The Cortland

Cute, little dive bar! Loved the vibes & the bartenders were great. On Mondays they have karaoke after 9:30pm too.

You know that pub that never fails, that pub that always greets you with a smile that comes from the heart rather than the intention of taking your money, that pub that watches your back if you come in alone, that pub that stands up for female comfort and security during a night out, that pub that leaves you with dream like memorable moments when your week has been nothing but a nightmare. Well, to put it simply, this is that pub.

Joe and Nora are the best! Friendly, attentive and fast.
Great atmosphere. I felt like I was walking into a bar version of that 70s show. Definitely a place I'd bring out-of-town visitors

Will return without a doubt!

Spiked hot cocoa was excellent. Fair prices for sure. Limited seating, but the vibe from the homey feel of the place is great. Bartenders were both very nice. Recommended.

Amazing atmosphere, incredibly friendly staff, tasty drinks, and the names of the cocktails were fantastic! Highly recommend for alternative or even music fans in general.

Literally the only bar I go to on Long Island. Ask for Kristin-she is nice but the men are mega hot if you're into eye candy. She's sexy too if you perfer females.

Would give this 6 stars if possible.

Just redid the place, looks awesome. Bingo nights on Wednesdays are awesome. Not as crowded as some places which is good. Always serving great beer and Frank is the man

Good local beer selection. Drinks are good, not too pricy. Cool ambiance and very 'Divey' in a good sense. Cool art work on the walls.

Nice little bar, it's been updated for a more modern look. Good selection of taps and cocktails.

My favorite hipster bar. Phenomenal beer selection. Friendly staff.

I came here with a lady friend for drinks. It was a clean place with a good beer selection.

Awesome environment. Chill vibes. Great Drinks.

Consistently great service at this place. May be too hipstery for some, but definitely not pretentious.

Damn good beer been going for years. Small but cozy

Awesome bartenders are great drink selections are supreme

Great bar to hang out with your friends in the wonderful community area

Super cozy bar with fantastic infusions and great staff.

Great place they have nice interior design and food.

Quaint hipster bar with great personality and unique drinks.

Real Bay Shore gem. Local NY brews and great mixed drinks.