Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Ordered the ham and cheese stromboli, fried pickels, two slices of cheese pizza. To drink unsweetened tea and a lemonade. The stromboli was great! The fried pickels were on point. The sauce on the slices was smooth. It was worth it. Love how attentative their customer service was.

I stopped in here for a quick bite for dinner.
Had a good chat with the owner. She very nice. She and her husband took over November 2022. I used to come here a lot in the past. However, the service and the food was lacking in many ways.
Our dinner and the service were great.
We definitely will be coming back.

Ever since they expanded, the quality/taste of the food hasn’t been the same. My server, Amber, was awesome sauce & the reason for the 5 stars. I got the chicken Alfredo dinner, the chicken Caesar salad was ok (chicken bland) & the chicken Alfredo was in the same size bowl as the salad. Normally, it’s the large bowl. Although this location is closer to me, for taste & quality, I will definitely continue to patronize the Peachtree City location. I do hope they return to their old ways because they were AWESOME!!

We come to the Fayetteville location all the time and every single time the customer service is on point…. We are literally taking a quick shopping break to have a pitcher and an app and they treat us like long lost friends! Love the food love the staff love the vibe!!! AMAZING

I used to eat at the Cheshire Bridge location twice a week when I worked in the area because it was the best Johnny's I had been to. I think that changed after eating at the Fayetteville location. I enjoyed the calzone so much that I had one on Saturday and went back for another on Sunday. The staff was also very friendly and attentive.

We stopped coming here a couple of years ago...for a number of reasons. However, we were in the area doing some business, and we were craving pizza. We ordered some garlic knots and a large Italian pizza. Britney was our server and was very pleasant and inviting. The food was phenomenal! The restaurant has been under new ownership for a little over a year now. We definitely will eat here more often.

Excellent!! Best pizza I’ve had in a very long time! I recommend the grilled chicken and tomatoes.

My servers were amazing. Paid attention and checked in at the right moments. I noticed the kitchen is clean. The pizza baker cleaned the oven after every batch he made. That attention to detail is appreciated

Love this place! Me and my girl stop by here often and the food is so good! Always fresh and the best quality in the area!

My family loves this place. The food is terrific. The staff is wonderful.. they greet us like friends and remember our order. Highly recommend!

So this is a picture of my meal from Johnny’s! I love their calzones! I knocked a star off because my “Strawberry” Cheesecake is missing the Strawberries!🤦🏽‍♀ Other than that it was a great meal.****Note*** I added extra Parmesan to my Calzone and also added Cheese to my Salad.

Food was delicious!!! Very nice and still be able to social distance while enjoying dinner with the family. The pizza was very cheesy, wings were really tasty, love the mozzarella sticks , definitely really good !

Came here for a birthday party and everything was great. The private room was perfect for our party, food and service were on point! Love their crust!

Our server Anna was very polite and efficient. Food was great and on time. We will be back!!

We had a small party of 20-25 last night. Johnny’s has been under new management for awhile now. It shows! The food was delicious. Our server , Sid went above and beyond to accommodate everyone’s needs. She was friendly, smiled, laughed and made sure we had everything in a timely manner with a great attitude. Great job Johnny’s. And a special thanks to, Sid.👍👍♥

The veggies on the pizza are fresh and never frozen. Makes the pizza taste better. If you've never had the garlic knots, you're definitely missing out!

I loved our server! She is a very bubbly black woman, I wish, I remembered her name, that gave us excellent service to our table and the others we watched her serve.

We had a great pizza, wings and a Greek salad last night from Johnnys. I forgot to take pictures before we have devoured it! Food was great!

I just ordered from DoorDash, and when I say, I was not expecting my Chef salad to look as good as it did...I usually will just do Zaxbys, but ya'll have found a new customer for life if the Salads always look like this!!😊

I wonder I if I can get grilled chicken on it next time?😅

The girl who served us was very nice, I'm sorry I didn't see her name recorded, good atmosphere, good service, and she smiled at everything, the excellent pizza!!! just like I love it!!!