Pico Tequila Grill - Bay Shore

Went here for taco Tuesday deal and the tacos were legit crazy good. Might make it a tradition to just go there Tuesdays when I'm hungry with the boys. Place has a nice selection of beer as well and the flavor profiles were crazy nice. Outside scene was very nice and the inside was cozy. Very enjoyable experience that's well suited for parties of about 5 or less.

The pico burrito and the bang bang tacos do not disappoint. I’ve come here several times and I always get the same ones because they’re just so good that I can not pass up. Staff is also very friendly

Services was very good. I enjoyed the food as well tasty.

My first time there and I will be back. Staff is so friendly. Food was great and drinks too.

Everything was great! Fried ice cream is a must.

So many gluten free options, friendly staff, and very delicious food make this a new favorite spot for the husband and I. Check out how they plated those nachos!

Great food, good customer service. Was my first and I'll definitely go back again.

Absolutely delicious food at a great price the service was also excellent

One of my favorite spots in Bayshore. The food is so good and cheap. I always feel like I want to try everything from their menu. I’ve had different types of tacos, nachos, and burritos and I’m never disappointed. The drinks are also good. Always crowded but that’s because the food is good so it’s worth the wait. The staff is very nice and friendly. Highly recommended this place!!

This place is absolutely amazing. The food is incredible, the staff is attentive and extremely friendly! I have been coming here about once every two weeks (sometimes once a week) since it opened! I have never had a bad experience. When my family and I come in we always feel so welcome by the staff, even my 2 year old (who has been coming here since she's a newborn) knows the staff! The waitstaff are a gem!

The food is delicious. Since we've been here so much, we literally have had everything on the menu. NOTHING has ever disappointed us! If you are reading this, thinking whether you should come eat here, don't pay attention to the one star reviews...GO! you will have a new favorite spot!

The bang bang shrimp and street tacos were delish and filling. The location isn't huge but it is a nice space with high stools or regular tables. The jalapeño & piña margaritas were tasty and strong, presented in mason jars, you get your money's worth.

The alcohol wasn't too expensive. And the dinner was definitely delicious. They actually have authentic Mexicans cooking their food. Which is what I love the most. So gd a must try. And it's around tons of other bars and restaurants..

My daughter took me to Pico for my birthday a year and a half ago and I loved it. I've been back at least 4 more times since including January 1st 2016 and today, January 9th. I love the tacos...especially the bang bang taco. Each time I've gone there I loved it as much as the first time. Great, consistent and fresh food. And love the margaritas too. It is by far my favorite place in Bay Shore to eat. The wait staff is friendly too. Today I had Krystal and she was great. Keep up the good work.

Absolutely amazing food. Only got take out from door dash but we’re looking forward to coming in to try it in the restaurant. Lots of options for me since I’m a vegetarian and my husband and friends rave about everything in the menu. Way better than the other local taco/Mexican places. Fresh and tasty. Plus, they had a Brussels sprout side that’s phenomenal!!!!!! Anytime a restaurant offers an exciting, different vegetable- I’m happy. And it is a creative take on brussel sprouts. I’m looking forward to trying other things on the menu!!! Only ordered three times- I have a whole meal waiting for me in the fridge and looking forward to ordering again haha

Wanted to try something new so we gave this place a shot. It was absolutely delicious! The nachos are a must have! Huge portion even for a to-go order. We also got the steak fajita and steak quesadilla. Food was ready for pick up in 15mins. Everything was really good! Definitely coming here again.

THE BEST MARGARITAS EVER! I don't even like tequila but the Pico Margarita is a game changer! I've been to Pico tons of times, taken family and friends and no one has ever gotten a bad meal or a bad drink!! Service is always a pleasure too! If you're in Bay Shore, definitely stop here!!

This place has done justice to the former standout food location. It was the birthplace of Smoking Al's. Now this next generation boasts.outstanding food at reasonable prices. Where else can you get Tequila on Tap?

First time here, awesome atmosphere, love the decorations, and the drinks are fantastic! I never knew a tequila menu could be so big! The music was loud enough to hear, but not overpowering so I could have a conversation with the others at my table. I ordered chicken empanadas, came with two. One was chicken and the other was beef. I didn't bring it up with my waitress because I almost couldn't choose between chicken or beef, but both were fantastic. I don't know what the beef was seasoned with but it's amazing. Also ordered a side of the warm cheese and sour cream that I didn't receive either, but thats okay because the empanadas were very big and full of flavor. I was charged for it on the check. Paid it anyway. Not worth it to argue over $3.

Server was so pleasant and very enthusiastic about the menu! Really helped to make excellent recommendations and the food was awesome! The Brussel Sprouts are insane. And by far, the best margarita around, and I am very picky!!

Birthday lunch with my wife and sister in law. Everything I ate was good. Loaded nachos with fresh guac for appetizer. I also recommend the bang bang shrimp. And the surf and turf burrito was very filling.