Bentino's Pizza

I pride myself on being a pizza expert and I must say Bentino’s is a solid option that is not to be disrespected. Craftsmanship ship was underwhelming but still a quality pie. Well above you average small town pizza spot. Flop was strong and crust wasn’t as crispy as preferred but the cheese and sauce was flawless.

Great pizza! Overall very good experience. Thank you

Bentino’s Pizza is great! We like the “Meat Madness Pizza “ but also enjoy the “Deluxe.”
The service is always quick and the folks working there are always friendly. Sometimes we order and pickup and sometimes we eat there. Either way, it’s all good!

This place has the best Pizza and Calzones around. It’s always our go to!!

Went for the first time this week! Food was sooo good we went back for lunch a couple days later! Pizza was delicious and my daughter loves there spaghetti and meatballs!

Called ahead and ordered my pizza. When I entered, I was asked if I had called in a pizza. Was seated immediately and pizza was served right up. Great pie. Recommend to all!

Wow! We do alot of travel and when out and about we always try one of two options, pizza or chili dogs, and today it was pizza from here. And I can say we love when we stumble upon great pizza like this. Had the calzone and the toppings are premium, cheese has amazing stretch and that cheese tooth feel. But the show stopper was the crust and sauce. Crust was light but from, good crunch with butter and garlic on it. Sauce slightly sweet, mid acidic but great flavor through the bite
Highly recommend this place if you want a great pizza or calzone.

After a bike ride on the trail, we were thinking a pizza sounded good and we found Bentino's. We were not disappointed. We ordered a large sausage and cheese pizza which was absolutely delicious. We had leftovers for dinner tonight. It's not real fancy of a place but that didn't really matter aa long as it was clean and it was. Pricing was very reasonable as well. I would definitely recommend it.

Great food pizza was really really good. Tastes like someone knows what pizza should be and taste like. Service was great no wait. Give them a try. If you are a pizza fan. Then you won't be disappointed.

First visit and really enjoyed. Hard to say best pizza when there are so many styles alway up to great specialty pizza being done in the area.

But I can saw this pizza was pretty good had a sweet red sauce.

I really enjoyed the house sauces and the garlic knots I prefer garlic butter and wet garlic knots to dry seasoned but the dough was so good and they were great!

Also originally enjoy the location and building all and all I enjoyed it and will be back!

Hot and delicious pizza! 🍕. I ordered today as a business associate highly recommended, and I was so pleased. I ordered 6 different large pizzas and all of them were timed perfectly and ready when promised. The atmosphere inside is quaint and inviting. Nice little place to stop and grab a bite to eat while shopping in downtown Waynesville.

Considering the area it is in, I will say , I had a good experience. Service was good not much time taken for delivering the Pizza to our table.

Had out of town guests. Met at Waynesville for lunch. The teenager in the group wanted pizza. The pizza was delicious. We all ordered salads. Very fresh and delicious. Food served quickly. Owner and staff very friendly. Clean facility. Clean bathrooms. Had a very enjoyable experience.

First time trying and it's good pizza. Not from the area so we've never had it but it would be a regular for us if we did. Jewel was great!!

Great pizza tonight 🍕 😋. Love supporting my town.

Love Gus and the staff. . They make their sauce and dough. They have fresh mushrooms (not canned). No anchovies. The pasta is good too. Gus runs restaurant well. Definitely one of my favorite restaurants ever

Let's start with the beer was the cleanest, coldest, crisp beer I have had. Idk who is cleaning their lines or how often they clean the lines but big ups to you guys. Pizza was good as well if I had to nitpick one thing the pizza was very greasy. With that being said I personally enjoyed the pizza very much.

We ordered 2 medium pizzas for $30. One was the three meat special, with pepperoni, sausage and bacon. The other was a Greek feta blend of toppings. Both were great. The crust is very unique and delicious. I would definitely order from them again.

This has been an absolute favorite of mine since I was in elementary school and my grandma and momma would order me their calzones and pizza all the time! Always kept a very friendly staff and actually for quite a while at least 4 or 5 of my close family members worked here and they loved it ! My favorite Waynesville restaurant ❤

I've been fortunate enough to eat at quite a few places in Ohio. The pizza they make here is but far one of the best. The service time is quick and orderly, the drinks are unlimited, and the management and employees are all extremely kind and helpful. If you're thinking about a place to get pizza, this is definitely a place I highly recommend.