Jonathan's Pizza and Wings

You won't find another small town pizza place like this one! Love the big city pizza in our little town.. and now that they added a salad bar stocked full of fresh veggies, we will be eating here even more. Love them and the atmosphere!!

Just discovered this place last week. I haven't had the pizza yet, but I've ordered their wings twice already for delivery and they were so so dang good! I'm pretty picky about wings but these were hot, fresh, and super crispy even after having to wait for delivery (only took about 20-30 min). Everything is packaged so neatly and they don't just throw your food in the box. They even gave me extra ranch without me asking. The only thing I would say is I do like a little more sauce on my wings which I'm sure they would do if I ask next time. The banana pudding is also delicious! Definitely a must try. Whoever answers the phone is super polite and helpful. I had the same delivery guy both times and he was very nice as well. As long as I live in this area, I'll be definitely getting my wings from them!

Order garlic Parmesan wings and a meat lovers pizza, the wings was out of this world good. They was crunchy, juicy very delicious and the pizza was good nice thin crust with a crunchy and it was delicious. Would be going back!! Thank you

It was my first time eating there and I was impressed. Our waitress was incredibly kind and patient with our table. A friend of mine was feeding her baby, which took a while, when the food came, once she was done feeding him our waitress came and asked if my friend would like her pizza warmed up.
The pizza was good, the slices are huge! I also had a side salad which was pretty good. They have good ranch!
My husband had wings and fries, I also stole a few fries and they were so good.
My husband also liked the wings that he received.
The prices were great!
Great food, great prices and most importantly (in my opinion) a great staff!

Wow!!!! I had my share of pizza in Nashville and this rivals any of them!
Good size for the prize. Good quality. Crunchy and doughy crust, great cheese and sauce ratio. Mama Mia, next time I'm in the area I'm ordering again.

The hole in the wall joints are always the best! Our waitress was kind and attentive! We enjoyed our food and it was a great value for the price! Small, quaint environment.Their pancakes are HUGE! Looking forward to coming back for dinner! My sons loved the games they had on the tables. They played while our food was being prepared. 😃

Pizza is HUGE! And taste really good! My kids and I loved it and will definitely be back for more and the garlic Parmesan wings are a must! They have so much flavor and they smell great too. I love the way it looks and feels inside too it’s like a comfy homey place. Workers are all great and the owner is the sweetest I really enjoyed meeting her and talking to her she is down to earth and cares about her business and her employees! Jonathan’s Pizza is definitely a must try restaurant!

Great family friendly restaurant. A must try. Service and food is impeccable! Thank you Carmen and Derek!

Love to support this place. Their cheeseburgers are yummy goodness and I look forward to having one. They have really good fried chicken and their BBQ is on point. You will not be disappointed if you check them out. Don't forget dessert. ♥

While I loved Jonathan’s before now not so much. The wings are ok. Not great jus ok and over priced. The pizza is also ok. I do not like the crust at all. I’m going to give them a bit to work the kinks out and I will give them another try. Brooklyns pizza is my all time favorite so since they are in the NY pizza category with them this is what I am comparing them to. I also think they should delete all reviews from Jonathan’s Cafe and start new with the pizza pizza.

Update: We have it a second shot and it was so much better! We ordered a large pepperoni and it was good. I am so happy we decided to try it again.

This place is great. Carmen and her staff treat you like family. It shows in the cooking. It's like coming home.

I've been here for breakfast and lunch and had a great experience each time. The waitress was very nice and the food was out in a timely manner. More importantly, the food was delicious! Please come out and support this new small business so they can be around in the years to come!

Pizza is amazing and wings are great as well! My kids loved it and they are picky on pizza so that’s a huge win! And the size of the pizza is great I have a family of 8 and 2 pizzas will feed us.

PERFECTION! Don't change anything about this pizza! Love it!

When they say large they mean LARGE... These pizzas are big enough for several people.

I first came to Jonathan’s Cafe after seeing their signs close to my home in Wade / Stedman area. It’s a small nook and cranny venue but all I can say is wow. The food is some of the best I have ever tasted. And trust me. I’m super picky.

The owner Carmen is super kind and very accommodating and her staff always work to make sure that your taken care of. I’ve been singing their accolades and sharing on social media to help build her following. It’s off the beaten path but well worth the trip. Even if your in Fayetteville You wanna give this place a try. You won’t be disappointed.

Always proud and happy to support quality small businesses. Jonathan’s Cafe is the place to be.

Favorite dishes. Chicken and Pastries (Thursday’s)
And Pork Chops (All day every day).
Don’t forget the Hobo Stew. You’ll be sleep in your car. For sure lol. Delicious.

Deli

Best strawberry shortcake ever! I'll keep coming back just for these amazing dessert specials! Definitely a recommend place to visit if your looking for an amazing home cooked meal. 👌

Been twice now just looking for something new and different. I was pleased the staff was friendly and the food was good. My to-go order came out in a timely manner. Looking forward to trying out their breakfast.

The food is always on point and the staff is super friendly. The owner is usually there and you can tell the love she puts into her business. The doughnuts.... heavenly!

The pepperoni and cheese pizza was amazing. Hot and cheesy. The staff was friendly. Service was excellent