weren't stingy on the toppings. We will definitely order from Carl's again!!!

I always like to try different places for pizza aside from big chain resturants. The quality of the pizza is usually much better and Carl's is no exception to this fact. The wait was about 10-15 minutes longer than predicted, but understandibly it was a Friday night and they had their work cut out for them. The wait was worth it and I enjoyed every slice. Will be a returning customer!

We found our new favorite pizza place!!! Excellent service, menu options and quality ingredients. Love the crust, thinner than most (but not to thin), not greasy at all!

Carl's LARGE is the largest large. Carl seems to be on premise all the time and really cares about the quality of the food he is serving. Awesome blue cheese with the wings (12 count, not 10) is a generous portion and house made, not xanthan gum infused factory packaged preservative laden goop. Beans and greens is super good. Order is always ready when they say it will be, I've never had to wait when picking up an order.