Scotty's On Sheridan

Wonderful meal from start to finish. Adam is a great server. Attentive friendly and made great recommendations. Greek salad is chopped perfectly. Love the warm rolls. Salmon was cooked perfectly. Huge piece. Moist and flavorful. Must try. The chicken piccata special and fresh spinach were very delicious. Desserts of apple pie and ice cream and coconut cake topped off the meal. The lemon drop and Cosmo were cold and delicious. Perfectly made.

Our meal from start to finish was amazing! Friendly staff too! We had the Francisco's Salmon and Lindsay's Filet entrees, both so good! Dessert yummy, the tiramisu and Door County cherry pie, don't pass on that! Will definitely recommend and return to Scotty's!

I love sitting in the cozy bar for dinner. Food and service are exceptional.

Really really good! The wait can be long but it's worth it! Warm bread is served. The mashed potatoes exceeded my expectations!

Food is Maverlous. Wait staff very friendly and attention oriented. Owner is always checking on his quests at least 2 times during your visit, and thanks you personally when you leave.

First timer loved the whitefish & tasted the chicken Milanese, was all very delicious.
Coming back , YES

Our dining experience was superb. We were greeted with a welcoming and inviting atmosphere. We ordered calamari, the linguine with shrimp, salmon and a few cocktails, everything was delicious. The staff was attentive and polite. Met and exceeded our expectations of a high class restaurant. We highly recommend and will definitely be back.

Had a fantastic dinner with my wife. Best meal that I had in a year. Very good selection, creativity conceived, and cooked perfectly. Our service was excellent despite a notice that they were still under staffed.

Went there to celebrate my birthday and couldn't be happier. Food was delicious and seevice was amazing.

Great food, great stand, great atmosphere

Three of us had the wedge salad and it was classic/perfect with bacon, tomatoes and a tasty blue cheese dressing. Ribs were spectacular. The Mediterranean salad bowl with the salmon and also the salmon entree were both excellent. Great drinks and California sauvignon blanc. We got to meet Scotty who served us and did an excellent job. Great place and we'll be back

Celebrated my birthday here and could not have been more satisfied.
The service was impeccable. The drinks were generous and wine list extensive. The Feta & Tomato Crostini was the perfect blend of feta cheese, tomatoes, garlic, basil, pine nuts, balsamic glaze. The mussels were tender and flavorful. After dipping the warm dinner rolls in the broth from the mussels I was afraid I wouldn't have room for dinner but I soldiered on. I had the beet salad and enjoyed it very much but couldn't stop looking at my husbands wedge salad and my sons Pear salad.
I had the scallops and for the first time in a long time I didn't get a sandy one in the bunch. They were cooked to perfection, warm and creamy with a beautiful sear. The scallops came with another arugula salad so I had my greens for the week. At the table we also had the Idaho Trout which was declared the best my husband has ever had. The Meatballs and White Beans were a big hit and the New York Strip was deemed great. I was served a complimentary huge slice of coconut cake which was moist and enough for two. The others shared flan and chocolate cake. Much was enjoyed by all.

Warm and inviting atmosphere. Friendly and attentive service. Good wine selection and an excellent American menu with vegetarian options. Great place for families and gatherings with a few friends. Don't miss this spot if you're in the area.

We had a wonderful dinner here. It was very busy on the Sunday night we went and our poor server had to take care of all the tables but he did an amazing job. He never lost his composure and remained cheerful the entire night. The food was very good. We all tried something different and everyone was happy. I would highly recommend this place and will be going back soon!

Excellent evening! We made reservations after visiting the holiday lights at Chicago Botanical Gardens. Our party of 6 were very happy with our meals! We were especially grateful for the awesome service! Another great thing was we could actually hear each other talk! I was thrilled to meet Scotty on my way out!

What wonderful service!! We ordered tonight from DoorDash and when an item was missing and they couldn’t contact the driver or us, Scotty’s brought it to my home themselves and added a dessert!! Food is delicious and again, spectacular service! Thank you we’ll keep coming back-especially for the bacon avocado crostini-we love it!!!

I haven’t been into the restaurant but they used to be on UberEats and that’s how I’ve tried the food. Everything we’ve gotten in delicious. The best steak I’ve found since moving here. The Avocado and Bacon Crostini is awesome. My husband and kids have tried several desserts and love them all. They’re available for delivery on GrubHub currently but I don’t believe the full menu can be ordered. Highly recommend.

Service was amazing they made sure we had everything we needed and were on top of everything. Food was great as well. We really enjoyed our meal!

I’d definitely go again- good food and exceptional staff. Mediterranean bowl was not what I expected, but pretty darn good!

Outstanding service, quality food that was presented very well, nice atmosphere and bottles of wine were priced better than many restaurants. I had the shrimp de jonghe and chicken milanese- both great. My woman gets filet mignon at all the best places and she said this was amongst the best ones she has had.