The Pizzeria of Bay Shore

THE EPITOME OF DELICIOUS! 😋 Took me back to Italy, the pizza is SPOT ON. Wow. I couldn’t think of anything else while inhaling my slices except how happy I was. Atmosphere is excellent. Place was very busy but very efficient and friendly. Lots of people coming in for lunch and roomy for everyone to stay. My first time trying them, they’re going on my food map, would 10/10 buy again.

We bought the pizza kit for the St. Patrick’s school fundraiser. Had a blast making the 2 pizzas and eating them too! Instructions were easy to follow. Will definitely participate again!

Truly an upscale experience for pizza. The food is absolutely delicious and the atmosphere is lively and tastefully decorated. Our waiter was very helpful and attentive. We will definitely be back to try more options on the menu.

Possibly one of the best pizzerias we have on long island hands down. The staff was friendly and helpful. I recommend this pizzeria if your looking for something good.

I wanted a chicken parm hero for lunch and was told to go here, and boy am I glad that I did. I was immediately greeted by the very friendly Cassie! She took my order, and 10 minutes later out it came. It was big enough for two meals! Thank you!

Great location. Very clean spacious modern restaurant. Authentic pizza with modern twist. Good value. Service could be more customer friendly.

Great pizzeria! Big portions and wonderful service. Rolled away happy!

The pizza was excellent here the place is also very nice, clean, and the bathrooms are very elegant for a "Pizzeria" grear atmosphere friendly staff. Highly recommend wish they had a location closer to my home.

Great place overall! The food was top notch, definitely would recommend this to anyone looking for a saturday night out with family or friends. I enjoyed the pizza and pasta they offered and was very full by the end. Splendid

The pizzeria is like our second home.
The staff, food, atmosphere… everything is outstanding.
We come here more than once a week. We may be addicted. Uncle Benny and Trifecta 4 Life!!!

In the winter, the crowd at the bar is welcoming and the bartenders are always so personable.
In the summer, they have live music and an awesome outdoor area to enjoy.

They also run specials each week (buy one get one pizza Mondays and buy one get one pasta Wednesdays). They are also great supporters of local law enforcement! We are proud to have this amazing family and business in our neighborhood!
Thank you for everything Pizzeria of Bay Shore!

Shout out to all the staff: Cassie, Max, Hilary and all of the amazing crew. We love you guys!

This is my family’s favorite place to come after church and eat. The foods so good and fresh. Good pizza and good dishes! Super friendly staff!

Sat in outside area tonight so our pup could join us. We all say thumbs/paws up YUMMY! 😋 🐶

O.M.G... my Bay Shore neighbors!! We have found GOLD!!! We do not have any good pizza on this side of Main Street but this gem right here is IT!! Service was wonderful, the pizza delish and one of the nicest looking bars in the neighborhood. Will def be back for happy hour! Only bad thing is they are walking distance from my home and there goes that weight control.. UGH!! Must try, must support our local business! 5 stars all around.. I'm too excited for this place. Excellent location for those headed to the ferry! Stop! Have a slice and a drink and enjoy the rest of your day!!

I had a great time here
My friend and family always say good things about this place.

One “small” (pun intended) issue, but not enough to take any stars away because the pizza is that good! I’ve had delivery and picked up a bunch of times and the service has always been top notch. Regular, specialty slices, rice balls, and wraps are all amazing! Ordered the garlic knots tonight and was kinda shocked at the size! My 3 year old asked if he can have a peanut 😂 Maybe add another knot? Looking forward to my next order!

Place is amazing! All around it’s a great place to go and enjoy some good food and drinks with family and friends. Every time I’m in town to visit that’s a spot I must go to before I fly back home to California. If you want som good pizza and a great atmosphere, The Pizzeria of Bay Shore is the spot!

Delicious food, trendy cool vibe, amazing rose sangria, hip music!
Maxine, Cass and Olivia were our servers/ bartenders. HIGHLY recommend the pizza, pasta, chicken parm, and pesto chicken. Can't wait for them to open in Babylon ! 😊

The pizza was delicious and they had amazing selections to choose from. My favorite was the meatball burrata and then the Chicago pepperoni paired with an espresso Martin! The vibe is great. A great place to meet with friends. Pizza, coffee and drinks. What else could you ask for!?

Truly one of if not the best pizza spots on the island. The food is consistently amazing . It’s always busy but they manage to remember everyone with a family vibe, Kyle and the staff remembers us by name every time. Went to pick up our family order, they had all the games on and the charismatic bar tender Brandon had me sitting down enjoying a drink in no time while I waited for our food. Great prices great people
Can’t say enough, love supporting our pizza family. Customers for life.

My dad and I were looking for a new dinner spot and came across this place. Our server Liz was extremely friendly and attentive. Everything came out perfectly and the food was delicious. For sure will be back.