New York Pizzeria

A nice visit in a small town. Right up the road from Taughannock Falls and worth the short trip. Cool sodas and lemonades in the cooler. Extra large cheese (pictured) was $18 today. We ate in and it was a very pleasant experience. Lots of slice options readily available if that's what you're looking for. Thanks for having us.

While visiting Garrett's Brewing next door, we ordered pizza from New York Pizzeria. The service was excellent and the pie was DELICIOUS!! Although busy, it was totally worth the wait to taste authentic NYC pizza. Highly recommended!!

I am from NYC and frequently lament the lack of decent pizza available in The Finger Lakes. I was so happy when I found this place. It is the closest I have come to real pizza in six years. I ony wish I lived closer, I'd be here all the time. Thank you!!!

If you are in Trumansburg and want pizza, this is the place to go. So delicious, other pizza doesn't really compare! Thin crust with quality sauce and cheese. Amazing selection of pizzas by the slice at lunch time, with only a couple available slice options at dinner time. Whole pizzas made to order anytime. My go-to combos are sausage, peppers and onions, or feta, tomato and onion... although you can never go wrong with just cheese! Eat in, or take it to go. There are benches out front if it's a nice day. And, a stone table and bench at the children's village is just up the block, which is a great option if you have little ones.

I have eaten pizza all over the country, and this place has the best and most consistently delicious pizza of any place by far!

This place is super fresh crispy crust delicious pizza every time I have been here. A must visit for any pizza lover!

Honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had. Options are limited to what is made up already unless you order a whole new pizza. But there were plenty of delicious options. Fun atmosphere and delicious especially if you’ve never had authentic New York Pizza. My husband and I enjoyed the option of Italian sodas from the cooler.

First of all I usually have ranch with my pizza and they didn’t have any BUT I did not need it at all! This pizza is amazing! The sauce, the cheese and the dough is the whole package!! My husband keeps saying how great it is and yes I’m writing this review as we are eating it!

Better than some of the pizza I get in Brooklyn. This is truly a jem in this town. We grabbed some slices and went next door to the brewery which is also amazing

Love their pizza...It's the best in the Fingerlakes! Try it once and you'll agree 😁

If you ever have the chance, you need to go get some pizza here. I live in NYC and this is the best pizza I’ve ever had. The crust is flawless throughout the slice. The ratios of ingredients are perfect. It’s just quality pizza that’s made by Fabrizio, a man from Sicily who sure knows what he’s doing. The guy makes all the pizza! The rest of the guys are really hospitable and make you feel at home too.

Best Pizza in town !!!! Super friendly owner and staff definitely recommend!!!

It has been awhile since I've had good pizza. That's one thing the south can't make, good pizza 😊

Great pizza!! I make a trip to Ithaca once e every few months and always stop here.

This is hands down the best pizza in Trumansburg. The ingredients are so fresh and delicious. And the crust has great crisp. I'm normally the type of guy who doesn't like to just grab a slice and go, but the slices here are so filling that I make an exception.

Solid New York style pizza. Cool little spot.

Best pizza in upstate for sure and the Guys that own it are from Italy and super awesome. Delicious delicious delicious. They are not open Sunday and Monday, which is sad for the world, but everyone deserves a couple days off every week!

Okay first off call ahead because the hours on the door do not always reflect reality. Second, they're closed two days a week and stop taking orders around 8:30. Third, customer service can sometimes fall a bit flat. Not rude, but not customer-centric. None of that matters because these guys have damn fine pizza. You'll have to drive six hours into NYC to find better and even that could be debatable. Try these guys!

On my way back from Ithaca when I found this on the web. When I called I spoke to a friendly person, who said they could make me a pie or that they had slices available. Arrived 5 minutes later. Friendly staff, great pizza and a pleasant environment.

Consistently the best pizza I've had in the Ithaca area. Easy 10 minute drive to Taughannock Falls, so get take out and enjoy your delicious dinner on the lake shore.